User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
I'll add my two cents to this discussion. We (Omaha) have been abused by excessive running as well. I would agree that our Run D needs some work, but the exploits (or whatever we're calling them) are getting excessive. Richey Royals spanked us using a balanced approach so I know teams can be successful using both run and pass.

The last 3 opposing offenses against us:
HIB - 74 rushes and 2 passes (97% run)
SDFL - 63 rushes and 12 passes (84% run)
Waller - 66 rushes and 15 passes (81% run)

Similar to Cav, I'm not calling any of the above 3 teams cheaters or taking advantage of the SIM. Hell, they beat us using the same capability I have access to so shame on me. My point is if Bort has any desire to make GLB somewhat realistic it should be more than a few formations and running plays.

Now, I'll get back to my OAI gameplanning of 90%+ rushing the rest of this season and expecting all remaining opponents to do the same...
 
jebby69
offline
Link
 
I am the OC for Chicago and agree that running it 90 times in a game is not very exiting. I also own the QB and WR for Chicago and basically paid $18 this season for guys I cant really use. I would love to stay balanced and actually prefer passing a little more than running, but the way the passing game is this season we would just lose most games. In an attempt to figure out what is wrong with our passing game I have looked at many teams in different leagues. While, most have not gone as drastic as I did today, ALMOST every team is passing significantly more this season than last. You dont see many successful teams that throw it up 50 times a game anymore (which was a norm last season). I am very impressed that the Fins can continue their dominance with the air assault.

I did not intend to get that many carries against the Bomb Squad, but several things happened that caused exaggerated the situation. First, the punter from the Bomb Squad did a phenomenal job. He pinned us inside our 5 yard line on multiple occasions. They also had a INT and kickoff returned for a TD's that just placed our offense back on the field for more plays. That said our tactics were still set to heavily favor running because that is about all that works somewhat for us this season.

Early this season we attempted to stay balanced and it cost us games. Last season the passing game was overpowered in my opinion and WR could catch almost anything thrown their way. Bort has either improved CB's coverage or hurt WR's because our passing attack that went for 5000 yards and almost 50 TD's has been rendered pretty much useless. In games this season where we attempted to stay balanced we had under 50% completion and twice as many INT's as TD's. We cannot expect to even be competitive with these kind of numbers. I have been using any scrimmage we schedule to try to find any openings that will allow us to open up the passing game.

Our team was initially created on the power running smash-mouth style of offense. We were heavily invested in strength and took our lumps when the speed rushers dominated and running wasn't as effective. It appears to me that this season bort has made strength a much more viable stat, at least on the offensive and defensive lines. Just look at the pancake numbers across leagues, they are up significantly everywhere. I agree, in real life a power pack shouldn't be able to run defenders over relentlessly and especially after receiving a certain amount of carries, he should just run out of gas and be unusable. This would still not stop the top teams from getting 3-4 backs and just rotating when one was worn down.

I think this game has put defenses at a significant disadvantage. They must be built to stop guys that have high (100+) speed/agility AND high STR/CAR. Guys on offense specialize and create a significant gap in a particular stat category that just makes them dominant and guys on defense cant specialize because they do not have the ability to switch based on the personnel package the offense throws on the field. You cant keep up with the fast guy if you want to be able to tackle the strong guy. IRL when teams would substitute a bowling ball at HB the defense would react with a package to stop it, in GLB you cant. Should a 50+ difference in strength make a guy so powerful, that I dont know. What I do know is that it is a tricky problem to fix, because the problem will just move to another area when this one is nerfed.

A few seasons ago alot of people saw the success of the speed rushers and marched down the path of creating their own. We have a couple of DE that modeled themselves after Julius Dee the great speed rushing DE of the Golfers that totally destroyed teams in his prime. At the time we were frustrated that our strength built linemen couldn't wear guys like this down and eventually when we went back to pass he was going to get his stats. We spent countless hours trying to determine what stats he was using to become so successful and tried to tailor our guys to become like him. We also had to refocus our linemen to be able to block this type of guy. It was apparent that season we weren't going to just be able to maul people, WE needed to adjust. The problem is the later in a players career you get, the less skill points there are to adjust. That is the problem with changes each season intended to bring certain builds back to the "norm". I would have been content trying to react to be able to block these speed guys and create some of our own, but bort took it into his own hands and for the most part rendered most speed rushers irrelevant. IMHO, a heavily invested speed rushing DE should have about as much success against an average built OT as power back currently have. A 50+ advantage in a skill is significant and should matter. This is the one place the defense could have an advantage, but with the o-line pathing, most DE just cant reliably get around the corner.

Everyone seems to use NFL stats to compare to and strive for as a norm in GLB. This is not the NFL, there will be great built players and shitty ones on the same field. What one guy might be specifically built for could exploit one team but be completely useless against another.

I agree with cavalier that I have pretty much chalked this season up to a big waste of time. Each season bort makes changes intended to improve the game as a whole, but with the diverse universe of player builds it inevitably screws things up somewhere. This season it just seems to be affecting almost everyone. I hope he figures something out and fixes this game before he loses alot of frustrated, dedicated players.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Yea, i think bort has made things worse the past couple seasons trying to adjust and fix things. The more he messes with it the weirder it gets. QB completion % is up a lot, but so are PDs to the point where most every incompletion is a PD. The RBs fall forward for 3 yards after gaining 1 pretty much every time due to lack of dline penetration on run and some strange combination of falling foward and diving in conjunction with a VA or SA making it a bit unrealistic. You can get 3 yards rushing pretty much every play. 3 yards times 4 downs is gonna get you a first down almost every time, albeit slowly. Hopefully, things are more interesting next season.


I also don't think it's all about builds adjusting as much as weird sim mechanics and certain attributes really not being worth much or working strangely on offense vs. defense, or SAs/VAs being too powerful in combinations and many being completely worthless.


Also, The Golfers don't play Chicago till the last game of the season. Who knows what the sim will be like then ?
Last edited Mar 10, 2009 18:27:50
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SkersAllTheWay
I'll add my two cents to this discussion. We (Omaha) have been abused by excessive running as well. I would agree that our Run D needs some work, but the exploits (or whatever we're calling them) are getting excessive. Richey Royals spanked us using a balanced approach so I know teams can be successful using both run and pass.

The last 3 opposing offenses against us:
HIB - 74 rushes and 2 passes (97% run)
SDFL - 63 rushes and 12 passes (84% run)
Waller - 66 rushes and 15 passes (81% run)

Similar to Cav, I'm not calling any of the above 3 teams cheaters or taking advantage of the SIM. Hell, they beat us using the same capability I have access to so shame on me. My point is if Bort has any desire to make GLB somewhat realistic it should be more than a few formations and running plays.

Now, I'll get back to my OAI gameplanning of 90%+ rushing the rest of this season and expecting all remaining opponents to do the same...


See that's the catch.......... if people start game planning to run more on offense & to stop the Run on defense ...

the passing will magically get better

It's a big cycle


 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Renders the game meaningless. Period. It's no different from the people who exploited uncapped new leagues early on by dropping down high-level players.

If you do it, you are part of the problem.

This is something Bort should fix immediately. Actually, he should have fixed it over a season ago.


Actually, the more people exploit it, the sooner Bort will HAVE to fix it.

I think this is awesome long term. 90 runs and 53 minutes of posession. LOL.
What's even worse is when one player carries the ball 50-70 times with no effectiveness loss.

I OC the Wolfpack and we obviously run a lot (and a wide range of runs, for what thats worth). I pass as much as is feasible to not sacrifice results :/
I mean take a look at USA Pro games. It's comical. Teams like CCCC get destroyed running balanced offenses, switch to 70+ runs and all of a sudden they start winning.

Everyone seems to know it's a joke but Bort. The Wolfpack play Monmouth on Thursday, and the over under for cumulative passes is like 15.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jebby69
I am the OC for Chicago and I also own the QB and WR for Chicago and basically paid $18 this season for guys I cant really use. .



This is all that needs to be said.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by LIGHTNINGBOLTinc


See that's the catch.......... if people start game planning to run more on offense & to stop the Run on defense ...

the passing will magically get better

It's a big cycle


I agree to a point LBinc. There should always be a chess match going on between OC and DC's in RL football and hopefully at some point in GLB. Those cycles take place all the time.

However, with the current state of GLB people aren't gameplanning to strengths/weaknesses of their team/opponents as it should be. It's more about gameplanning to find the weaknesses of the SIM. As Islander1 says, everyone seems to know this but Bort.
 
enoch101
offline
Link
 
I have to give mad respect to cav and alpine once again for not riding csonka to the title last year.

I think bort did very litle to improve the game from season 7 to 8
 
Spirer
offline
Link
 
What you needed to win games in season 7: half-decent O-line and 1 Powerback
What you need to win games in season 8: half-decent O-line and 1 Powerback

Powerbacks are the dumbest thing ever in GLB. A HB wouldn't never be good with 100 STR, simply because he would be a slug that would always get TFLed... GLB presumes to be a simulation, but sadly it's more like a bad arcade...
Last edited Mar 10, 2009 20:13:05
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
If you do it, you are part of the problem.


I understand the thought process behind this, but I disagree in part.

I liken it to the Prisoner's Dilemma: if doing the right thing could potentially cost you personally if another entity does the selfish thing, without prior knowledge you should give them the benefit of the doubt so you have a chance for a more-desirable outcome. But when dealing with those who have proven they won't do the right thing, you should prevent them from taking unfair advantage of you as they have done to others in the past.

In other words, a team who has used weaknesses in the sim to their advantage before is likely to do so again. You have no reason to expect them to begin behaving according to your own preferences now, while you do have responsibility to win for yourself and your teammates. That's a situation where it's appropriate to use every advantage available imo.

It's an unpleasant scenario and others may reasonably feel differently, but I find little honor in being a willing victim.
 
kenmoody
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

If you do it, you are part of the problem.


I understand the thought process behind this, but I disagree in part.

I liken it to the Prisoner's Dilemma: if doing the right thing could potentially cost you personally if another entity does the selfish thing, without prior knowledge you should give them the benefit of the doubt so you have a chance for a more-desirable outcome. But when dealing with those who have proven they won't do the right thing, you should prevent them from taking unfair advantage of you as they have done to others in the past.

In other words, a team who has used weaknesses in the sim to their advantage before is likely to do so again. You have no reason to expect them to begin behaving according to your own preferences now, while you do have responsibility to win for yourself and your teammates. That's a situation where it's appropriate to use every advantage available imo.

It's an unpleasant scenario and others may reasonably feel differently, but I find little honor in being a willing victim.


agreed.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by enoch101
I have to give mad respect to cav and alpine once again for not riding csonka to the title last year.

I think bort did very litle to improve the game from season 7 to 8


Makes me wonder if that was why Csonka didn't resign, too.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
I know LC was a bit frustrated at times after a game where he was dominating but only got 25 carries and 1 catch when he knew what he was capable of. LC is a great guy though. Always good for laughs on the forums. I do miss his postings this season. Cav is one of the most standup anonymous internet personalities i've ever not met before. Most people know this though


Then again, we're off to a better start than last season. Is this the Ewing Theory?




edit: i like how much more thoughtful and civil this thread about problems with glb is compared to ones in the main forum. Makes it easy and informative to read
Last edited Mar 10, 2009 21:51:43
 
billbates
offline
Link
 
The defense needs to have some sort of a bonus after seeing a play more than 5 times a game. Dline should start to get better jumps and linebacker moving up to fill gaps.
 
Lost Time
offline
Link
 
As the OC for the Pounders i have to say i almost screwed the pooch against HIB today trying to incorporate pass plays where i should of run. Thing is i knew it when it happened. The trouble is trying to find the nice pass plays to put in there so you don't run it all the time and still get a win. That to me is so time consuming and not what i signed up for. It should not be that hard to find the pass plays so you don't run it 90+% of the time and "exploit the system"

Trying to get your QB and WR/TE in the game is a struggle to say the least. I believe most all of us are trying to keep true to a combination of run/pass without losing sight of advancing. It is a tricky business to say the least. Let's see how can i win this without running all the time and stick some pass plays in there. uhmmm let me sit down, belly up to the computer, get me a cup of coffee and spend the next 2-4 hours trying to find it each game.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.