User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
Originally posted by PaqMarq11

Originally posted by Koncorde


Originally posted by PaqMarq11



but the people who has obvious bias for the offense said "completions are down!!! make the passing more powerful!!!"

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2215665


We don't need that in here thankyou.


but this reported "bug" contradicts the thread about passing completions being down. that thread is "lobbying" to get it back up again, right?

so i don't know...


i know pass deflections are up for w/e reason but both problems can exist simultaneously


pd's likely won't be completions.

they are on the opposite sides.
 
palindrome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
Feb 20, 2009
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=379870&pbp_id=5456916 (<- not quite the problem but another weird movement)
notice the CB keeps running (practically through the WR) while the WR stops to catch the pass


My guy is the CB here.

Have over 100 speed, over 95 agility and 68 vision plus 8 super vision.

They ran that play a lot and the weird movement seems to happen quite a bit.
 
Jazzpelli
offline
Link
 
Could this weird movement be associated with the QB/CB and not the WR/CB dynamic? The QB is able to fool the CB with a pump fake? And yes, I realize that the CB is not frozen like one would expect if a pump fake occurred but I am wondering if somehow its firing causing the CB to have the weird movement. I've always associated that move with a low agility and vision on the CB's part but that's for countering the effect and I'm still curious as to the cause of the movement.
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jazzpelli
Could this weird movement be associated with the QB/CB and not the WR/CB dynamic? The QB is able to fool the CB with a pump fake? And yes, I realize that the CB is not frozen like one would expect if a pump fake occurred but I am wondering if somehow its firing causing the CB to have the weird movement. I've always associated that move with a low agility and vision on the CB's part but that's for countering the effect and I'm still curious as to the cause of the movement.


i agree.

seems like they take a step back
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jazzpelli
Could this weird movement be associated with the QB/CB and not the WR/CB dynamic? The QB is able to fool the CB with a pump fake? And yes, I realize that the CB is not frozen like one would expect if a pump fake occurred but I am wondering if somehow its firing causing the CB to have the weird movement. I've always associated that move with a low agility and vision on the CB's part but that's for countering the effect and I'm still curious as to the cause of the movement.


A Pump Fake can redirect a defender.
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
But you can usually see a pump fake happening in the animation. Is that the case here? I've been seeing a whole lot of weird CB movement over the last game or 2. Basically, IMO, the D needs options and is getting the short-end on all fronts in the sim. Guess people pay to see their offensive "stars" get stats. Eventually, at this rate, folks will stop creating D players all-together and then we'll see how the game works. At the very least, D needs some custom slots to handle all the over-powered offensive weapons which generally cost a whole lot less SPs to build too. *sigh*
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 12:18:51
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Toriq
But you can usually see a pump fake happening in the animation. Is that the case here? I've been seeing a whole lot of weird CB movement over the last game or 2. Basically, IMO, the D needs options and is getting the short-end on all fronts in the sim. Guess people pay to see their offensive "stars" get stats. Eventually, at this rate, folks will stop creating D players all-together and then we'll see how the game works. At the very least, D needs some custom slots to handle all the over-powered offensive weapons which generally cost a whole lot less SPs to build too. *sigh*


hey koncorde

toriq makes a comment just like my thread that you locked.

but with these:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2220514
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2215665

is it too late? bort is going to start looking at it. will the pass defense get the next nerf?
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 12:34:20
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
I need answers from Bort first before any testing can take place regarding any advice.

One however is an issue with WR motion at the point the pass is released resulting in unnecessary PD's.

This is a potential issue with CB motion and/or the process it goes though resulting in unnecessary completions.

They are two completely different issues and for discussing them they should be kept seperately as possible.

The below is probably the most complete answer anyone can give on the subject based off the few replays seen.

Originally posted by Koncorde


Part of the problem is that if your player doesn't actually have the skills to play close (i.e. high agility, vision) then it's difficult to maintain that closeness when the WR stops dead to make a catch. There is a CB delay in reading of any pass - though vision and super vision (and subsequently, first step, change direction, shutdown coverage, swat ball etc) all work towards reducing that delay and/or compensating for being out of position.

Semi aggressive meanwhile shouldn't majorly effect his pattern - however on a play when he feels he's going to be beaten I suspect he drops back to cover it safely/or to the position he feels he can make the best play on the ball. It's looking a bit dramatic for the CB in this case because he's effectively moving away from the play.

Without knowing the WR build for instance (but obviously I can see that in each case the pass is high by the animation of the ball) it may be a similar issue to those I have covered before - notably that the CB is working out where he can make a play on the ball, which happens to be further behind the WR than the WR can make a play (due to higher jumping or similar).

There may however be an issue with sideline passes in that case. The CB will not route out of bounds to meet the path of the ball (I think that was an earlier season fix) so he's moving further back downfield instead. The path of the ball in some of those cases definitely look like they may have gone out of bounds without the WR's catch.

I'd have to check with some of my own replays to be honest.


If everyone could please stfu about a nerf before any investigation has taken place please as that does nothing but stir up bullshit rumours and hypercritical responses to any changes.
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde


If everyone could please stfu about a nerf before any investigation has taken place please as that does nothing but stir up bullshit rumours and hypercritical responses to any changes.


take a look at this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2229630&page=1

it wasn't started by me. but they see the writing on the wall. a lot of people are getting a little bit worried most especially with how things are being run here (they are a little bit wiser now).

 
AD_SoDope
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
but the people who has obvious bias for the offense said "completions are down!!! make the passing more powerful!!!"

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2215665


I have a WR as well as a CB and I think the passing game is too tough this season
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AD_MVP
Originally posted by PaqMarq11

but the people who has obvious bias for the offense said "completions are down!!! make the passing more powerful!!!"

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2215665


I have a WR as well as a CB and I think the passing game is too tough this season


defense caught up a bit.

the example of the OP clearly shows that the offense is still ahead.

i have a qb and te, btw
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
I need answers from Bort first before any testing can take place regarding any advice.

One however is an issue with WR motion at the point the pass is released resulting in unnecessary PD's.

This is a potential issue with CB motion and/or the process it goes though resulting in unnecessary completions.

They are two completely different issues and for discussing them they should be kept seperately as possible.

The below is probably the most complete answer anyone can give on the subject based off the few replays seen.

Originally posted by Koncorde



Part of the problem is that if your player doesn't actually have the skills to play close (i.e. high agility, vision) then it's difficult to maintain that closeness when the WR stops dead to make a catch. There is a CB delay in reading of any pass - though vision and super vision (and subsequently, first step, change direction, shutdown coverage, swat ball etc) all work towards reducing that delay and/or compensating for being out of position.

Semi aggressive meanwhile shouldn't majorly effect his pattern - however on a play when he feels he's going to be beaten I suspect he drops back to cover it safely/or to the position he feels he can make the best play on the ball. It's looking a bit dramatic for the CB in this case because he's effectively moving away from the play.

Without knowing the WR build for instance (but obviously I can see that in each case the pass is high by the animation of the ball) it may be a similar issue to those I have covered before - notably that the CB is working out where he can make a play on the ball, which happens to be further behind the WR than the WR can make a play (due to higher jumping or similar).

There may however be an issue with sideline passes in that case. The CB will not route out of bounds to meet the path of the ball (I think that was an earlier season fix) so he's moving further back downfield instead. The path of the ball in some of those cases definitely look like they may have gone out of bounds without the WR's catch.

I'd have to check with some of my own replays to be honest.


If everyone could please stfu about a nerf before any investigation has taken place please as that does nothing but stir up bullshit rumours and hypercritical responses to any changes.


I'm more than willing to stfu if i can see this here http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread_list.pl?forum_id=3733&team_id=0

as in....it's actually being investigated.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
There's no point investigating this issue currently, whilst the other test is ongoing. They'd conflict.
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
There's no point investigating this issue currently, whilst the other test is ongoing. They'd conflict.


Well, that makes zero sense, IMO. So we wait for the offense QB/WR issue (which IMO is bunk from what I see in sims) to get fixed - which coincidentally probably involves nerfing CBs according a a post I saw from Bort, nerfing their vision specifically if I recall correctly - and then after that happens the CB problems (which coincidentally will likely be multiplied by the previous test/nerf to "fix" passing for already overpowered offenses (IMO)) will be tested against it, but of course the sim will be completely different by then. Hmmm, no one ever heard of parallel testing? Don't you have teams to test various issues? All of you 30+ testers work on one specific issue at a time?

Sorry, I gotta call it like I see...hogwash. May as well not have a test environment and go back to the way it was before in that case. Yes, I'm a bit bitter about how this is going on. I have players on both sides of the ball and the D is getting the short-end of the stick on every side imaginable...from builds to AI options to nerfs galore, just so the offense can continue to score mega-points a game. Great!

*sigh* I really had high hopes for the test environment actually balancing things versus just working for the offense. But, as I mentioned somewhere above, guess those O guys just have to have their already unrealistic stats keep going....

Like the energizer bunny...

*bigger sigh*

Proof? Current testing is on...

> Pass Completion Mother Thread: Started by: Koncorde (sticky) - Offense

> Please complie evidence of Sure Tackle VA being Broken here - Defense

> Blocking continues to suck on outside runs - Offense

> Possible Bug with Singleback Flanker Drag Play / QB checkdowns - Offense

> Pass Completion Percentages in USA Pro (Last Season VS This Season) - Offense

> Test of "QB vision"/Hot Route/Open target: Started by: Koncorde (locked) - Offense

> Leading the receiver - Thought this was supposed to be fixed... - Offense

Only 6 to 1 in favor of offense and the single D issue is related to a BS VA...

Love that testing "balance"!

*biggest sigh yet*

No wonder good people like BearBryant have given up on being D coordinators when there is such a pronounced bias towards offense. I'm just about to do the same thing. Just not worth it, TTTT.

Last edited Mar 5, 2009 19:48:29
 
Hukton Vioxx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by palindrome
Originally posted by kuaggie

Feb 20, 2009
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=379870&pbp_id=5456916 (<- not quite the problem but another weird movement)
notice the CB keeps running (practically through the WR) while the WR stops to catch the pass


My guy is the CB here.

Have over 100 speed, over 95 agility and 68 vision plus 8 super vision.

They ran that play a lot and the weird movement seems to happen quite a bit.


Can WRs push off? With a build like that you have got to be lacking something...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.