"the best ideas will often come from the non "high visibility" agents" well - I don't necessarily think that is a provable statement -
the problem is that Bort only has so much time in the day - he could take someone like a Deathblade and say 'form some focus groups for me; I'm thinking about 10 people discussing endorsements; about 10 people discussing how to best calculate an MVP" etc etc.
Then since Deathblade is extremely active (could also be Knick or any number of people) in the suggestion forum - he would probably have an idea who to recruit - and their goal could be that Deathblade is going to submit a report to Bort within a week (as an estimate).
The problem with that is - many people will see that as being just as 'elitist' as testers and mod's are....
there is no way to pick and choose 10 people from among thousands without there being an outcry - as some examples:
"Deathblade just chooses his friends"
"Deathblade just chooses people who kiss his ass"
"Why wasn't I picked?"
"Why was person X picked? he is an idiot!"
"I had a post about this last week - and my idea wasn't utilitized - why is that??"
etc etc etc
I agree with you - discussing ideas in the suggestion forum is often very unsatisfying - people might crap all over your idea - and never come back to debate it; you might post what you think is a good idea and no one ever responds to it - people can focus more on flaming each other than discussing the idea.....
That doesn't even include the fact that SO many ideas (and good ones) get posted/discussed that never get implemented or even seem to make the radar.....it is definitely an imperfect system - and those are some of the reasons I don't post here as often as I used to
I know some people have begun private forums - along the same lines as what you are pitching here - but i don't know how those work as I'm not a member of any of them
Last edited Feb 27, 2009 09:30:51