Yah, overall I was very unhappy with the way endorsements went. Of course, it could be because I had terrible luck, but I just don't like that I could have by far the best player at a position in a league, on a team that went 20-0 and an LB on my team that was a backup and terrible gets the endorsement. That happened twice to me (the other was 18-2 and lost in the LC). I just think overall this is one of the worst thought out releases this game has had.
jdbstealth
offline
offline
I don't believe Bort took enough time on this. He says he tested it, but you'd think he would notice things like how heavily weighted things were toward championship teams. The formula that was used to determine how many "tickets" you get in the endorsement lottery needs a serious overhaul.
Cadillac24 DTD
offline
offline
Originally posted by tautology
Gratz to Cali, you'll need the help in Pro Zeta, I suspect.
Consider we face the Benitos today who have about 8 endorsements themselves, yes, we'll take all the help we can
Gratz to Cali, you'll need the help in Pro Zeta, I suspect.
Consider we face the Benitos today who have about 8 endorsements themselves, yes, we'll take all the help we can
tautology
offline
offline
Originally posted by jrogish
Are there attribute bonuses that go with the endorsements or is it just imaginary crap like make a rap video?
The Pro level ones are fairly insane...things like +2 speed, +2 Agility, +2 Vision, +1 to the ENTIRE Shutdown TREE, + 1 Monster Hit (Thats for a SS)
They get a little less potent as you step down the league ladder.
A Pro level endorsement is generally worth 25 to 50 SPs....seems a bit much tbh.
Are there attribute bonuses that go with the endorsements or is it just imaginary crap like make a rap video?
The Pro level ones are fairly insane...things like +2 speed, +2 Agility, +2 Vision, +1 to the ENTIRE Shutdown TREE, + 1 Monster Hit (Thats for a SS)
They get a little less potent as you step down the league ladder.
A Pro level endorsement is generally worth 25 to 50 SPs....seems a bit much tbh.
ErDrRon
offline
offline
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by jrogish
Are there attribute bonuses that go with the endorsements or is it just imaginary crap like make a rap video?
The Pro level ones are fairly insane...things like +2 speed, +2 Agility, +2 Vision, +1 to the ENTIRE Shutdown TREE, + 1 Monster Hit (Thats for a SS)
They get a little less potent as you step down the league ladder.
A Pro level endorsement is generally worth 25 to 50 SPs....seems a bit much tbh.
+1
Originally posted by jrogish
Are there attribute bonuses that go with the endorsements or is it just imaginary crap like make a rap video?
The Pro level ones are fairly insane...things like +2 speed, +2 Agility, +2 Vision, +1 to the ENTIRE Shutdown TREE, + 1 Monster Hit (Thats for a SS)
They get a little less potent as you step down the league ladder.
A Pro level endorsement is generally worth 25 to 50 SPs....seems a bit much tbh.
+1
GMathiasf
offline
offline
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by jrogish
Are there attribute bonuses that go with the endorsements or is it just imaginary crap like make a rap video?
The Pro level ones are fairly insane...things like +2 speed, +2 Agility, +2 Vision, +1 to the ENTIRE Shutdown TREE, + 1 Monster Hit (Thats for a SS)
They get a little less potent as you step down the league ladder.
A Pro level endorsement is generally worth 25 to 50 SPs....seems a bit much tbh.
Absolutely. I think they need to be more frequent (at minimum the number of spots on the depth chart and per Conference, possibly twice as frequent in the Pros) and also less powerful.
Originally posted by jrogish
Are there attribute bonuses that go with the endorsements or is it just imaginary crap like make a rap video?
The Pro level ones are fairly insane...things like +2 speed, +2 Agility, +2 Vision, +1 to the ENTIRE Shutdown TREE, + 1 Monster Hit (Thats for a SS)
They get a little less potent as you step down the league ladder.
A Pro level endorsement is generally worth 25 to 50 SPs....seems a bit much tbh.
Absolutely. I think they need to be more frequent (at minimum the number of spots on the depth chart and per Conference, possibly twice as frequent in the Pros) and also less powerful.
Lambda
offline
offline
Originally posted by bucknhacks
Should scrap the whole idea if you're not gonna stick to a plan, and let it play out. This isn't Pro Bowl voting, it's who would a (make believe) sponsor want to use to sell his product? Someone from a winning team, or a losing team? Who goes to Disneyworld after every Super Bowl? I'd gladly have all Endo's removed, if all the complainers would just shut the fuck up. Everything Bort changes, or adds has to be done twice, cause all the whiners crawl out of the woodwork, and start screaming bloody murder, because something's not "fair". Welcome to the real world folks.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=528599
Harper's Guide to Greatness
Endorsement with EllisBell Publishing.
Inside scoop on how to be great.
+1 agility, +1 strength, +2 tackling, Make tackle chance +25%
it has nothing to do with being fair, it has to do with being a completely retarded system. it makes sense to endorse the hell out of championship teams, but it doesn't make a goddamn bit of sense to endorse only one player per position. the analogy earlier in this thread is perfect.
these things are given to people based on:
a) fame, a completely broken metric that is based almost entirely on raw level, with same level players differing seemingly at random, with absolutely no importance placed on awards won, stats, team wins, etc.
b) randomness, entirely stupid in its own right. do you think nike flipped a coin to decide whether to endorse michael jordan or tom gugliotta? i understand a bit of randomness, but it should randomly choose one of the top tier qbs in terms of stats, wins, etc., rather than one of any of the qbs in the league. it makes sense given the nature of the endorsements to randomly select between a league's version of tom brady, peyton manning, brett favre, but it doesn't make sense to randomly select between a brady, a manning, and a tavaris jackson for ANY endorsement
you could reach out to the scrub teams by doing a local endorsement thing, with say 5 local endorsements given out per team with lower cash rewards and worse gear.
like taut said, he really messed up on this.
Should scrap the whole idea if you're not gonna stick to a plan, and let it play out. This isn't Pro Bowl voting, it's who would a (make believe) sponsor want to use to sell his product? Someone from a winning team, or a losing team? Who goes to Disneyworld after every Super Bowl? I'd gladly have all Endo's removed, if all the complainers would just shut the fuck up. Everything Bort changes, or adds has to be done twice, cause all the whiners crawl out of the woodwork, and start screaming bloody murder, because something's not "fair". Welcome to the real world folks.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=528599
Harper's Guide to Greatness
Endorsement with EllisBell Publishing.
Inside scoop on how to be great.
+1 agility, +1 strength, +2 tackling, Make tackle chance +25%
it has nothing to do with being fair, it has to do with being a completely retarded system. it makes sense to endorse the hell out of championship teams, but it doesn't make a goddamn bit of sense to endorse only one player per position. the analogy earlier in this thread is perfect.
these things are given to people based on:
a) fame, a completely broken metric that is based almost entirely on raw level, with same level players differing seemingly at random, with absolutely no importance placed on awards won, stats, team wins, etc.
b) randomness, entirely stupid in its own right. do you think nike flipped a coin to decide whether to endorse michael jordan or tom gugliotta? i understand a bit of randomness, but it should randomly choose one of the top tier qbs in terms of stats, wins, etc., rather than one of any of the qbs in the league. it makes sense given the nature of the endorsements to randomly select between a league's version of tom brady, peyton manning, brett favre, but it doesn't make sense to randomly select between a brady, a manning, and a tavaris jackson for ANY endorsement
you could reach out to the scrub teams by doing a local endorsement thing, with say 5 local endorsements given out per team with lower cash rewards and worse gear.
like taut said, he really messed up on this.
TyrannyVaunt
offline
offline
With all this fussing... Bort should just reset it... And just do endorsements for everyone... But base it off your fame score.
Maybe not make your player eligible until LVL 32, and then you start getting the endorsement deals coming in.
At least then everyone is getting something and the bitching and flaming would end.
Amirite?
Maybe not make your player eligible until LVL 32, and then you start getting the endorsement deals coming in.
At least then everyone is getting something and the bitching and flaming would end.
Amirite?
jrogish
offline
offline
Originally posted by Lambda
do you think nike flipped a coin to decide whether to endorse michael jordan or tom gugliotta
That may be the first Tom Gugliotta reference I've heard in 15 years (very nice), but you're exactly right. Large companies like Nike, Adidas, Under Armour, Gatorade, etc. don't pick between A and B, they give endorsements to A, B and C-Z.
do you think nike flipped a coin to decide whether to endorse michael jordan or tom gugliotta
That may be the first Tom Gugliotta reference I've heard in 15 years (very nice), but you're exactly right. Large companies like Nike, Adidas, Under Armour, Gatorade, etc. don't pick between A and B, they give endorsements to A, B and C-Z.
GMathiasf
offline
offline
I think the biggest problem is that fame is terrible. It's based off of games played in a league and then a small bonus for trophies. That literally is it. Bort has said something about performance in closely matched games, but I don't know what that means or how it could possibly be demonstrated (how do you know my LG dominated the line of scrimmage all day?) for many positions. So, if you won a league Championship, you have 2 trophies. At many positions (DT, FS, TE, FB, etc.), there will be absolutely no trophies won. So, the best FS in the league really has no chance to win any trophy unless a Conference or League Champ. and has exactly the same chance of winning a trophy as the backup FS on the worst team. It's such a terrible and illogical system.
TyrannyVaunt
offline
offline
The higher the fame, the better the endorsement should be. Regardless of position. Look Steve Hutchinson is perhaps the best G in the NFL... But I don't see him doing Sony commercials... Instead I see Peyton Manning. A Guard shouldn't have a fame score as high as a QB, HB, WR. Just like a NT shouldn't have a fame score like a dominant LB or Safety.
So make fame based on something like this...
Players Fame = # of snaps + league rank (BBB, A, AA, AAA, Pro) + position trophies + team trophies + position factor.
Position Factor would be weighted by position (QB, HB, WR = 300 flex should be higher weight than other positions).
The higher the fame, the better the endorsement.
Every player gets an endorsement once their fame is 600+. The higher the fame, the better the endorsement deals become.
So make fame based on something like this...
Players Fame = # of snaps + league rank (BBB, A, AA, AAA, Pro) + position trophies + team trophies + position factor.
Position Factor would be weighted by position (QB, HB, WR = 300 flex should be higher weight than other positions).
The higher the fame, the better the endorsement.
Every player gets an endorsement once their fame is 600+. The higher the fame, the better the endorsement deals become.
rotharek
offline
offline
if you don't break top 10 stat leaders for your position, you shouldn't be considered for endorsements
TheSandman
offline
offline
Originally posted by rotharek
if you don't break top 10 stat leaders for your position, you shouldn't be considered for endorsements
this
if you don't break top 10 stat leaders for your position, you shouldn't be considered for endorsements
this
GMathiasf
offline
offline
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt
The higher the fame, the better the endorsement should be. Regardless of position. Look Steve Hutchinson is perhaps the best G in the NFL... But I don't see him doing Sony commercials... Instead I see Peyton Manning. A Guard shouldn't have a fame score as high as a QB, HB, WR. Just like a NT shouldn't have a fame score like a dominant LB or Safety.
So make fame based on something like this...
Players Fame = # of snaps + league rank (BBB, A, AA, AAA, Pro) + position trophies + team trophies + position factor.
Position Factor would be weighted by position (QB, HB, WR = 300 flex should be higher weight than other positions).
The higher the fame, the better the endorsement.
Every player gets an endorsement once their fame is 600+. The higher the fame, the better the endorsement deals become.
Why trophies? Those are a terrible measure of performance honestly and are more about beating the crap out of bad teams than anything else. Whichever Conference has more CPUs wins the trophies.
The higher the fame, the better the endorsement should be. Regardless of position. Look Steve Hutchinson is perhaps the best G in the NFL... But I don't see him doing Sony commercials... Instead I see Peyton Manning. A Guard shouldn't have a fame score as high as a QB, HB, WR. Just like a NT shouldn't have a fame score like a dominant LB or Safety.
So make fame based on something like this...
Players Fame = # of snaps + league rank (BBB, A, AA, AAA, Pro) + position trophies + team trophies + position factor.
Position Factor would be weighted by position (QB, HB, WR = 300 flex should be higher weight than other positions).
The higher the fame, the better the endorsement.
Every player gets an endorsement once their fame is 600+. The higher the fame, the better the endorsement deals become.
Why trophies? Those are a terrible measure of performance honestly and are more about beating the crap out of bad teams than anything else. Whichever Conference has more CPUs wins the trophies.
TyrannyVaunt
offline
offline
Originally posted by GMathiasf
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt
The higher the fame, the better the endorsement should be. Regardless of position. Look Steve Hutchinson is perhaps the best G in the NFL... But I don't see him doing Sony commercials... Instead I see Peyton Manning. A Guard shouldn't have a fame score as high as a QB, HB, WR. Just like a NT shouldn't have a fame score like a dominant LB or Safety.
So make fame based on something like this...
Players Fame = # of snaps + league rank (BBB, A, AA, AAA, Pro) + position trophies + team trophies + position factor.
Position Factor would be weighted by position (QB, HB, WR = 300 flex should be higher weight than other positions).
The higher the fame, the better the endorsement.
Every player gets an endorsement once their fame is 600+. The higher the fame, the better the endorsement deals become.
Why trophies? Those are a terrible measure of performance honestly and are more about beating the crap out of bad teams than anything else. Whichever Conference has more CPUs wins the trophies.
Yes there are issues with gutted teams, and putting up uber numbers because you played against a bunch of gut jobs... But you play 16 games. Typically there are only 1 to 2 CPU's per conference. This season is a little strange given Zeta has 3 and Alpha has zero, but that is an exception of the rule. So yes, trophies should be counted toward your fame number. If you play 14 games against quality opponents, and 2 CPU's... For the most part every team has their work horses who will have a shot to get some padded stats during those two games. So whats the big deal?
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt
The higher the fame, the better the endorsement should be. Regardless of position. Look Steve Hutchinson is perhaps the best G in the NFL... But I don't see him doing Sony commercials... Instead I see Peyton Manning. A Guard shouldn't have a fame score as high as a QB, HB, WR. Just like a NT shouldn't have a fame score like a dominant LB or Safety.
So make fame based on something like this...
Players Fame = # of snaps + league rank (BBB, A, AA, AAA, Pro) + position trophies + team trophies + position factor.
Position Factor would be weighted by position (QB, HB, WR = 300 flex should be higher weight than other positions).
The higher the fame, the better the endorsement.
Every player gets an endorsement once their fame is 600+. The higher the fame, the better the endorsement deals become.
Why trophies? Those are a terrible measure of performance honestly and are more about beating the crap out of bad teams than anything else. Whichever Conference has more CPUs wins the trophies.
Yes there are issues with gutted teams, and putting up uber numbers because you played against a bunch of gut jobs... But you play 16 games. Typically there are only 1 to 2 CPU's per conference. This season is a little strange given Zeta has 3 and Alpha has zero, but that is an exception of the rule. So yes, trophies should be counted toward your fame number. If you play 14 games against quality opponents, and 2 CPU's... For the most part every team has their work horses who will have a shot to get some padded stats during those two games. So whats the big deal?
Last edited Feb 27, 2009 00:31:57
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























