User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania AAA Leagues > Oceania AAA #1 > Oceania AAA - Season 2 - MVP Candidates
Page:
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
I'm not quite sure he deserves mention in this thread, but I think he is up there with the elite CBs.

Shade Malone
27 Tackles
19 PD
5 Int
2 FF
1 TD


Those numbers, outside of the interceptions and TD, may not seem elite, but the fact that he only has 27 tackles and 19 PDs means that opposing offenses are avoiding him. That makes the 5 Ints even more impressive.
Last edited May 12, 2008 20:51:02
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Malone and, regrettably, Brantford's Game Breaker would be my picks for top AAA corners.

And I'd put Tonga's Amanda Hugginkiss right behind them.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Malone and, regrettably, Brantford's Game Breaker would be my picks for top AAA corners.

And I'd put Tonga's Amanda Hugginkiss right behind them.


Yep, Huggs is one of those guys ... doesn't light up the stat sheet, but takes away half of the field.
 
Rudger
offline
Link
 
Dont know if anyone else has noticed this but 2nd CB spot allways plays loose regardless of personal settings. I agree that normally high tackles is a bad sign for CB, that means allot of passes coming his way. Though it also often means he has a good build with high tackle and vision, and I know he helps us on the run game.

I think despite our record the Bulls have 2 of the top CBs in Oceania AAA. Rage doesnt allow anything on his side of the field so Mcneeley gets double work. Just look at his number of passes defended plus leading the league in INTs and INT return yards(by 71 yards). That tells the real story of how he makes the other team pay.

Just puting it out there that he leads the league in 3 defensive catagories, I dont see how he can be anything but Defensive MVP. I know he is MVP of the Bulls this year.

*updated Numbers*
Mcneeley
100 Tackles (1st)
36 Passes Defended(1st)
7 Interceptions (Tied 1st)
163 Ret Yards (1st)
1 Int TD (Tied 2nd)
2 Forced Fumbles
Last edited May 14, 2008 09:42:08
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
how many missed tackles do these guys have?
 
Rudger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
how many missed tackles do these guys have?


Mcneely missed 4, i think that was early in the season though
 
Eon724
offline
Link
 
McNeeley is a beast of a CB.

Originally posted by PityTheFool
McNeely and actually both of our corners have been without a doubt our biggest strength. They've kept us from getting beat worse than we have in some games and kept us in others.


Thanks for the support Pity. We try to lock them down.
Last edited May 12, 2008 23:55:50
 
TtD
offline
Link
 
McNeeley is a half decent CB on a very bad D going by his stats. Hes given up 100 successful plays, stopped 36 and missed 4 tackles. That's almost a 3:1 ratio of giving up passes. Also means he gets targetted every game and as such he has a very similar ratio to our broken CB who runs about 10yds from the guy hes supposed to mark each play.

If you take Amanda at T.I.T for a comparison, 9 games, no missed tackles, 18 tackles, 16 PD, thats an almost 1:1 ratio, so 50% of passes hir way fail to reach their target, thats a stud CB.
 
Jonas-Dahl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TtD
McNeeley is a half decent CB on a very bad D going by his stats. Hes given up 100 successful plays, stopped 36 and missed 4 tackles. That's almost a 3:1 ratio of giving up passes. Also means he gets targetted every game and as such he has a very similar ratio to our broken CB who runs about 10yds from the guy hes supposed to mark each play.

If you take Amanda at T.I.T for a comparison, 9 games, no missed tackles, 18 tackles, 16 PD, thats an almost 1:1 ratio, so 50% of passes hir way fail to reach their target, thats a stud CB.


Isn’t that the wrong way to look at it???

I also play CB for TIT and in our game vs. Samoa Flying Foxes I had 7 tackles but 6 of them were on a run. And at the Pagan Fire Eaters only 2 tackles on a pass and 8 PD

Just saying that lots of tackles doesn’t necessary means that you allow a lot of passes.

But yes – Amanda is a STUD




 
HaplosDog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TtD
McNeeley is a half decent CB on a very bad D going by his stats. Hes given up 100 successful plays, stopped 36 and missed 4 tackles. That's almost a 3:1 ratio of giving up passes. Also means he gets targetted every game and as such he has a very similar ratio to our broken CB who runs about 10yds from the guy hes supposed to mark each play.

If you take Amanda at T.I.T for a comparison, 9 games, no missed tackles, 18 tackles, 16 PD, thats an almost 1:1 ratio, so 50% of passes hir way fail to reach their target, thats a stud CB.


You can't say that if a CB has 36 tackles, that's 36 succesful plays for the offense. My CB has a lot of tackles, but over 75% of them are either on special teams or in run support. Almost all of the run support ones are for very short gains, even a few for losses. The majority of my the pass tackles are of the "6 yard gain on 3rd and 8" variety. So that becomes a very low portion of my total tackles that are succesful offensive plays. Unfortunately, for a CB, you have to watch his games to really be able to assess his strenghts and weaknesses. The worst play that a CB can make is not recorded in the stats, That's when he's beaten and doesn't even make the tackle.
 
DaSaintFan
offline
Link
 
I'd have to see the updated totals: But I gotta go with

TE J.Doom (SSR) ... 134rec - 1331.5 yds - 5TD

Yes, he's got 12 drops.. but when a TE leads the league in receptions and yardage that says something about a 'Go-to' guy... if his TD total was higher, I'd say he's a 'lock' as who'd I would put my MVP vote for.

And considering their primary QB has: 381 completions... so the TE has caught almost 50% of all passes their QB has thrown?
Last edited May 13, 2008 08:37:29
 
nhazelett
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TtD
McNeeley is a half decent CB on a very bad D going by his stats. Hes given up 100 successful plays, stopped 36 and missed 4 tackles. That's almost a 3:1 ratio of giving up passes. Also means he gets targetted every game and as such he has a very similar ratio to our broken CB who runs about 10yds from the guy hes supposed to mark each play.

If you take Amanda at T.I.T for a comparison, 9 games, no missed tackles, 18 tackles, 16 PD, thats an almost 1:1 ratio, so 50% of passes hir way fail to reach their target, thats a stud CB.


lol thats not 100 successful plays, buddy. A lot of them are run plays, and just because you give up a 4 or 6 yard catch, doesn't mean it was successful. McNeeley never gets beat, and he'll give up a catch to save a first down or touchdown always. And 4 missed tackles all season isn't bad either. Not to mention 2 FF.
Last edited May 13, 2008 17:36:20
 
Rudger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TtD
McNeeley is a half decent CB on a very bad D going by his stats. Hes given up 100 successful plays, stopped 36 and missed 4 tackles. That's almost a 3:1 ratio of giving up passes. Also means he gets targetted every game and as such he has a very similar ratio to our broken CB who runs about 10yds from the guy hes supposed to mark each play.

If you take Amanda at T.I.T for a comparison, 9 games, no missed tackles, 18 tackles, 16 PD, thats an almost 1:1 ratio, so 50% of passes hir way fail to reach their target, thats a stud CB.


Thats very astute to take everything at face value and also assume we have a bad defense. Also this is about Most Valuable Player, amanda would hardly be that. The best thing you can say is she did pretty good on a team that is very good.

Not to mention the fact that our offense has struggled this season(just now turning it around), and its been our defense that hold us in the fight. And, if you know anything about real football... Offense playing poorly puts the pressure on the deffense even more.

I also like how you forget to compare amanda's 1 INT 0 Ret yards to mcneeley's 7 INT 163 Ret yards. Im sure she is just too studly to bother intercepting the ball...
Last edited May 13, 2008 17:35:51
 
nhazelett
offline
Link
 
BTW turnit thanks for showing McNeeley some love for MVP though, I couldn't have done it without the opposite corner on my team, Rage Bloodpike. If he wasn't completely shutting down his side, the QB wouldn't ever throw it my way.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Nobody mentioned Amanda for MVP. That was a tangent of evaluating corners.

Frankly, I don't think any of the corners belong in the discussion when compared to Vin or Nuggett.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.