User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Europe West > Europe West AAA League > WE AAA 1 Mid-season Team
Page:
 
Mavooo
offline
Link
 
Echoing these guys sentiments.

One of the LB's also cant get off the field, hence the high tackles.

I think Manbeast MnPhereson is pretty darned good too. heck I wouldnt tarde any of my starting LB's for the aforementioned guys.

It's still nice to see lists like this. Alot of fun and a good way to kill time.

thanks for making the effort
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
I guess I'm a little biased, since I have 2 DB's... but I think the success of a DB is more subjective than objective. I think you'll see that in the NFL a lot too... the best DB's are the ones that you don't hear.

Perhaps the best way to categorize DB's performance is to bundle those players up as well, and use the average yard per attempt as that criteria.
 
Mavooo
offline
Link
 
"art of the safety's job is to stop things from going past them, right? So tackling #'s would not be an indication of a bad safety."

Our safeties are a big in the running game. Dont know how many times Ive seen Hitman, recognize a run from deep backfield to get his ass to the LOS in a hurry to make a tackle for either a loss or minimal gain.
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mavooo
"art of the safety's job is to stop things from going past them, right? So tackling #'s would not be an indication of a bad safety."

Our safeties are a big in the running game. Dont know how many times Ive seen Hitman, recognize a run from deep backfield to get his ass to the LOS in a hurry to make a tackle for either a loss or minimal gain.


I'm not denying that. But as a fellow redskins fan, would you agree that last year, Sean Taylor had a better year (well, up until... you know) than he did the previous in which he had 100+ tackles?
 
Mavooo
offline
Link
 
I hear ya but I would also attribute some of that to having a more capable counterpart at the other safety position.
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
Okay, then lets ask this question. Would you rather your linebackers be making the tackles on the running back, or the safety. If the safety is making the tackles (esp the FS), then the LB isn't doing his job, right?
Last edited May 12, 2008 12:19:54
 
JD Cuda
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gargus
Okay, then lets ask this question. Would you rather your linebackers be making the tackles on the running back, or the safety. If the safety is making the tackles (esp the FS), then the LB isn't doing his job, right?


But would that make the safety's performance any worse? Just because he needs to do more work and he does the work well, does that diminish his performance?
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
no, but that wouldn't make him any better. That just means he's doing his job. If someone else out there is better than FS#1, who has more tackles, but has better linebackers on his team, FS#2 will have less tackles.
 
Mavooo
offline
Link
 
I hear what your saying. Im not sure where this is going. The point was made earlier by someone that the safety wasn't doing his job if he registered alot of tackles. I understand if alot of receptions are being made in front of him you could say those tackles arent very indicative of good play by the safety.

My point is that our safeties do make fast reads and make plays vs the run even from 7-10 yds off the LOS. Such tackles made by the safety shouldnt be lumped in with a tackle deep downfield. One tackle probably meant the safety took a bad angle or couldnt cover the TE, you get what I mean. But the other tackle should be considered a standout play.

 
Mavooo
offline
Link
 
Funny thing is Im not disagreeing with anything your saying gargus.

I dont think I would wanna do a list like this, too many damn things to consider.
 
vabills
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gargus
Originally posted by Mavooo

"art of the safety's job is to stop things from going past them, right? So tackling #'s would not be an indication of a bad safety."

Our safeties are a big in the running game. Dont know how many times Ive seen Hitman, recognize a run from deep backfield to get his ass to the LOS in a hurry to make a tackle for either a loss or minimal gain.


I'm not denying that. But as a fellow redskins fan, would you agree that last year, Sean Taylor had a better year (well, up until... you know) than he did the previous in which he had 100+ tackles?



Oh that explains why you don't know a lot about football, you're a skins fan.

Being a Bills fan in DC, I have to laugh at the idocy I hear from the local sports casters all the time.
 
JD Cuda
offline
Link
 
Alright, we've got the arguments as to why this current list should stay a beta version.

Let's get some nominations (and reasons) for some new blood to be infused into the list!
 
vabills
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdupuy3
Alright, we've got the arguments as to why this current list should stay a beta version.

Let's get some nominations (and reasons) for some new blood to be infused into the list!


I nominate Aaron Brooks as the best backup QB (wanna ba Frank Reich), because his owner is a pain the the ass.
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mavooo
Funny thing is Im not disagreeing with anything your saying gargus.

I dont think I would wanna do a list like this, too many damn things to consider.


Fair enough... I can also see where you're coming from. I think there are certain tangibles and intangibles for the skilled positions.
 
Gargus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vabills


Oh that explains why you don't know a lot about football, you're a skins fan.

Being a Bills fan in DC, I have to laugh at the idocy I hear from the local sports casters all the time.


Good one! oh, and by the way... "sportscaster" is one word...

Last edited May 12, 2008 12:45:04
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.