User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania A Leagues > Oceania A #3 > Oceania A -3 Pro Bowl (rough draft)
Page:
 
PitchBlack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nematoad
How do we keep this thing honest? Theres going to be a lot of people voting purely for teammates or there own players...


well it comes down to integrity and enforcement really. IMO we shouldn't even count incomplete ballots and we WILL NOT accept more than 1 ballot per IP.
 
RyanCane26
offline
Link
 
I'd nominate Madieu Winfield for the CB spot

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=566893&playoffs=0 .. big time stats and the GW Int vs. Newcastle

and DE Ohms Law from AREC only had 29 tackles and 1 sack.. I'm not sure if he should be included, no offense to Bear
Last edited Feb 3, 2009 18:37:07
 
Cornish Rhino
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cornish Rhino
Mat Williams has only played one game for us this season so should probably not be on this list. He played well against the Frenzy, but not that well (Sorry Champ...)


In his place I'd suggest Suge Leit http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_game_log.pl?player_id=547863

Good performances against good teams over overall stats

 
Cornish Rhino
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RyanCane26
I'd nominate Madieu Williams for the CB spot

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=566893&playoffs=0


I second, he helped spoil our fun too

 
Psycho79
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RyanCane26

and DE Ohms Law from AREC only had 29 tackles and 1 sack.. I'm not sure if he should be included, no offense to Bear

Law is a backup for us, I'm almost sure he probably meant to put our starting RE that had 29 sacks.

cornelius bennet http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=455728

 
BobbyBlackk
offline
Link
 
Hey; I apologize for any minor errors...I put in extensive time to put it all together overnight, and as you can see the post was around 5am this morning EST. As for voting, I'll have ALL voting rules and such listed...I am capable of moderating the IP log, and you'll be able to post the info in your team forums to get the team together and vote as well.
 
gazizza
offline
Link
 
Quite a bit of bias here but how does the QB that ranks 3rd in passing yards, 2nd in TD's, and threw only ONE INT all year (all the while splitting time 2:1 with his backup QB) not get a nomination? Trapper Helios should be in imo.

I also think that Madieu Winfield (not Williams as previously stated above) should get the nod for one of the CB spots.
 
jayman
offline
Link
 
from the guam gorillas jay sackster DE was forth in sacks
 
BobbyBlackk
offline
Link
 
Understanding everyone's frustrations, but we need to take in account incomplete balls from QB's & their ratings as well...you can throw the ball 5,000yds in 1 season, but that doesn't make you the best QB, the best QB makes completions. 9 times out of 10, someone w/ the most yards REALLY has a low completion percentage...And for CB's...CB's is a TOUGH race...there were ALOT of neck and necks, but w/ all the new additions to the site over the seasons we need to take into account everything from PDs, tackles, sacks and beyond.

If you feel you need more time to get votes in I don't mind lengthening the time until the official ballot is released. And there is NO biased decisions here...I have 0 Ties into this league. I personally went through ALL but, Zetas MLB, LOLB, QB, WR, TE, FS & HB. PitchBlack, the one who contacted me, knowing I've done ALOT of pro bowl work over the seasons, he actually helped out w/ those categories. Band together as Owners/GMs and if you'd like you can compile your own, I don't mind...
 
RyanCane26
offline
Link
 
No one is questioning what you're doing, just giving input on some adjustments we'd make.. you're not from this league, you don't know the personnel.. we do.. Just helping out

Appreciate what you're doing
 
gazizza
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BobbyBlackk
Understanding everyone's frustrations, but we need to take in account incomplete balls from QB's & their ratings as well...you can throw the ball 5,000yds in 1 season, but that doesn't make you the best QB, the best QB makes completions. 9 times out of 10, someone w/ the most yards REALLY has a low completion percentage...


A QB could throw screen passes exclusively and have an insane completion percentage but how does that make him a better QB than one that throws it down field every once in a while?

Oh well, I'll stop complaining about it because...well, who really cares, BUT I will say that I think it's funny that you'd disregard some pretty important stats for one stat that doesn't really matter as much.

I honestly thank you for doing this as I'm sure it takes a lot of time, I just don't agree with the process of choosing some of the positions.

Good job/luck to all of the nominees.
 
Burdiac
offline
Link
 
In all honesty as GM for the Rockhampton Norseman. I want to say that Boom Stick ash does not deserve the pro bowl nod.He was a backup for most of the time and moved my own DE, JB Funnypapers, (who finished with more tackles, sacks,and hurries than ash) to the right outside linebacker. I back the guam gorillas jay sackster to take his place. Most of the boom stick ashes stats also came by special teams of which their is no category.
 
BobbyBlackk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gazizza
A QB could throw screen passes exclusively and have an insane completion percentage but how does that make him a better QB than one that throws it down field every once in a while?

Oh well, I'll stop complaining about it because...well, who really cares, BUT I will say that I think it's funny that you'd disregard some pretty important stats for one stat that doesn't really matter as much.

I honestly thank you for doing this as I'm sure it takes a lot of time, I just don't agree with the process of choosing some of the positions.

Good job/luck to all of the nominees.


I'm not singling out strictly %'s I do look overall.

I'M CREATING A NEW THREAD NOW FOR PRO BOWL DISCUSSIONS, IN WHICH I WILL KEEP TRACK OF ALL VOTES FOR ENTRIES INTO THE PRO BOWL. The Date & Time for the Ballot is being pushed back until EVERYONE can say the ballot is at minimum of 95% FAIR, b.c in turn, I WILL BE FOLLOWING UP WITH THE PRO BOWL SCORE (Alpha Vs. Zeta) WITH ACTUAL SCORES. So this is for the pride of your conference. Playoffs Rnd.1 begin for you guys today, so WE WILL DISCUSS AND VOTE INTO THE BALLOTS UNTIL Saturday, February 7, 200p - 12:00 AM EST (Noon) SO WE CAN HAVE THE BALLOTS UP THAT NIGHT FOR THE 48HR VOTING PROCESS. People will go on and say; "I really do n't care about a Pro Bowl.." blah blah blah...but let's be honest...spirit is dwindling, and activity is slowing down...let's enjoy ourselves a little bit

 
PitchBlack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gazizza
Quite a bit of bias here but how does the QB that ranks 3rd in passing yards, 2nd in TD's, and threw only ONE INT all year (all the while splitting time 2:1 with his backup QB) not get a nomination? Trapper Helios should be in imo.

I also think that Madieu Winfield (not Williams as previously stated above) should get the nod for one of the CB spots.


Dude, when i saw that Helios Trapper wasn't a top scorer according to the pro-bowl script i was boggled as well man. THERE DEFINITELY no bias here as i wanted to stick to the numbers and let the league vote in and out who they wanted as much as possible. I would willing to second the motion to add him to the ballot

We knew there would be snubs and issues so that's why we are all here to add/remove who we feel should be.
 
gazizza
offline
Link
 
It's all good, I actually feel guilty about complaining as that isn't really my nature and it's just a game and everything. I know that he probably isn't the best in the league, but him being omited from consideration seemed weird to me. Also, thanks for seconding the motion for him
Last edited Feb 4, 2009 07:04:05
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.