User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mrgordy
DMP

No fumbles!

Besides, you HAVE to look at conferences... 8 of the top 10 in rush yards are in the Alpha conference! Me thinks the rushing defense sucks over there.

Also, if you include DMP and the threat he is in all aspects... 600 yards and 11 TDs as a pass option vs. 137 yards and 2 TD.


i'll concede the fumbles, although i don't believe we've had a fumble that has cost us a game- plus fumbles is more of a luck thing if you're carrying/strength/cover up are all high.

Conferences....legitimate argument but lets look at some of edup's high yardage games and how zeta teams matched up when they played that team

vs. Patagonia Predators
Jack edup 288.5
Cartegana Hawkeyes 106

vs. Curitiba Luezards
Jack edup 146
Sao Paulo Snipers 66

vs. Cuzco Inca Warriors
Jack edup 170
Sao Paulo Jaguars 141.5

Too bad the Roosters got a cupcake alpha team cause it makes the comparison even harder to make- DMP may be better, maybe edup is and this will probably all change next season when bort makes changes. However i started this thread for who would win the rushing title and it looks like the title goes to my guy
 
mrgordy
offline
Link
 
No doubt, you had a GREAT season!

I misread the OP, I didn't realize it was just for the rushing title (determined by total rushing yards I presume?)

Congrats!
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
i only click on Zeta when i look at team stats. DMP wins
 
Link
 


DMP
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie

Too bad the Roosters got a cupcake alpha team cause it makes the comparison even harder to make- DMP may be better, maybe edup is and this will probably all change next season when bort makes changes. However i started this thread for who would win the rushing title and it looks like the title goes to my guy


Isn't that phrase redundant?
 
Pheloneus
offline
Link
 
Ok so ill just post what each did against the only 2 common opponents.


MenWith Nuts

Roosters 255-0 SOAP 229-0

DMP 595.5 yds 15 TD's
1 Rcpt 40 Yds 1 TD

635.5 total yds 16 TD's

J Up 461.5 yds 16 TD's
0 Rcpts

461.5 Total yds 16 TD's


Recife Lions

Roosters 151-3 SOAP 41-6

DMP 235 Yds, 6 TD's
3 Rcpts 36 yds 2 TD's

271 Total Yds 8 TD's

J Up 109 Yds, 2 TD's
0 Rcpts

109 Yds 2 TD's


I think we have a winner folks.

There are 5 teams in Alpha that get beat up on week in and week out. Jack EdUp had a great season, and did have a good deal split with his teammate, and for that, I give him kudos on an excellent season.

But the better RB is DMP.
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pheloneus
Ok so ill just post what each did against the only 2 common opponents.


MenWith Nuts

Roosters 255-0 SOAP 229-0

DMP 595.5 yds 15 TD's
1 Rcpt 40 Yds 1 TD

635.5 total yds 16 TD's

J Up 461.5 yds 16 TD's
0 Rcpts

461.5 Total yds 16 TD's


Recife Lions

Roosters 151-3 SOAP 41-6

DMP 235 Yds, 6 TD's
3 Rcpts 36 yds 2 TD's

271 Total Yds 8 TD's

J Up 109 Yds, 2 TD's
0 Rcpts

109 Yds 2 TD's


I think we have a winner folks.

There are 5 teams in Alpha that get beat up on week in and week out. Jack EdUp had a great season, and did have a good deal split with his teammate, and for that, I give him kudos on an excellent season.

But the better RB is DMP.


I'm not trying to blast you too much for this, as it's a pointless argument but using those two comparisons is the stupidest thing i've ever seen. You really gotta pay more attention to other teams in this league. The Lions had gutted themselves AFTER playing SOAP but before playing bogota so that comparison is completely invalid. And while any game against a cupcake is not a fair comparison to make, menwithnuts added higher level CPU players (instead of using lvl 1 offensive players on defense like they did at the beginning of the year)DMP had 7 more carries than jack edup- if you extrapolate an extra 7 carries to edup that's an extra 140 rushing yards (his ypc was 20.1)- that yardage would have put Edup on top against a tougher defense.

Not to say which one is better, but there's no hard evidence to go on and no real way to justify
Last edited Feb 2, 2009 00:53:09
 
drewsky
offline
Link
 
Just wanted to say that Earl Texan ain't no slouch either. Highest YPC in Zeta and probably most broken tackles, too.
 
Pheloneus
offline
Link
 
Good call on differences in teams when played, either way, you had a good year for a Back up. My opinion none the less is still unchanged, DMP is the better RB.
 
Link
 
Congrats on Jack Edup's Rushing Title kuaggie.

Pansy conference or not he put up some great numbers!



DMP
 
missnlife
offline
Link
 
260 yards against the best run D(until today...f'n Roosters!) is pretty solid, edup.

*grumble*
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
yeah, i made some changes to AI. DMP could have padded his stats no doubt
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
yeah, i made some changes to AI. DMP could have padded his stats no doubt


yeah i was expecting it to get VERY close in the last game- i wanted to get dirk a trophy as well but was worried 100% passing might have given DMP the title back.
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
think he got tired from catching all TD passes, backup was in running plays
 
Pheloneus
offline
Link
 
grats Kuaggie , your earned it man.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.