Levels do matter, but theres more to it than just levels. It does no good to have the highest leveled players in the game if you have them out of position and running a poor gameplan. It also doesnt help if you are closer in levels but have much lower chemistry.
My guess is that team doesnt know how to game plan since they are only 8-7 and in 10th place. Combined with their lower chemistry, I'd say thats why you won. However if they knew how to game plan, and had closer chemistry to yours, they would win due to the level difference. Pick a team thats that many levels higher than you and is at least a playoff team with chemistry like yours to prove your point next time. Because this example didnt do it.
for example...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=313135You lost 40-16 to a higher level team.