It's possible, but I do think Bort tends to make sacrifices to keep people quiet than to make changes for the betterment of the game.
Forum > Suggestions > Player Results Affected by Size
ThaOutlaw
offline
offline
Originally posted by kevbk6222
just my $.02. but, if bort decides to go with the "realism" route like his poll then maybe height/weight will matter more? since we are heading for a more realistic game?
That was just for stats, so from what I've seen said around the forums they aren't applying that to builds, sims, ect. Just stats.
Pretty clever.
just my $.02. but, if bort decides to go with the "realism" route like his poll then maybe height/weight will matter more? since we are heading for a more realistic game?
That was just for stats, so from what I've seen said around the forums they aren't applying that to builds, sims, ect. Just stats.
Pretty clever.
ThaOutlaw
offline
offline
Originally posted by Staz
It's possible, but I do think Bort tends to make sacrifices to keep people quiet than to make changes for the betterment of the game.
Yep. However, there have been things he said that makes me think he's just gonna forget um' and make the game how he thinks he should make it.
I could be wrong. Could be just the hope that I have.
It's possible, but I do think Bort tends to make sacrifices to keep people quiet than to make changes for the betterment of the game.
Yep. However, there have been things he said that makes me think he's just gonna forget um' and make the game how he thinks he should make it.
I could be wrong. Could be just the hope that I have.
TerminatorX
offline
offline
I like the idea but O-line times should be able to be higher than 4.99, maybe more like 4.7 to 4.8 ish for a lighter higher speed lineman
kevbk6222
offline
offline
my personal feeling is that all positions should be able to choose what ever weight (minimum 150) and what ever height (max 6'9?) and those two attributes should effect the players attribute rolls and skill soft caps. if a guy wants a 165 DT fine. at the high school level that is plausible. but, against a 350 G who actually is kinda agile he will get smashed most of the time. i just want more customization.
Last edited Jan 29, 2009 19:02:59
flames54
offline
offline
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
all that math hurt my head. but it sounded true. you get a +1 from me.
You do realize that you yourself have the perfect example of why this should not happen. Your elusive back weighs in at 218lbs which is right near the max a hb can weigh so if it's scaled all of a sudden your back will get a pile slower and it's even more out of control than the tradition berfs are.
I don't think height weight should ever matter. If you leave it as random during creation people will just keep rerolling and every single player will weigh the same for certain builds.
There's also the added hitch of you are pretty much locked into your player after creation so you can't even attempt to change him from elusive to power if you wanted to.
all that math hurt my head. but it sounded true. you get a +1 from me.
You do realize that you yourself have the perfect example of why this should not happen. Your elusive back weighs in at 218lbs which is right near the max a hb can weigh so if it's scaled all of a sudden your back will get a pile slower and it's even more out of control than the tradition berfs are.
I don't think height weight should ever matter. If you leave it as random during creation people will just keep rerolling and every single player will weigh the same for certain builds.
There's also the added hitch of you are pretty much locked into your player after creation so you can't even attempt to change him from elusive to power if you wanted to.
ryan_grant-25
offline
offline
Originally posted by flames54
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
all that math hurt my head. but it sounded true. you get a +1 from me.
You do realize that you yourself have the perfect example of why this should not happen. Your elusive back weighs in at 218lbs which is right near the max a hb can weigh so if it's scaled all of a sudden your back will get a pile slower and it's even more out of control than the tradition berfs are.
I don't think height weight should ever matter. If you leave it as random during creation people will just keep rerolling and every single player will weigh the same for certain builds.
There's also the added hitch of you are pretty much locked into your player after creation so you can't even attempt to change him from elusive to power if you wanted to.
didnt think about HBs like this, thought this would just be used to slow the O line down.
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
all that math hurt my head. but it sounded true. you get a +1 from me.
You do realize that you yourself have the perfect example of why this should not happen. Your elusive back weighs in at 218lbs which is right near the max a hb can weigh so if it's scaled all of a sudden your back will get a pile slower and it's even more out of control than the tradition berfs are.
I don't think height weight should ever matter. If you leave it as random during creation people will just keep rerolling and every single player will weigh the same for certain builds.
There's also the added hitch of you are pretty much locked into your player after creation so you can't even attempt to change him from elusive to power if you wanted to.
didnt think about HBs like this, thought this would just be used to slow the O line down.
Apple Dapple
offline
offline
Originally posted by flames54
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
all that math hurt my head. but it sounded true. you get a +1 from me.
You do realize that you yourself have the perfect example of why this should not happen. Your elusive back weighs in at 218lbs which is right near the max a hb can weigh so if it's scaled all of a sudden your back will get a pile slower and it's even more out of control than the tradition berfs are.
I don't think height weight should ever matter. If you leave it as random during creation people will just keep rerolling and every single player will weigh the same for certain builds.
There's also the added hitch of you are pretty much locked into your player after creation so you can't even attempt to change him from elusive to power if you wanted to.
No, because no matter how many times you re-roll you'll never get an OLmen with the appropriate weight to run a 4.3.
btw, you aren't "locked into" anything, really.
There are plenty of 220 lb HB's who are fast and not particularly strong runners. Then there is 205 lb. Maurice Jones-Drew who is powerful little back. You might have a point, maybe, with like... DE's who are 240 as opposed to 290 lbs (I'm not even sure what the constraints on DE's are) but even then, it isn't something that can't be counter-acted by build. The point is, no build should make a DT faster than a speed WR of comparable level.
I see where you're coming from but your argument isn't really that big a knock. The ability to sort of train your weight, however, could go nicely with this.
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
all that math hurt my head. but it sounded true. you get a +1 from me.
You do realize that you yourself have the perfect example of why this should not happen. Your elusive back weighs in at 218lbs which is right near the max a hb can weigh so if it's scaled all of a sudden your back will get a pile slower and it's even more out of control than the tradition berfs are.
I don't think height weight should ever matter. If you leave it as random during creation people will just keep rerolling and every single player will weigh the same for certain builds.
There's also the added hitch of you are pretty much locked into your player after creation so you can't even attempt to change him from elusive to power if you wanted to.
No, because no matter how many times you re-roll you'll never get an OLmen with the appropriate weight to run a 4.3.
btw, you aren't "locked into" anything, really.
There are plenty of 220 lb HB's who are fast and not particularly strong runners. Then there is 205 lb. Maurice Jones-Drew who is powerful little back. You might have a point, maybe, with like... DE's who are 240 as opposed to 290 lbs (I'm not even sure what the constraints on DE's are) but even then, it isn't something that can't be counter-acted by build. The point is, no build should make a DT faster than a speed WR of comparable level.
I see where you're coming from but your argument isn't really that big a knock. The ability to sort of train your weight, however, could go nicely with this.
flames54
offline
offline
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
Originally posted by flames54
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
all that math hurt my head. but it sounded true. you get a +1 from me.
You do realize that you yourself have the perfect example of why this should not happen. Your elusive back weighs in at 218lbs which is right near the max a hb can weigh so if it's scaled all of a sudden your back will get a pile slower and it's even more out of control than the tradition berfs are.
I don't think height weight should ever matter. If you leave it as random during creation people will just keep rerolling and every single player will weigh the same for certain builds.
There's also the added hitch of you are pretty much locked into your player after creation so you can't even attempt to change him from elusive to power if you wanted to.
No, because no matter how many times you re-roll you'll never get an OLmen with the appropriate weight to run a 4.3.
btw, you aren't "locked into" anything, really.
There are plenty of 220 lb HB's who are fast and not particularly strong runners. Then there is 205 lb. Maurice Jones-Drew who is powerful little back. You might have a point, maybe, with like... DE's who are 240 as opposed to 290 lbs (I'm not even sure what the constraints on DE's are) but even then, it isn't something that can't be counter-acted by build. The point is, no build should make a DT faster than a speed WR of comparable level.
I see where you're coming from but your argument isn't really that big a knock. The ability to sort of train your weight, however, could go nicely with this.
If I can choose my height and weight sure, but then everybody will have 6'4 receivers and it'll get boring real fast.
I like it how it is now, just adds some flavour but means very little. Changing how it works now is essentially adding another attribute to the game.
Originally posted by flames54
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
all that math hurt my head. but it sounded true. you get a +1 from me.
You do realize that you yourself have the perfect example of why this should not happen. Your elusive back weighs in at 218lbs which is right near the max a hb can weigh so if it's scaled all of a sudden your back will get a pile slower and it's even more out of control than the tradition berfs are.
I don't think height weight should ever matter. If you leave it as random during creation people will just keep rerolling and every single player will weigh the same for certain builds.
There's also the added hitch of you are pretty much locked into your player after creation so you can't even attempt to change him from elusive to power if you wanted to.
No, because no matter how many times you re-roll you'll never get an OLmen with the appropriate weight to run a 4.3.
btw, you aren't "locked into" anything, really.
There are plenty of 220 lb HB's who are fast and not particularly strong runners. Then there is 205 lb. Maurice Jones-Drew who is powerful little back. You might have a point, maybe, with like... DE's who are 240 as opposed to 290 lbs (I'm not even sure what the constraints on DE's are) but even then, it isn't something that can't be counter-acted by build. The point is, no build should make a DT faster than a speed WR of comparable level.
I see where you're coming from but your argument isn't really that big a knock. The ability to sort of train your weight, however, could go nicely with this.
If I can choose my height and weight sure, but then everybody will have 6'4 receivers and it'll get boring real fast.
I like it how it is now, just adds some flavour but means very little. Changing how it works now is essentially adding another attribute to the game.
Staz
offline
offline
I wouldn't say it's like adding another attribute, just would prohibit 300+lb players from running 4.3 40yd dashes, and being able to bounce around the field like rubber balls.
Running backs weighing 218lbs wouldn't get a hit really. I see plenty of those guys running low 4's, however, a 280lb RB wouldn't be fast in real life, so why should he be able to keep up with a 218lb running back?
Often times you'll see players under 220 running 40's in the 42-4.4 range, players between 220-260 running more in the 4.4-4.6 range, players between 260-280 generally in the 4.6-4.8 range (those are generally heavy DEs and light DTs) and players above 2.8 going more in the 4.9+ range
Of course, those are "fast" times
Running backs weighing 218lbs wouldn't get a hit really. I see plenty of those guys running low 4's, however, a 280lb RB wouldn't be fast in real life, so why should he be able to keep up with a 218lb running back?
Often times you'll see players under 220 running 40's in the 42-4.4 range, players between 220-260 running more in the 4.4-4.6 range, players between 260-280 generally in the 4.6-4.8 range (those are generally heavy DEs and light DTs) and players above 2.8 going more in the 4.9+ range
Of course, those are "fast" times
Last edited Jan 30, 2009 21:15:04
lVlellovv
offline
offline
I would like to be able to train your weight...
and I would like to see Offensive lineman and DTs not outrun a speed WR..just common sense.
and I would like to see Offensive lineman and DTs not outrun a speed WR..just common sense.
Diamonddog
offline
offline
Yeah, I sort of agree, but you have to have something that allows a 320 lb D-lineman to knock the stuffing out of a quick player when he does get ahold of him...
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
offline
Originally posted by ThaOutlaw
Originally posted by Staz
I believe Bort has already knocked down the "caps" for different positions. That, and I think just adding weight into an equation would be a lot more simple, and universal, than singling out positions.
I think you are right, and I think if he's not gonna go for that he's never gonna do anything about it.
He tried to start a thread about it back in the day, and he got blasted by the whiners..so that usually means they win.
Or Bort just went with his gut & allow people putting 100 Speed on an O-lineman to believe they have 100 Speed and not the actual 80 (or whatever) Cap he set.
Originally posted by Staz
I believe Bort has already knocked down the "caps" for different positions. That, and I think just adding weight into an equation would be a lot more simple, and universal, than singling out positions.
I think you are right, and I think if he's not gonna go for that he's never gonna do anything about it.
He tried to start a thread about it back in the day, and he got blasted by the whiners..so that usually means they win.
Or Bort just went with his gut & allow people putting 100 Speed on an O-lineman to believe they have 100 Speed and not the actual 80 (or whatever) Cap he set.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























