Originally posted by TideSpot
Uhh hmmm......ok, as much as I respect the power rankings, I've got to dispute the AREC's number 6 ranking.....and put my 2 cents in.....
Bama beat Brisbane, and lost to the Ghosts by just 4 points. And we pretty much spanked the Guam Gorillas in the"Best of Oceania A" Tournament just a few days ago....
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=356214
And Bama holds the # 3 seed at this point, in the Zeta conference playoffs.
Bama fans have been calling my office all day, insisting I speak up on our behalf, and demand a little respect for our team. So there you go...
Well, let's go through the motions. I think we can both agree that, as the #1 teams in their respective conferences, Florida and Guam deserve the #1 and #2 positions respectively (sorry, I do have to discount the tournament win for these purposes). After that there are three teams currently ranked ahead of you: Newcastle, Brisbane, and Rapid City. Your two losses were to Newcastle and Rapid City, so if lined up directly against either of them for a position in the rankings, you'll lose out. You beat Brisbane, but much to the chagrin of your own ranking, they beat Rapid City.
The end result is a sort of paper-rock-scissors situation not unlike the Big 12 South this past season. You could make arguments for each. Newcastle gave the biggest challenge to the #1 Frenzy, but also have a disappointing loss to a sliding iue5 team on their schedule. Brisbane's losses were both earlier this season and they have been dominant since, even squeaking out a nail-biter against Rapid City. Rapid City's losses were by a total of 11 points: 8 to Florida and 3 in overtime against Brisbane (they got to go first >_> ). Alabama has two losses to very good teams, but one was a blowout, plus 'Bama doesn't have the advantage of Florida as a comparison standard like the others. I imagine this is why you get shafted down to #6, despite being a team that can go toe-to-toe with any of the teams above you.
In all reality, all four of these teams are effectively tied. This isn't a situation where one or two of these teams is pretty much done with tough games for the season, each one has major challenges ahead of them. The last three weeks will be absolute chaos on the rankings. Until it's sorted out, we can all pretty much put our own team on top of the four-way split for decent reasons.
I personally think it should go Florida-Guam-Rapid City-Newcastle-Alabama-Brisbane.
Uhh hmmm......ok, as much as I respect the power rankings, I've got to dispute the AREC's number 6 ranking.....and put my 2 cents in.....
Bama beat Brisbane, and lost to the Ghosts by just 4 points. And we pretty much spanked the Guam Gorillas in the"Best of Oceania A" Tournament just a few days ago....
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=356214
And Bama holds the # 3 seed at this point, in the Zeta conference playoffs.
Bama fans have been calling my office all day, insisting I speak up on our behalf, and demand a little respect for our team. So there you go...

Well, let's go through the motions. I think we can both agree that, as the #1 teams in their respective conferences, Florida and Guam deserve the #1 and #2 positions respectively (sorry, I do have to discount the tournament win for these purposes). After that there are three teams currently ranked ahead of you: Newcastle, Brisbane, and Rapid City. Your two losses were to Newcastle and Rapid City, so if lined up directly against either of them for a position in the rankings, you'll lose out. You beat Brisbane, but much to the chagrin of your own ranking, they beat Rapid City.
The end result is a sort of paper-rock-scissors situation not unlike the Big 12 South this past season. You could make arguments for each. Newcastle gave the biggest challenge to the #1 Frenzy, but also have a disappointing loss to a sliding iue5 team on their schedule. Brisbane's losses were both earlier this season and they have been dominant since, even squeaking out a nail-biter against Rapid City. Rapid City's losses were by a total of 11 points: 8 to Florida and 3 in overtime against Brisbane (they got to go first >_> ). Alabama has two losses to very good teams, but one was a blowout, plus 'Bama doesn't have the advantage of Florida as a comparison standard like the others. I imagine this is why you get shafted down to #6, despite being a team that can go toe-to-toe with any of the teams above you.
In all reality, all four of these teams are effectively tied. This isn't a situation where one or two of these teams is pretty much done with tough games for the season, each one has major challenges ahead of them. The last three weeks will be absolute chaos on the rankings. Until it's sorted out, we can all pretty much put our own team on top of the four-way split for decent reasons.
I personally think it should go Florida-Guam-Rapid City-Newcastle-Alabama-Brisbane.
Last edited Jan 28, 2009 21:35:24





























