valid point.. know of any others outside BBB10?
Pimpfrogs
offline
offline
Head to head with the Thunder this week... Goin' to cause a pantie melt down!!!!!!!!!!
Mr. Me2
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sanderval
Originally posted by silenthatred
Against the lolteams...I agree!
Um.. we (in the east) all play the same "lolteams" do we not? So if she does better against said lolteams, and manages to keep the averages up against what i assume you would call the "non lolteams"... she's got a valid argument at the "best returner" label. I seem to recall her doing better against most of her returning counterparts on a Per game basis.. i'm sure this all sounds rather myopic, and i haven't really checked the numbers.. so i'll do that now..
I present, courtney vs the league:
Numbers are KR Yds Avg TD PR Yds Avg TD
Game 1 Courtney 1 League 0
CB Princess Courtney 2 49.5 24.8 0 18 448.5 24.9 2
HB Dr. Emmit Brown 12 220.5 18.4 0 0 0 0 0
HB Francisco Kaiser 9 156.5 17.4 0 0 0 0 0
Game 2 Courtney 2 League 0
CB Princess Courtney 2 57 28.5 0 10 172 17.2 0
HB Lex Currie 7 144.5 20.6 0 4 43.5 10.9 0
Game 3 Courtney 3 League 0
HB "Radar" O'Reilly 12 217 18.1 0 0 0 0 0
CB Princess Courtney 2 49 24.5 0 7 105 15 0
Game 4 Split decision even though its 2 vs 1 CB had a better avg
Courtney 3.5 League 0.5
CB Princess Courtney 2 39.5 19.8 0 8 139 17.4 0
[bCB George "Woodenteeth" Washington 10 210.5 21.1 0 0 0 0 0
HB Slow As A Turtle 0 0 0 0 3 36 12 0
Game 5 Courtney 4.5 League 0.5
HB Speed Smoak 7 131 18.7 0 4 40 10 0
CB Princess Courtney 2 45.5 22.8 0 8 157.5 19.7 1
Game 6 Courtney 5.5 League 0.5
CB Princess Courtney 2 55.5 27.8 0 9 153.5 17.1 0
CB Curts Scott III 9 157.5 17.5 0 4 26 6.5 0
Game 7 Returner was CPU, won't count
Game 8 Courtney 6.5 League 0.5
CB Princess Courtney 2 60 30 0 14 349.5 25 1
CB Wayne Carter III 12 237 19.8 0 2 22 11 0
HB Mario Stokes 3 43.5 14.5 0 0 0 0 0
Game 9 Courtney 7.5 League 0.5
HB Rikkun Kaitani 2 30 15 0 0 0 0 0
CB Mexican Jumping Beans 0 0 0 0 6 60 10 0
CB Princess Courtney 4 87 21.8 0 7 79 11.3 0
Game 10 Another split decision
Courtney 8 League 1
CB Princess Courtney 1 22 22 0 11 161.5 14.7 0
HB John McDonogh 14 221 15.8 0 0 0 0 0
CB Christopher "Kid" Reid 0 0 0 0 1 16 16 0
Game 11
Courtney 9 League 1
HB Chad McFadden 12 230.5 19.2 0 0 0 0 0
WR Math Young 4 72.5 18.1 0 0 0 0 0
CB Princess Courtney 2 56 28 0 12 322.5 26.9 2
Game 12
Courtney 10 League 1
CB Princess Courtney 1 27 27 0 36 801.5 22.3 14
FB Kevin Costner 41 588 14.3 0 0 0 0 0
Now.. without checking teams, rule out 6 of what you would consider to be "lolteams" assuming you think half the conference isn't competitive. At best... she still outperformed her counterparts head to head more often than not. At best she split with any given team. With her worst performances resulting in a draw. There's probably only 1, maybe 2 other returners in the league that could say the same, with that one most likely belonging to Keg River & Oshawa (if memory serves, i could be mistaken about that) and of those two, one is 2nd in PR avg, one in KR avg. You could argue she has fewer attempts than both of them, but then again, neither of them are ranked high in both KR and PR.. but as you can see from the box scores, she's doing both KR and PR while most teams divide the position so Courtney is doing both, and excelling at both while her competitors, for the most part, are only doing 1.
I'm not even going to bother wasting my time reading this, because comparing the opposite returner on an inferior team vs. her's on a superior team is a one-sided, non-objective argument...The only non lolteam she had a TD against was Keg River Boozehounds. And they are barely out of the lol zone and I can only assume they have problems with builds or gameplanning given the way they are losing with the level team they have. If she returns a punt for a TD against us, I'll be on board, until then, loldots, or in this case, loldot!
Originally posted by silenthatred
Against the lolteams...I agree!
Um.. we (in the east) all play the same "lolteams" do we not? So if she does better against said lolteams, and manages to keep the averages up against what i assume you would call the "non lolteams"... she's got a valid argument at the "best returner" label. I seem to recall her doing better against most of her returning counterparts on a Per game basis.. i'm sure this all sounds rather myopic, and i haven't really checked the numbers.. so i'll do that now..
I present, courtney vs the league:
Numbers are KR Yds Avg TD PR Yds Avg TD
Game 1 Courtney 1 League 0
CB Princess Courtney 2 49.5 24.8 0 18 448.5 24.9 2
HB Dr. Emmit Brown 12 220.5 18.4 0 0 0 0 0
HB Francisco Kaiser 9 156.5 17.4 0 0 0 0 0
Game 2 Courtney 2 League 0
CB Princess Courtney 2 57 28.5 0 10 172 17.2 0
HB Lex Currie 7 144.5 20.6 0 4 43.5 10.9 0
Game 3 Courtney 3 League 0
HB "Radar" O'Reilly 12 217 18.1 0 0 0 0 0
CB Princess Courtney 2 49 24.5 0 7 105 15 0
Game 4 Split decision even though its 2 vs 1 CB had a better avg
Courtney 3.5 League 0.5
CB Princess Courtney 2 39.5 19.8 0 8 139 17.4 0
[bCB George "Woodenteeth" Washington 10 210.5 21.1 0 0 0 0 0
HB Slow As A Turtle 0 0 0 0 3 36 12 0
Game 5 Courtney 4.5 League 0.5
HB Speed Smoak 7 131 18.7 0 4 40 10 0
CB Princess Courtney 2 45.5 22.8 0 8 157.5 19.7 1
Game 6 Courtney 5.5 League 0.5
CB Princess Courtney 2 55.5 27.8 0 9 153.5 17.1 0
CB Curts Scott III 9 157.5 17.5 0 4 26 6.5 0
Game 7 Returner was CPU, won't count
Game 8 Courtney 6.5 League 0.5
CB Princess Courtney 2 60 30 0 14 349.5 25 1
CB Wayne Carter III 12 237 19.8 0 2 22 11 0
HB Mario Stokes 3 43.5 14.5 0 0 0 0 0
Game 9 Courtney 7.5 League 0.5
HB Rikkun Kaitani 2 30 15 0 0 0 0 0
CB Mexican Jumping Beans 0 0 0 0 6 60 10 0
CB Princess Courtney 4 87 21.8 0 7 79 11.3 0
Game 10 Another split decision
Courtney 8 League 1
CB Princess Courtney 1 22 22 0 11 161.5 14.7 0
HB John McDonogh 14 221 15.8 0 0 0 0 0
CB Christopher "Kid" Reid 0 0 0 0 1 16 16 0
Game 11
Courtney 9 League 1
HB Chad McFadden 12 230.5 19.2 0 0 0 0 0
WR Math Young 4 72.5 18.1 0 0 0 0 0
CB Princess Courtney 2 56 28 0 12 322.5 26.9 2
Game 12
Courtney 10 League 1
CB Princess Courtney 1 27 27 0 36 801.5 22.3 14
FB Kevin Costner 41 588 14.3 0 0 0 0 0
Now.. without checking teams, rule out 6 of what you would consider to be "lolteams" assuming you think half the conference isn't competitive. At best... she still outperformed her counterparts head to head more often than not. At best she split with any given team. With her worst performances resulting in a draw. There's probably only 1, maybe 2 other returners in the league that could say the same, with that one most likely belonging to Keg River & Oshawa (if memory serves, i could be mistaken about that) and of those two, one is 2nd in PR avg, one in KR avg. You could argue she has fewer attempts than both of them, but then again, neither of them are ranked high in both KR and PR.. but as you can see from the box scores, she's doing both KR and PR while most teams divide the position so Courtney is doing both, and excelling at both while her competitors, for the most part, are only doing 1.
I'm not even going to bother wasting my time reading this, because comparing the opposite returner on an inferior team vs. her's on a superior team is a one-sided, non-objective argument...The only non lolteam she had a TD against was Keg River Boozehounds. And they are barely out of the lol zone and I can only assume they have problems with builds or gameplanning given the way they are losing with the level team they have. If she returns a punt for a TD against us, I'll be on board, until then, loldots, or in this case, loldot!
Bigkevinking
offline
offline
"Now.. without checking teams, rule out 6 of what you would consider to be "lolteams" assuming you think half the conference isn't competitive. At best... she still outperformed her counterparts head to head more often than not. At best she split with any given team. With her worst performances resulting in a draw. There's probably only 1, maybe 2 other returners in the league that could say the same, with that one most likely belonging to Keg River & Oshawa (if memory serves, i could be mistaken about that) and of those two, one is 2nd in PR avg, one in KR avg. You could argue she has fewer attempts than both of them, but then again, neither of them are ranked high in both KR and PR.. but as you can see from the box scores, she's doing both KR and PR while most teams divide the position so Courtney is doing both, and excelling at both while her competitors, for the most part, are only doing 1."
Keg River is 2nd in PR and 22 in KR, Jacks are 2nd in KR and PR. I say Courtney is the best, she can do both. There will always be lol teams there to screw with a teams/players stats. Courtney is 10-1 in your opinion and that shows she is the best.
Keg River is 2nd in PR and 22 in KR, Jacks are 2nd in KR and PR. I say Courtney is the best, she can do both. There will always be lol teams there to screw with a teams/players stats. Courtney is 10-1 in your opinion and that shows she is the best.
Sanderval
offline
offline
To silent: It's perfectly fine if you don't agree, i just put the numbers out there because those were the easiest to obtain. I'm sure there's someway to account for the differences in teams and how that effects the players ability to perform, but I don't know what that is. I never really gave a lot of weight to the PR TDs for the reasons you mentioned, but it should still count for something, otherwise everyone would do it. I highly doubt there will be a PR TD against Carolina though.
I can see the point in your disapproval of the team vs team comparison also. So other than scoring a PR TD specifically against Carolina, how would you measure a returners ability? What's your criteria? Is there even a best? Do we compare everyone's returns vs the top teams and rule out the rest? Or maybe you don't care.. which is fine as well.. just curious on how you see it.
Your argument does put an interesting wrinkle into the equation though.. because if Keg River is "barely out of the lol zone" that makes their ranking in PR even more significant, so maybe they have a legit claim at best PR.
I can see the point in your disapproval of the team vs team comparison also. So other than scoring a PR TD specifically against Carolina, how would you measure a returners ability? What's your criteria? Is there even a best? Do we compare everyone's returns vs the top teams and rule out the rest? Or maybe you don't care.. which is fine as well.. just curious on how you see it.
Your argument does put an interesting wrinkle into the equation though.. because if Keg River is "barely out of the lol zone" that makes their ranking in PR even more significant, so maybe they have a legit claim at best PR.
Mr. Me2
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bigkevinking
"Now.. without checking teams, rule out 6 of what you would consider to be "lolteams" assuming you think half the conference isn't competitive. At best... she still outperformed her counterparts head to head more often than not. At best she split with any given team. With her worst performances resulting in a draw. There's probably only 1, maybe 2 other returners in the league that could say the same, with that one most likely belonging to Keg River & Oshawa (if memory serves, i could be mistaken about that) and of those two, one is 2nd in PR avg, one in KR avg. You could argue she has fewer attempts than both of them, but then again, neither of them are ranked high in both KR and PR.. but as you can see from the box scores, she's doing both KR and PR while most teams divide the position so Courtney is doing both, and excelling at both while her competitors, for the most part, are only doing 1."
Keg River is 2nd in PR and 22 in KR, Jacks are 2nd in KR and PR. I say Courtney is the best, she can do both. There will always be lol teams there to screw with a teams/players stats. Courtney is 10-1 in your opinion and that shows she is the best.
Well to say without checking teams would say that I have the schedule the Jakes played as well as all their opponents memorized. Sorry but I do not. I simply looked at all the games the return TD were in. All but one was against a lolteam. Everything you said pretty much goes along with what I was saying before. The Jakes were the superior team. Football, being a team game, requires more than one player for a good kick or punt return to happen. So using the head to head argument is really invalid because it doesn't take into account the 20 other loldots on the field. In the majority of those games the TDs happened it, it could have been the speed DE returning punts and there would have been scores. Hell, let my QB get a shot!
Sanderval...As far as how I rate it, you are right, I really don't care. I simply thing threads like this are generally a joke, because they usually are. And the inflated numbers can usually be attributed to loldots. If you were going to attempt to make some sort of rankings, it would have to be among even level teams and yes throw out the garbage. To act like all teams are created equal is just not true. If all the teams were of even level player builds, it would be one thing, but they are not. If we are just going with head to head, then Zag Mann is the best RB ever!
For example:
vs Versailles PR 7 Yards 79 Avg 11.3
vs Vancouver PR 9 Yards 153.5 Avg 17.1
vs Keg City PR 8 Yards 157.5 Avg 19.7 TD 1
Are those respectable numbers? Sure. Good even. Some might say great. But they are far from the over inflated stats that put the Jakes at 2nd in KR and PR. If you are going to throw those numbers around, then you are including the lolteams, which makes the whole thing loldots! And still doesn't take into account that the Jakes ST dots are better than the ST dots of their opponents. In short, it has less to do with the returners player build and more to do with the competitions. There are a number of dots that would do the same or better returning punts for the Jakes.
"Now.. without checking teams, rule out 6 of what you would consider to be "lolteams" assuming you think half the conference isn't competitive. At best... she still outperformed her counterparts head to head more often than not. At best she split with any given team. With her worst performances resulting in a draw. There's probably only 1, maybe 2 other returners in the league that could say the same, with that one most likely belonging to Keg River & Oshawa (if memory serves, i could be mistaken about that) and of those two, one is 2nd in PR avg, one in KR avg. You could argue she has fewer attempts than both of them, but then again, neither of them are ranked high in both KR and PR.. but as you can see from the box scores, she's doing both KR and PR while most teams divide the position so Courtney is doing both, and excelling at both while her competitors, for the most part, are only doing 1."
Keg River is 2nd in PR and 22 in KR, Jacks are 2nd in KR and PR. I say Courtney is the best, she can do both. There will always be lol teams there to screw with a teams/players stats. Courtney is 10-1 in your opinion and that shows she is the best.
Well to say without checking teams would say that I have the schedule the Jakes played as well as all their opponents memorized. Sorry but I do not. I simply looked at all the games the return TD were in. All but one was against a lolteam. Everything you said pretty much goes along with what I was saying before. The Jakes were the superior team. Football, being a team game, requires more than one player for a good kick or punt return to happen. So using the head to head argument is really invalid because it doesn't take into account the 20 other loldots on the field. In the majority of those games the TDs happened it, it could have been the speed DE returning punts and there would have been scores. Hell, let my QB get a shot!
Sanderval...As far as how I rate it, you are right, I really don't care. I simply thing threads like this are generally a joke, because they usually are. And the inflated numbers can usually be attributed to loldots. If you were going to attempt to make some sort of rankings, it would have to be among even level teams and yes throw out the garbage. To act like all teams are created equal is just not true. If all the teams were of even level player builds, it would be one thing, but they are not. If we are just going with head to head, then Zag Mann is the best RB ever!
For example:
vs Versailles PR 7 Yards 79 Avg 11.3
vs Vancouver PR 9 Yards 153.5 Avg 17.1
vs Keg City PR 8 Yards 157.5 Avg 19.7 TD 1
Are those respectable numbers? Sure. Good even. Some might say great. But they are far from the over inflated stats that put the Jakes at 2nd in KR and PR. If you are going to throw those numbers around, then you are including the lolteams, which makes the whole thing loldots! And still doesn't take into account that the Jakes ST dots are better than the ST dots of their opponents. In short, it has less to do with the returners player build and more to do with the competitions. There are a number of dots that would do the same or better returning punts for the Jakes.
Last edited Jan 25, 2009 16:49:31
Bigkevinking
offline
offline
I do agree with silenthatred, he makes valid points. Just like real life we can only wonder how players would be on different teams. Like I remember in the early 2000's my family would talk about the difference between Brady and Manning and the difference was that Manning had superior WRs. We will see how Courtney does in A next season with teams that will have players at the same caliber of the Jakes.
Sanderval
offline
offline
Fair enough. Thanks for chiming with valid points even if you don't have much of a stake in the results. And it's not so much i think all teams are equal, i'm just going with the numbers given. They aren't perfect, but at the end of the day that's what we use to assign final ranks. I was more interested in getting constructive feedback from an opposing or parallel viewpoint. You never know how information will benefit you down the line..
I wouldn't sell Zag's accomplishments too short though, granted it may not have been a lot, you still have to do what you can when you can.
I wouldn't sell Zag's accomplishments too short though, granted it may not have been a lot, you still have to do what you can when you can.
byrongame21
offline
offline
So if we are in agreement that all teams are not created equal, why even bother caring about stats at any position? Marvin Harrison is obviously only a good WR because Peyton Manning has been throwing him the ball for the majority of his career? Or maybe Manning is rather average in real life but was lucky enough to have WRs like Harrison, Wayne, and Stokley, and a receiving TE like Clark to throw to? Emmitt Smith was a great RB, but also ran behind some phenomenal O-lines during his career and maybe would not be looked upon so highly otherwise. Maybe Jerry Rice was only good because Montana and Young threw to him for the majority of his career? Maybe the Cardinals only made the playoffs because they won their pathetic division, but in reality don't deserve to be there? If not stats, what is your ultimate barometer? Wins and losses... alright then lets just let Versailles represent the East and skip the playoffs. Or maybe's it's championships... which would make Trent Dilfer a better QB than Dan Marino.
I agree that the system is flawed, no doubt about it. Stats are far more complex than the simple numbers that represent them. But to say that stats mean nothing just doesn't make much sense to me. Is Princess Courtney the best returner in this conference? That's obviously highly debatable considering the arguments already stated above. I just don't think you can throw stats out of the equation completely by any means.
I agree that the system is flawed, no doubt about it. Stats are far more complex than the simple numbers that represent them. But to say that stats mean nothing just doesn't make much sense to me. Is Princess Courtney the best returner in this conference? That's obviously highly debatable considering the arguments already stated above. I just don't think you can throw stats out of the equation completely by any means.
Mr. Me2
offline
offline
Originally posted by byrongame21
So if we are in agreement that all teams are not created equal, why even bother caring about stats at any position? Marvin Harrison is obviously only a good WR because Peyton Manning has been throwing him the ball for the majority of his career? Or maybe Manning is rather average in real life but was lucky enough to have WRs like Harrison, Wayne, and Stokley, and a receiving TE like Clark to throw to? Emmitt Smith was a great RB, but also ran behind some phenomenal O-lines during his career and maybe would not be looked upon so highly otherwise. Maybe Jerry Rice was only good because Montana and Young threw to him for the majority of his career? Maybe the Cardinals only made the playoffs because they won their pathetic division, but in reality don't deserve to be there? If not stats, what is your ultimate barometer? Wins and losses... alright then lets just let Versailles represent the East and skip the playoffs. Or maybe's it's championships... which would make Trent Dilfer a better QB than Dan Marino.
I agree that the system is flawed, no doubt about it. Stats are far more complex than the simple numbers that represent them. But to say that stats mean nothing just doesn't make much sense to me. Is Princess Courtney the best returner in this conference? That's obviously highly debatable considering the arguments already stated above. I just don't think you can throw stats out of the equation completely by any means.
I read the first two sentences, got to Marvin Harrison and Peyton Manning and stopped. This is dot ball. NFL teams all have something in common. They are full of players in the NFL! They are all at the same level. Even Detroit is full of NFL players. That same Detroit Lions team might not be that good in the NFL, but you can pick the college team to play them and watch said college team get dominated by players that are bigger, strong and faster. Said college team would do the same to a high school team and right down the ladder. That's basically what we have here. A bunch of teams at various levels, but all in the same league in this game. You'll be hard pressed to find a league, or conference even, in this game where players are of all the same caliber. Real life comparisons don't apply. If you couldn't already tell from the 255-0 scores.
So if we are in agreement that all teams are not created equal, why even bother caring about stats at any position? Marvin Harrison is obviously only a good WR because Peyton Manning has been throwing him the ball for the majority of his career? Or maybe Manning is rather average in real life but was lucky enough to have WRs like Harrison, Wayne, and Stokley, and a receiving TE like Clark to throw to? Emmitt Smith was a great RB, but also ran behind some phenomenal O-lines during his career and maybe would not be looked upon so highly otherwise. Maybe Jerry Rice was only good because Montana and Young threw to him for the majority of his career? Maybe the Cardinals only made the playoffs because they won their pathetic division, but in reality don't deserve to be there? If not stats, what is your ultimate barometer? Wins and losses... alright then lets just let Versailles represent the East and skip the playoffs. Or maybe's it's championships... which would make Trent Dilfer a better QB than Dan Marino.
I agree that the system is flawed, no doubt about it. Stats are far more complex than the simple numbers that represent them. But to say that stats mean nothing just doesn't make much sense to me. Is Princess Courtney the best returner in this conference? That's obviously highly debatable considering the arguments already stated above. I just don't think you can throw stats out of the equation completely by any means.
I read the first two sentences, got to Marvin Harrison and Peyton Manning and stopped. This is dot ball. NFL teams all have something in common. They are full of players in the NFL! They are all at the same level. Even Detroit is full of NFL players. That same Detroit Lions team might not be that good in the NFL, but you can pick the college team to play them and watch said college team get dominated by players that are bigger, strong and faster. Said college team would do the same to a high school team and right down the ladder. That's basically what we have here. A bunch of teams at various levels, but all in the same league in this game. You'll be hard pressed to find a league, or conference even, in this game where players are of all the same caliber. Real life comparisons don't apply. If you couldn't already tell from the 255-0 scores.
fooliopimp
offline
offline
But point being, Princess Courtney is still one of the top returners in Canada BBB 10, regardless if the teams are good or bad. Against the good teams, that player returns better on average, and that player runs all over the bad teams. Granted, the teams are bad, but Princess Courtney still runs over the bad teams, better than most other returners?
But this is a moot point; I think Stewart is a better returner imho. (In CAN BBB 10)
But this is a moot point; I think Stewart is a better returner imho. (In CAN BBB 10)
byrongame21
offline
offline
Originally posted by silenthatred
Originally posted by byrongame21
So if we are in agreement that all teams are not created equal, why even bother caring about stats at any position? Marvin Harrison is obviously only a good WR because Peyton Manning has been throwing him the ball for the majority of his career? Or maybe Manning is rather average in real life but was lucky enough to have WRs like Harrison, Wayne, and Stokley, and a receiving TE like Clark to throw to? Emmitt Smith was a great RB, but also ran behind some phenomenal O-lines during his career and maybe would not be looked upon so highly otherwise. Maybe Jerry Rice was only good because Montana and Young threw to him for the majority of his career? Maybe the Cardinals only made the playoffs because they won their pathetic division, but in reality don't deserve to be there? If not stats, what is your ultimate barometer? Wins and losses... alright then lets just let Versailles represent the East and skip the playoffs. Or maybe's it's championships... which would make Trent Dilfer a better QB than Dan Marino.
I agree that the system is flawed, no doubt about it. Stats are far more complex than the simple numbers that represent them. But to say that stats mean nothing just doesn't make much sense to me. Is Princess Courtney the best returner in this conference? That's obviously highly debatable considering the arguments already stated above. I just don't think you can throw stats out of the equation completely by any means.
I read the first two sentences, got to Marvin Harrison and Peyton Manning and stopped. This is dot ball. NFL teams all have something in common. They are full of players in the NFL! They are all at the same level. Even Detroit is full of NFL players. That same Detroit Lions team might not be that good in the NFL, but you can pick the college team to play them and watch said college team get dominated by players that are bigger, strong and faster. Said college team would do the same to a high school team and right down the ladder. That's basically what we have here. A bunch of teams at various levels, but all in the same league in this game. You'll be hard pressed to find a league, or conference even, in this game where players are of all the same caliber. Real life comparisons don't apply. If you couldn't already tell from the 255-0 scores.
Yes, which I thought you had previously established with your whole idea of only comparing the games against similar-leveled opponents. I'm not talking about the lolteams that you talk about, I'm talking about the top tier teams that have similar players of similar ability. You can't completely abandon stats in this game, unless you wanna try and scout every play-by-play, which we all know nobody has even a tenth of the time to do. A barometer is needed, no matter how imperfect it may be.
Originally posted by byrongame21
So if we are in agreement that all teams are not created equal, why even bother caring about stats at any position? Marvin Harrison is obviously only a good WR because Peyton Manning has been throwing him the ball for the majority of his career? Or maybe Manning is rather average in real life but was lucky enough to have WRs like Harrison, Wayne, and Stokley, and a receiving TE like Clark to throw to? Emmitt Smith was a great RB, but also ran behind some phenomenal O-lines during his career and maybe would not be looked upon so highly otherwise. Maybe Jerry Rice was only good because Montana and Young threw to him for the majority of his career? Maybe the Cardinals only made the playoffs because they won their pathetic division, but in reality don't deserve to be there? If not stats, what is your ultimate barometer? Wins and losses... alright then lets just let Versailles represent the East and skip the playoffs. Or maybe's it's championships... which would make Trent Dilfer a better QB than Dan Marino.
I agree that the system is flawed, no doubt about it. Stats are far more complex than the simple numbers that represent them. But to say that stats mean nothing just doesn't make much sense to me. Is Princess Courtney the best returner in this conference? That's obviously highly debatable considering the arguments already stated above. I just don't think you can throw stats out of the equation completely by any means.
I read the first two sentences, got to Marvin Harrison and Peyton Manning and stopped. This is dot ball. NFL teams all have something in common. They are full of players in the NFL! They are all at the same level. Even Detroit is full of NFL players. That same Detroit Lions team might not be that good in the NFL, but you can pick the college team to play them and watch said college team get dominated by players that are bigger, strong and faster. Said college team would do the same to a high school team and right down the ladder. That's basically what we have here. A bunch of teams at various levels, but all in the same league in this game. You'll be hard pressed to find a league, or conference even, in this game where players are of all the same caliber. Real life comparisons don't apply. If you couldn't already tell from the 255-0 scores.
Yes, which I thought you had previously established with your whole idea of only comparing the games against similar-leveled opponents. I'm not talking about the lolteams that you talk about, I'm talking about the top tier teams that have similar players of similar ability. You can't completely abandon stats in this game, unless you wanna try and scout every play-by-play, which we all know nobody has even a tenth of the time to do. A barometer is needed, no matter how imperfect it may be.
ac74ecu
offline
offline
Do people really read this much?!?!
LOL...good game Jakes...we'll meet again in the playoffs!
LOL...good game Jakes...we'll meet again in the playoffs!
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























