Originally posted by Animalmother
Nerf motivational speaker...when we have no idea how much it even effects a moral. Dont forget nobody has any idea how in game moral even works.
I propose we nerf Clutch because I hypothesize that its the root of all the DE issues /sarcasmWell, bort just admitted that it could be part of the problem... and it's undeniable that broken tackles are way up, and that fumbles are way down. Even if you attribute the broken tackles to VAs, that does NOTHING to explain the lack of fumbles, especially when rushing attempts are also way up across the board. One can also safely make the assumption that a back with higher morale is more likely to break a tackle than one with low morale based on all of the moral lowering SA's say that by lowering the players morale, they'll be easier to tackle.
So, at the worst, I think nerfing Motivational Speaker would bring powerbacks back down to a reasonable level... and at best, I think it would tone down a lot of the wacky things on offense this year (like, a lot of the deflected passes seen on streaks and whatnot I bet wouldn't be caught with lower morale). Either way, I don't think it'd be a terribly hard thing to check (bort wouldn't even have to watch film, just run a ton of games with MV and look at the numbers, and then run those same games without MV speaker.) and could have a HUGE effect on the sim.
edit:
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Blamo
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Blamo
rather than adding new VAs, I'd rather see some of the current ones balanced. Most notably Motivational Speaker, which I still hypothesize to be one of the main reasons offenses (powerbacks specifically) are out of control this season.
That may be part of low fumbles and high brktackles, but there are a couple of long-standing problems with certain defense reactions that contribute to higher scores as well, that show up from time to time (like CB's moving forward to cover streak routes and getting blown by, etc). I've been focusing on those recently more than anything.
I know you're a busy man, but is there any chance you'll get the time to test it and maybe see if this is the case? I'd imagine a Motivational Speaker change would be a lot simpler (and less time consuming) to implement than a lot of the of the other defensive issues, but would probably help out the defense a lot while these other bugs are being ironed out.
Of course, beggars can't be choosers and I'll be happy with whatever you decide to fix 
Mot Speaker works exactly as intended currently. The actual morale boost isn't all that big, and it still takes confidence into account. Over the course of several plays, though, I guess I could see one side of the ball getting boosted back up to near full. I suppose I could run a bunch of games with a K or P with 15 MS and then run a bunch with the skill disabled and compare final stats.
I've seen the idea to make it only affect 5 random players or something. That might work alright. Or maybe some of the SA's and such just need a larger morale hit than they currently do. Hard to tell without a bunch o testing.Well, the thing that I'm worried about is the cumulative boost of it. Especially since at this point I imagine that teams have such good rotations that it would be hard to sustain any sort of morale drop. And even if you do get a decent morale hit, as soon as your offense gets a chance to rest they're able to get a chunk of it back.
Either way, I'd at least like to know if it IS the problem. If it's not the problem, and powerbacks have just figured out how to break 20 tackles a game... I'll adjust my build accordingly. But if it's because the punter is jacking up their morale all game, that seems kind of unfair.