User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Has anybody tried simply demoralizing powerbacks this year?
Page:
 
boondocksaint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Mordaloch

hey Blamo, so you saying, say people 3x capped tackling for example got it like 70's 80's with equipment that increases chance of fumbles forced according to bort?


According to Bort? Yes
According to the sim? No, not really.

I'm looking at a player with 73 tackling and 65 strength who hasn't forced a fumble for two seasons, in around 70 tackles.


Quite truthfully, I've not seen anything that verifiably increases fumbles. How many fumbles have any of you all seen this season regardless of SA's/strength/tackling att's?
 
Link
 
I think the problem is that every time a power back breaks a tackle, his morale increases.

And it's not "simple"
 
Mordaloch
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Mordaloch

hey Blamo, so you saying, say people 3x capped tackling for example got it like 70's 80's with equipment that increases chance of fumbles forced according to bort?


According to Bort? Yes
According to the sim? No, not really.

I'm looking at a player with 73 tackling and 65 strength who hasn't forced a fumble for two seasons, in around 70 tackles.


yeah i noticed that in this game just don't see that many fumbles unless there is a big level difference and at that point who cares i want to increase my chances to force fumbles against equal level competition and i want to find something that works. problem is a lot of this is left up to us guys who try to think outside the box and often get criticism for our (non cookie-cutter type builds) when we try to experiment with things. /shrug
 
Blamo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mordaloch
hey Blamo, so you saying, say people 3x capped tackling for example got it like 70's 80's with equipment that increases chance of fumbles forced according to bort?


Yeah, that's what Bort says, at least. Like Deathblade, it's kind of questionable up to this point, though. There are other factors involved, though, such as momentum of the players and whatnot. So I don't think a slow player with 90 tackling is going to force many more fumbles than a fast player with 50 tackling, you know? At this point it's a matter of finding the right balance, I guess. I'd like to try 90 speed/60 strength/68 tackling to see how that would do, but since I'm traditionally a speed guy, even moving equipment around won't give me those kind of numbers yet

Originally posted by pottsman
I know of one pro team that decided to heavily invest in the hard hitters tree for their LBs after the beginning of the season, when they missed a lot of tackles. Said pro team isn't doing too well, but their missed tackles are way down over the last 4 games.


Interesting. Do you know which skills they worked on most?
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mordaloch

yeah i noticed that in this game just don't see that many fumbles unless there is a big level difference and at that point who cares i want to increase my chances to force fumbles against equal level competition and i want to find something that works. problem is a lot of this is left up to us guys who try to think outside the box and often get criticism for our (non cookie-cutter type builds) when we try to experiment with things. /shrug


All of my players are test players to be quite honest.
 
Blamo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
I think the problem is that every time a power back breaks a tackle, his morale increases.

And it's not "simple"


Yeah, but his morale can't be above 100. So even if he breaks a few tackles at first, his morale can't go any higher... Then hopefully Big/Monster hit will do more damage to his morale than a broken tackle will increase. And unless a guy is breaking 4 or 5 tackles on EVERY play (and I don't think the problem is quite that bad) you should hopefully be able to get a string where you can get a monster hit, a couple regular tackles, and maybe a TFL to bring him down to earth a little bit. Then that at least levels the playing ground to a fairly "normal" level. Then I guess it's a matter of if the powerback is lucky enough to get a few broken tackles (small morale boost) break out a big run for a TD (huge morale boost) or if the defense is lucky to cause a couple more big hits/TFL (small-medium morale drains) or cause a fumble (big morale drain), or if it sits somewhere in the middle. Obviously, it's not at all a guarantee... but I think it would at least bring the defense even with powerbacks, which is something that most teams are struggling to do right now.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Blamo
My only suggestion, like I said, would be to try and jack your strength/tackling up as high as possible for the players that you DO decide to try this with. I think MLB is probably the position I'd try it with, since I think you lose the least there from having a slower player and I think from the MLB position is where you'd get to the powerback most often... Not to mention if you want D-General, you have to travel down that path anyways. I don't know if I'd shift more than that into it, though. Even if your OLBs are speed heavy, they should be able to "drag" the HB long enough for the MLB to get there and hopefully lay the beef onto the back. I think that SS's have the best SAs to get this kind of thing done, but I don't know if that's a position where I'd want to consistently sacrifice that much speed/utility to try and stop powerbacks. It's too bad the defense doesn't have anything like the TE1/2 for certain play packages to give the defense that kind of flexibility.


You're on the right track. The MLB position is very critical for stopping the run game. Agility is a slightly more important ability over speed. He needs to be able to move side to side and make quick cuts, but you can't neglect speed too much because he has to cover backs coming out in pass coverage, or double receivers, ect.

What some don't realize is that LBs are very difficult to perfect because of the high # of skills that are important for their positions. I wouldn't say I'm an expert but I've got several that are pretty good, and IMO what you want is for your LOLB to be the most balanced because he needs to be able to tackle and cover the TE in man coverage, so that it frees up your SS to run blitz. The MLB should be the field general with the strongest tackling ability and run stopping SAs. Most of the time the LOLB will not be able to contain an off tackle run by himself and it's the MLB that provides support. The ROLB needs to be your speedier guy with pass rush abilities because he's the main blitz man and has the farthest distance to travel most of the time.

But getting back to the point of the thread, stopping power backs, that all starts up front with the D-line. Your LDE needs to be the grunt that he's supposed to be and focuses on shutting off the edge of the off tackle gap. Pinch the other side off with a monster NT and it significantly slows the HB down coming through the hole, then hammer him with your LBs. Every time he comes into contact with those players he is subjected to their combined intimidation abilities. Theoretically, over time that will have a cumulative effect on the player and he'll lose his edge.

but the real question is, can you get all that done by the playoffs.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mordaloch
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by Mordaloch


hey Blamo, so you saying, say people 3x capped tackling for example got it like 70's 80's with equipment that increases chance of fumbles forced according to bort?


According to Bort? Yes
According to the sim? No, not really.

I'm looking at a player with 73 tackling and 65 strength who hasn't forced a fumble for two seasons, in around 70 tackles.


yeah i noticed that in this game just don't see that many fumbles unless there is a big level difference and at that point who cares i want to increase my chances to force fumbles against equal level competition and i want to find something that works. problem is a lot of this is left up to us guys who try to think outside the box and often get criticism for our (non cookie-cutter type builds) when we try to experiment with things. /shrug


again, you're on the right track. But forcing fumbles is an enigma. We've dumped points into every possible combination of builds and nothing has really lead to more fumbles.....and the honest truth is that I'm not going to spend any extra energy trying. Our philosophy is to wear down the entire team, not just one player, but in order to do that you have to have exceptional depth and a team first agenda that has everyone trying to accomplish the same goal. Now that I think of it, that's probably what keeps me playing the game.

like I said, overcoming an exploit will take more than just one player.

 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Blamo
Originally posted by fallingmercury

I think the problem is that every time a power back breaks a tackle, his morale increases.

And it's not "simple"


Yeah, but his morale can't be above 100. So even if he breaks a few tackles at first, his morale can't go any higher... Then hopefully Big/Monster hit will do more damage to his morale than a broken tackle will increase. And unless a guy is breaking 4 or 5 tackles on EVERY play (and I don't think the problem is quite that bad) you should hopefully be able to get a string where you can get a monster hit, a couple regular tackles, and maybe a TFL to bring him down to earth a little bit. Then that at least levels the playing ground to a fairly "normal" level. Then I guess it's a matter of if the powerback is lucky enough to get a few broken tackles (small morale boost) break out a big run for a TD (huge morale boost) or if the defense is lucky to cause a couple more big hits/TFL (small-medium morale drains) or cause a fumble (big morale drain), or if it sits somewhere in the middle. Obviously, it's not at all a guarantee... but I think it would at least bring the defense even with powerbacks, which is something that most teams are struggling to do right now.


well said. It's a jackhammer approach. You just keep drilling his ass with every body you can until either he breaks or your defense breaks. right now that's the only you can hope for unless Bort decides to scale it back a hair, but that's his call.
 
Blamo
offline
Link
 
Well, see... I like to think I know a thing or two about building linebackers. I disagree with your agility > speed theory, although I think it is becoming a little more important than it has in seasons past. Still, for LBs I see it more as an attribute to augment speed than anything. I also think that both OLB positions should strive for 100+ speed. If possible, you'd really like them to be able to cover their half of the field. I believe they can get by with strength+tackling totaling about 100, although I'd say 110 would be much closer to ideal. I can live with missed tackles a few extra missed tackles as long as they're getting to the ball, and often. Especially if you have fast safeties who can be there in support in case your LB misses a tackle. What I am coming around to, though, is that a MLB should probably be sitting at closer to 80-85 speed and probably try and get to 136 strength+tackling to support runs up the middle, but still be there to make plays out to the hashes... especially when one of your speedy LBs misses.


I also don't think that powerbacks are currently an "exploit", and I honestly do believe that a certain kind of SS and/or MLB would probably be enough to help heavily slow down a powerback. Shifting too many players to help out with powerback just leaves your defense open to other things, though.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Blamo
Well, see... I like to think I know a thing or two about building linebackers. I disagree with your agility > speed theory, although I think it is becoming a little more important than it has in seasons past. Still, for LBs I see it more as an attribute to augment speed than anything. I also think that both OLB positions should strive for 100+ speed. If possible, you'd really like them to be able to cover their half of the field. I believe they can get by with strength+tackling totaling about 100, although I'd say 110 would be much closer to ideal. I can live with missed tackles a few extra missed tackles as long as they're getting to the ball, and often. Especially if you have fast safeties who can be there in support in case your LB misses a tackle. What I am coming around to, though, is that a MLB should probably be sitting at closer to 80-85 speed and probably try and get to 136 strength+tackling to support runs up the middle, but still be there to make plays out to the hashes... especially when one of your speedy LBs misses.


I also don't think that powerbacks are currently an "exploit", and I honestly do believe that a certain kind of SS and/or MLB would probably be enough to help heavily slow down a powerback. Shifting too many players to help out with powerback just leaves your defense open to other things, though.


I understand your philosophy on speed LBs but I wish you the best of luck trying to hit 100 speed. In order to do that you will have to make that his focus from day 1 and it would take several seasons. You can't do that on 40+ players. Also, you would have to rob points from vital attributes such as vision and confidence, plus you need stamina to be around 40 for most starters, and that's IF you have equal back ups behind them. Strength and tackling need to be at least the mid 50s to cut down on normal missed tackles, let alone power backs....you're going to need 60+ tackling on your MLB at the very least.

For high level players there's no way to get back that many points. In seasons 1 and 2 we were chasing so many shadows that points were scattered to hell and back. The only players over 40 that have 100 in anything are normally skill positions that sank everything into one skil. IMO you can't build LBs that way because their role constantly changes. Pass coverage was big one season, speed backs the next, and now power backs. LBs have to be versatile, and if you don't have a group of them set up for a specific purpose then you're not going to beat a good running team.

.02
 
wallysmith
offline
Link
 
Another potential reason why demoralizing is no longer feasible... Motivational Speaker is an unbalancing skill:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1690866&page=14#15418929
 
Blamo
offline
Link
 
100 speed isn't that hard to hit, IMO. My level 42 is sitting at a nice 99 speed right now. Confidence is hardly something I'd call "vital", but I've still got it at about 48... and have my vision near 60 and agility near 68. Stamina is at 40, too. My strength and tackling are both below where you would like them, but my LB has less missed tackles than yours, so apparently I did something right I've also got 40+ jumping, so I could have probably had my strength and tackling numbers closer to where you'd like them if I had chosen to sacrifice that.


And on newer players, hitting 100 speed won't even be hard IMO. My level 17 should be a little above 100 speed at level 40 even if I never put another point into it, and my level 9 will probably reach that plateau a little later... but he'll probably be sitting close to 75-80 agility. Regardless, I think having two super fast guys on the outside, and one decently fast but strong LB in the middle really covers almost all of your bases. Your outside guys can stop an elusive/speedy back from anywhere he's going to run, they're useful in pass coverage, they're adequate pass rushers, they'll fill holes in the middle and they can run down possession receivers. Meanwhile your MLB should be able to take care of most of the runs in the middle, but still be fast enough to clean up any of your OLBs mistakes. If you have a good SS, you're even better off.
 
Blamo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wallysmith
Another potential reason why demoralizing is no longer feasible... Motivational Speaker is an unbalancing skill:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1690866&page=14#15418929


Didn't think of that. That could really squash the whole idea beyond a series or so.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Blamo
Well, see... I like to think I know a thing or two about building linebackers. I disagree with your agility > speed theory, although I think it is becoming a little more important than it has in seasons past. Still, for LBs I see it more as an attribute to augment speed than anything. I also think that both OLB positions should strive for 100+ speed. If possible, you'd really like them to be able to cover their half of the field. I believe they can get by with strength+tackling totaling about 100, although I'd say 110 would be much closer to ideal. I can live with missed tackles a few extra missed tackles as long as they're getting to the ball, and often. Especially if you have fast safeties who can be there in support in case your LB misses a tackle. What I am coming around to, though, is that a MLB should probably be sitting at closer to 80-85 speed and probably try and get to 136 strength+tackling to support runs up the middle, but still be there to make plays out to the hashes... especially when one of your speedy LBs misses.


I also don't think that powerbacks are currently an "exploit", and I honestly do believe that a certain kind of SS and/or MLB would probably be enough to help heavily slow down a powerback. Shifting too many players to help out with powerback just leaves your defense open to other things, though.


sorry, I wasn't saying it's an exploit. I was referencing the term that some people are calling it. Personally I think it's just a change to the sim that created and unfortunate result.

Also, no offense bro, but if you're not shifting people around to take certain plays away then you better have a super defense. If a team knows how to do something well, like run the off tackle, you're not going to stop it with a vanilla coverage. Sometimes you have to take chances and you have to commit IMO, but that doesn't mean you have to do anything unsafe. There are plenty of base coverages that can be used to cover the majority of the plays from the power run formations if you have the right personnel. Versatile LBs will make their own reads based on their vision when it comes to run/pass....you just have to know where you can afford to move them. But even if you don't move them they will close on the HB and hit him eventually.

If you've got one player on your team that can stop a legit power back then kudos to you man, because the rest of us aren't so fortunate. I'm done for the night but thanks for the discussion....it was worth staying up late.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.