User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania AAA Leagues > Oceania AAA #1 > Oceania AAA#1 Coaches Poll ~ Season 7, Game 5
Page:
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shaffe
Originally posted by Bushido


I see nothing equal about Portland and the Panthers (no disrespect to the Panthers). The Panthers have won by the skin of their teeth in their last 3 games. Portland would have won by 14+ against those 3 teams.


With all due respect, I don't think you can even begin to compare Moloka/Samoa/Mofa's to the schedule Portland has played. Alpha is just so much deeper and stronger than Zeta this year it's not even funny.

Although I'm still voting Portland/Kingston 1/2 in my ballot. Zeta might not be that great, but they are destroying teams in a season where it seems nearly impossible to do so.


My friend, I think you gravely, gravely underestimate Zeta. Of course, I have a biased perspective on this, as you do for Alpha.

Alpha is the deeper of the two conferences, I'll concede this point. I'd even go so far as to say that Alpha is the stronger of the two conferences, as it is deeper. I don't think the 10-6 interconference rivalry score this season carries as much weight, as Alpha did have to play two virtual CPU teams this season. That's beside my main point, though.

What is easy to forget is that both Portland and Kingston were stunned in the playoffs last season, which IMO is the only reason they weren't promoted. They should've been, that's for sure, and their record here this season proves that. But blowing teams out because "Zeta might not be that great" takes away from the talent Zeta does have.



 
shaffe
offline
Link
 
I just think that teams 4-10 in Alpha are far better than teams 4-10 in Zeta. I consider the top 3 in both conferences (New Celedonia, SWG, Tasmaina for Alpha and Portland, Kingston, and Tortuga) to be all of fairly eqal footing. But past that I would take Nuku'alofa/Ohio Valley/Alice Springs/Speigtstown/Samoa/Tongan/Molokai ahead of Tonga/Solomon Islands/Mount Isa/Rocky Mountain/FF.com/Papua New Guinea/Saipan - but that is just me. Add in that Zeta has three gutted teams that will throw everything out of whack and you have what I consider to be a far superior conference in Alpha.

Of course that's just one man's opinion. And I suppose somebody had to start it, the season has gone along far too smoothly. Perhaps another thread?
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shaffe
I just think that teams 4-10 in Alpha are far better than teams 4-10 in Zeta. I consider the top 3 in both conferences (New Celedonia, SWG, Tasmaina for Alpha and Portland, Kingston, and Tortuga) to be all of fairly eqal footing. But past that I would take Nuku'alofa/Ohio Valley/Alice Springs/Speigtstown/Samoa/Tongan/Molokai ahead of Tonga/Solomon Islands/Mount Isa/Rocky Mountain/FF.com/Papua New Guinea/Saipan - but that is just me. Add in that Zeta has three gutted teams that will throw everything out of whack and you have what I consider to be a far superior conference in Alpha.

Of course that's just one man's opinion. And I suppose somebody had to start it, the season has gone along far too smoothly. Perhaps another thread?


I believe we'll have to agree to disagree on your primary argument. I feel precisely that the 4-10 teams in Alpha are much closer to the 4-10 teams in Zeta than the Top 3 in each conference are to one another. I believe that Portland is clearly superior to Tasmania, and I believe that Kingston is clearly superior to New Caledonia. I believe that Tortuga is better than Melbourne, but I believe that the gap is much closer than the previous 2 matchups.

I do agree, though, that having 3 gutted teams in Zeta skews the rankings a fair amount for Alpha. A big reason for the poor interconference showing for Zeta this season.

LOL, we need a gadfly in here. I like being cordial, but it's fun to take a break every once in a while.
 
The_Warden
offline
Link
 
I will say without a doubt Portland is the #1 team in the league. But on the other hand, it would be a great accomplishment to beat any of these undefeated teams, as they are all on a pretty damn good hot streak. I would have to say that besides the gutted teams in Zeta, the 2 conferences are fairly close in regards to level of competition with the others at or around the same record.
 
Link
 
You know, CDC, when 2 years ago when the Zeta won more games than the Alpha in inter conference and I pointed out the match ups that wasn't valid, it was just the record. Either 10-6 is valid or it isn't. And frankly, so many gutted teams in the Zeta pretty much proves that the Alpha has a tougher road to travel.

That said, until they face each other it's really hard to argue against Portland and Kingston just from a talent perspective. Talent isn't the only thing but as long as they are undefeated I have a tough time saying with any confidence that an Alpha team could beat them.
 
The_Warden
offline
Link
 
And in order to get an actual feel for what the rest of the league feels, we need more people involved in the coaches poll

Originally posted by Snark

Method:
A first place vote was worth 15 points, 2nd place 14, and so on down the line. Seven teams participated this round. Thanks to all who contributed!


7 teams is way low. And actually I may have forgot to send ours in
 
Link
 
I forget to send mine anytime the voting falls on a weekend sadly.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Brian the Stunt Bum
You know, CDC, when 2 years ago when the Zeta won more games than the Alpha in inter conference and I pointed out the match ups that wasn't valid, it was just the record. Either 10-6 is valid or it isn't. And frankly, so many gutted teams in the Zeta pretty much proves that the Alpha has a tougher road to travel.

That said, until they face each other it's really hard to argue against Portland and Kingston just from a talent perspective. Talent isn't the only thing but as long as they are undefeated I have a tough time saying with any confidence that an Alpha team could beat them.


Since I'm in the law school mood right now, all we do is discuss the weights of given arguments. If you'd oblige me, I'd be happy to respond.

I strongly disagree with your black-and-white statement that 10-6 "is valid or it isn't". I forget how many teams in each conference of Oceania AA#2 were CPUs in Season 5. Were there 2-4 CPU teams in Alpha when Zeta won 10-6, then yes, this would certainly diminish Zeta's claim to conference superiority or something equally as silly in the long run. Would it totally obliterate Zeta's claim? Of course not: on that given day, 10 Zeta teams were better than 6 Alpha teams.

And I believe this applies now. This season, in that given week with those given matchups, 11 teams in Alpha were superior, and only 5 teams in Zeta were superior. As I have said before, I believe Alpha is the deeper of the two conferences, and is in effect the stronger of the two conferences. The weight of using this as an indicator is diminished, but not totally reversed, by the fact that there were 3 virtual CPU teams at this time. Again, this is my belief.

I only partially agree with your statement that Alpha has the "tougher road" to the playoffs. Strictly by mathematics, you're correct. 8/16 is a smaller percentage than 8/13. All things being perfectly equal, you're right. But it's not perfectly equal. If Kingston were in Alpha, I'd put money that they'd go 16-0. They'll very likely either go 16-0 or 15-1 in Zeta. It's not nearly as tough for them. If you're in the middle of the pack, that's where it's tougher. There are 7 teams in Zeta fighting for the 4-10 seeds as I see it now. Those teams have a comparatively tougher road. What I'm saying is: while mathematically accurate, your talent level/gameplanning will dictate the difficulty of the road. You may need to have a slightly (and I'd argue quite slightly) higher level of talent to remain competitive in Alpha this season.

I think you're dead on about Portland and Kingston, however. This I fully agree with.
Last edited Jan 14, 2009 15:23:10
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The_Warden
And in order to get an actual feel for what the rest of the league feels, we need more people involved in the coaches poll

Originally posted by Snark


Method:
A first place vote was worth 15 points, 2nd place 14, and so on down the line. Seven teams participated this round. Thanks to all who contributed!


7 teams is way low. And actually I may have forgot to send ours in


I agree. I missed 1 earlier because I was just swamped. But there are 29 active teams, right?
 
The_Warden
offline
Link
 
Yeah, 32-3=29. I too missed the 1st week. and technically I missed this week but I did post what my team had agreed on. Id like to see a few more teams participate on the poll. But it is what it is.
 
Tishi
offline
Link
 
The best part of polls are that they are based upon opinion. The gang at Portland and Kingston know I have the utmost respect for them. Hell, Kingston kicked the snot out of us already and Portland will do the same in a few games. I just see some of the new talent as just as good.

Everyone else is entitled to their opinion.

 
General Terms
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bushido

I see nothing equal about Portland and the Panthers (no disrespect to the Panthers). The Panthers have won by the skin of their teeth in their last 3 games. Portland would have won by 14+ against those 3 teams.



While this statement may be true, which I am not saying it is, this is a COACHING poll not a who has the best team poll. I think the Panthers have attained more with their roster than the Rain have done with theirs. Portland has the fastest horse right now - doesnt take a hall of fame jockey to ride it. The Panthers handling of their team IMHO has had more to do with their success than the steed on which they ride. WTG Panthers.


Last edited Jan 14, 2009 17:50:55
 
Link
 
Originally posted by General Terms
Originally posted by Bushido


I see nothing equal about Portland and the Panthers (no disrespect to the Panthers). The Panthers have won by the skin of their teeth in their last 3 games. Portland would have won by 14+ against those 3 teams.



While this statement may be true, which I am not saying it is, this is a COACHING poll not a who has the best team poll. I think the Panthers have attained more with their roster than the Rain have done with theirs. Portland has the fastest horse right now - doesnt take a hall of fame jockey to ride it. The Panthers handling of their team IMHO has had more to do with their success than the steed on which they ride. WTG Panthers.




It's a Coaches poll, not a coaching poll
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Portland is the best team, Alpha is the better conference.
 
shaffe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Modok
Portland is the best team, Alpha is the better conference.


I can agree with that.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.