User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Not enough fumbling?
Page:
 
Link
 
I think Tackling skill should increase your chance of causing a fumble, if it doesn't already. Or increase the effect.
 
sully
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by sully

Then again, if that were to happen, it would probably mean that DEs would be able to get to the quarterback, and that's a completely separate discussion.

I agree that QBs should fumble at least occasionally when being sacked (esp. from the blindside). But with how inflated the sack numbers still are, I'm not sure if it's such a bad thing at the moment.


I can see that, though I know in my team's league, the sack numbers are getting much better. Unless your team has participated in a 985729875-0 blowout, most of the top sack getters are somewhere around 5-7 sacks at the moment, which imo is a huge leap from the 188 sacks they probably would've had at this time last year.
 
Link
 
Guys, open your eyes.

What has been a huge issue this season? DEFENSIVE PLAYERS BUILT FOR SPEED, NOT STRENGTH AND TACKLING.

There is your answer.
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
To be fair everything that I've read implies that the reason fumbles are under-represented is because most defensive players haven't allocated enough points to strength or SAs.

- guy above me said the same thing but replaced eloquence with capitalization
Last edited Jan 11, 2009 18:55:42
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
And not many play on power tackling.
 
VegasABD
offline
Link
 
+100...Agree Sully...and great post...in our 5 games...1 fumble...
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
It seems reasonable where it is, if they upped it some builds would be getting a ludicrous number of FF's. Counting scrims my DT's had 8 so far in 10 games.
 
Grim Truth
offline
Link
 
I remember a few seasons ago there were a lot of fumbles. What happened was that while RB's kept building carrying LB's stopped building strength and tackling. Fumbling isn't a random thing, a lot goes into it, and if the LB's the RB's are playing are high speed/vision/agility and low strength/tackling, which is sort of what we have on mass right now, what will happen is what you've/we've all noticed. Low fumbling, high ypc for power RB's, low ypc for Speed/Elusive RB's. As LB's build strength the fumbles will increase again.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Can we stop asking for more fumbles? They're at a good point now -- many of the fumbles in the NFL are recovered by the team anyways.

Personally, I'm glad to see less fumbles -- most running backs in the NFL worth a damn fumble 2-3 times a season. That seems to be about where we stand here now. I'm happy with fumble rate.
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
Can we stop asking for more fumbles? They're at a good point now -- many of the fumbles in the NFL are recovered by the team anyways.

Personally, I'm glad to see less fumbles -- most running backs in the NFL worth a damn fumble 2-3 times a season. That seems to be about where we stand here now. I'm happy with fumble rate.


The question is how much do you have to devote to your carrying stat to achieve these kind of results. Defensive players generally have to build up a much larger number of stats to be effective than do offensive players. If the investment in "strength + carrying" + SAs for ball carriers is the same as "tackling + str" + SAs for defenders to achieve a realistic balance, then it's fair. Also remember that in real life TEs, WRs, and QBs frequently fumble the ball as well.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WTFPILLOWSHIRT
Guys, open your eyes.

What has been a huge issue this season? DEFENSIVE PLAYERS BUILT FOR SPEED, NOT STRENGTH AND TACKLING.

There is your answer.


Wrong. Good try though. We have guys that has high strength and tackling and still not creating fumbles. Reason been they are on wrap up. The problem is that if they don't go on wrap up, they will be missing tackles left and right, they still do miss tackles left and right when going up against power backs.

Big Hit or Monster Hit does not seem to help with creating fumbles either. I have seen a lot of Big Hit or Monster Hit happen in games and so far I have not seen one that caused a fumble.

My guess is that Bort nerfed wrap up tackling this season, especially the % for creating fumbles when on wrap up.

BTW, fumbles are way down this season, take a look at USA PRO. After 5 games, only 2 teams have forced more than 5 fumbles, and the leader with 10 forced fumble is a CPU team that also missed 108 tackles. I didn't do an exact calculation, but by just looking at it the average forced fumble per team in USA PRO is less than half per team a game. We are not even going to consider the number of fumbles recovered by the offense, we might just as well take fumbling out of the game altogether.
 
scy2200j
offline
Link
 
GLB ≠ NFL
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
It seems reasonable where it is, if they upped it some builds would be getting a ludicrous number of FF's. Counting scrims my DT's had 8 so far in 10 games.


Although Merlin doesn't seem to have an issue with it, how would you explain the rest of the Monkeys having only 1 FF this season so far? I'm sure there are some good guild DL and LB on the Monkeys.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
I think FFs are incredibly random atm. Less so than in the past, but that's mainly because they've been down across the board. I mean, it's obviously build-related somehow, but the fact that no one really knows (like, at all) how to consistently force fumbles, is a bit troubling for me.
 
sully
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by scy2200j
GLB ≠ NFL


Originally posted by sully
(Douchebag disclaimer: I realize that GLB is not the NFL, so by posting that GLB != NFL, you fully admit you have no reading comprehension and are merely posting such because you want to be first in line to expose your sandy vagina and need to OD on midol)


Thank you for admitting the lights are not on upstairs.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.