User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > ReProgram the Simulation - Redo The Game
Page:
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Season 7 has been arguably the season with the most changes to the sim...and resulted in tons of complaints (this is broken, stop making changes, etc).

It's taken us months to get where we are (personally I think it's mostly getting better...sometimes 2 steps foward, 1 step back, though), and redoing the sim would take too long.


Not saying we scrap all the progress. Just saying its time to take a step back, have a moment of deep thought and restart the whole process. There's only so long you can go with just adding things on. The core bits of the game need reworking and no amount of add-on stuff is going to accomplish that.

Bort's learned a ton through this experience. If knew everything he knows now a year ago, GLB would be much different. This would be his chance to implement all of those things that he laments about without having to blow up the whole thing. Granted, points 1-7 are my own opinion, but I think, from what I see Bort struggling with, that these are the issues he should/would address.
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Season 7 has been arguably the season with the most changes to the sim...and resulted in tons of complaints (this is broken, stop making changes, etc).

It's taken us months to get where we are (personally I think it's mostly getting better...sometimes 2 steps foward, 1 step back, though), and redoing the sim would take too long.


Instead of having to spread out the entire sim fixin', just do it all in a two week downtime or something..

OR!

Here's a reaaaaaal out there idea.

Get another developer (gasp!)
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
You and GG are gonna have fun here...that I can assure you...

Now about these changes...well, I wish you luck, but I highly doubt it...unfortunately. I agree, though.


I give up making suggestions. Bort aint interested in overhauls, unfortunately. However, I would like to say that season 1-2 were by far the more realistic sims. These days it's farcical more and more. VAs, SAs, AdvEQT, other bonuses, and all the other additions inside the code, have all made the game impossible to play now. Creating far too much disparity among builds only a few levels apart. Not to mention the total exclusion of "balanced" builds having any form of relevance to the game.
Last edited Jan 11, 2009 23:20:30
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by turnerhero

You and GG are gonna have fun here...that I can assure you...

Now about these changes...well, I wish you luck, but I highly doubt it...unfortunately. I agree, though.


I give up making suggestions. Bort aint interested in overhauls, unfortunately. However, I would like to say that season 1-2 were by far the more realistic sims. These days it's farcical more and more. VAs, SAs, AdvEQT, other bonuses, and all the other additions inside the code, have all made the game impossible to play now. Creating far too much disparity among builds only a few levels apart. Not to mention the total exclusion of "balanced" builds having any form of relevance to the game.


He's no interested in listening to the suggestions right now TBH. Something has to happen in GLB soon, he's gonna have to dig in and get his hands dirty, and make some people mad..

If not GLB is going to die.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JDaniels127
Originally posted by Nixx

Season 7 has been arguably the season with the most changes to the sim...and resulted in tons of complaints (this is broken, stop making changes, etc).

It's taken us months to get where we are (personally I think it's mostly getting better...sometimes 2 steps foward, 1 step back, though), and redoing the sim would take too long.


Instead of having to spread out the entire sim fixin', just do it all in a two week downtime or something..

OR!

Here's a reaaaaaal out there idea.

Get another developer (gasp!)


In all actuality, if he committed to this full re-write and overhaul, he would have the 30days left in this season and the typical 10 days of the off season to complete it. So basically, a full 40 days. Considering that he would know what he'd want to do and that he's done it before, it seems like a reasonable time frame.

 
GG
offline
Link
 
It's like completely pointless to even have any plays. Or to use varied plays. It's all just now using those 3-5 plays over and over, and the same cookie-cutter defensive AI tactics. Just a few levels of difference and all the added "extras" that builds can stack up on their players, makes the idea of a "game" (ie competition) impossible now unless you have identical builds and identical SP allocations and identical VAs as your opponents.

There's a percentage of teams and leagues where things look "ok", "realistic", but that's more like a very small ratio compared to how many teams and leagues of teams there are that are enduring ridiculous sims, stats, and total inability on either O or D to get any semblance of "competition" even tho builds between the teams are just a LITTLE different in SPs and using different SAs/EQT/VAs than others.

Everything in this game has turned into Cookie Cutter City.

The whole "vive le difference" thing doesnt exist AT ALL in GLB.
Last edited Jan 11, 2009 23:32:42
 
mandyross
offline
Link
 
Are you a programmer?
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity


In all actuality, if he committed to this full re-write and overhaul, he would have the 30days left in this season and the typical 10 days of the off season to complete it. So basically, a full 40 days. Considering that he would know what he'd want to do and that he's done it before, it seems like a reasonable time frame.



I think re-writing/testing/keeping GLB running...would be over-haul on one lone developer. Especially in 40 days. Thnk of all the whining that would erupt. The ragequits...I agree with this idea 100% and without people being unreasonable and short sighted I think it would have been done a long time ago.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JDaniels127
he's gonna have to dig in and get his hands dirty


Ie, overhauls is the only way really. If you're gonna get your hands dirty, it has to be overhauling the whole engine. Otherwise it's pointless because....

Originally posted by
If not GLB is going to die.


 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by JDaniels127

he's gonna have to dig in and get his hands dirty


Ie, overhauls is the only way really. If you're gonna get your hands dirty, it has to be overhauling the whole engine. Otherwise it's pointless because....

Originally posted by

If not GLB is going to die.




We both agree there, which is a rarity .
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JDaniels127


We both agree there, which is a rarity .


Which goes to show and really does EMPHASIZE how precarious GLB is in right now. That two people who disagree so much agree on this.

 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mandyross
Are you a programmer?


I dabble, but not on the level of this game. I'm also not Bort. But from my understanding he is extremely skilled at what he does and that's what I'm basing the time frame off of.

Say 42 Days, 6 weeks. So minus 12 days for weekends. That's 28 days. 8 Hour work day makes it 224 work hours. And that's if he takes Saturday and Sunday as personal days, which he doesn't have to do but I assume he is human and needs/likes rest.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Bort created the whole GLB game in 6 months while working another job. That's 6 months from an idea in his head to it being completed as the season 1 game that existed, in just 6 months while holding down a job as well.

Meaning, he could re-write the attributes-system and overhaul other stuff in like 1-2 months if he wanted to.
Last edited Jan 11, 2009 23:34:28
 
GG
offline
Link
 
It took him like no time at all to overhaul the game to incorporate VAs....which was one of the very worst implementations ever. But he did that, he overhauled the game to include that. So he can overhaul the game to remove that, or to re-do it all. Especially because a lot of the stuff he always seems to be interested in is the worst thing for the game, bringing in only more and more layers of disparity to pile on top of existing disparities.

It's like any idea of parity he is literally totally against implementing.
 
mandyross
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Originally posted by mandyross

Are you a programmer?


I dabble, but not on the level of this game. I'm also not Bort. But from my understanding he is extremely skilled at what he does and that's what I'm basing the time frame off of.

Say 42 Days, 6 weeks. So minus 12 days for weekends. That's 28 days. 8 Hour work day makes it 224 work hours. And that's if he takes Saturday and Sunday as personal days, which he doesn't have to do but I assume he is human and needs/likes rest.


It seems an awful tight schedule to me. And a huge risk of his current base of customers.

Although I do totally agree with your individual points as to which changes should be good.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.