This idea is nice in theory but you would still have to nerf kickers and punters also I believe the power backs with max VA's were running train on everyone
Originally posted by Crawly Originally posted by whodey08
We just need to be able to properly sub based on the offensive personnel. No, we just need builds to be reasonably realistic. You don't get the entire defense changing every time the Giants sub out Jacobs and bring in Ward. The same group of defenders should be reasonably capable of stopping both speed, agility, and power backs, in theory (and should be reasonably vulnerable to all three, too). Having multiple distinct defensive units sub in and out based on who's in the game doesn't solve anything.
Originally posted by whodey08 Is it our fault that teams dont utilize the functions of this game. The AI is instrumental in success. Its part of the game.
If you choose not to use it than thats your choice but it is a part of the game and if used properly it can make your team compete no matter who you are facing. Adjusting your player builds to stop all sorts of backs, WRs, etc is also a part of the game. It's instrumental in success. It's not my fault you don't utilize it.
Originally posted by whodey08 It actually does solve it. "It's true! It's true because I said it's true!".
Originally posted by Chessey This idea is nice in theory but you would still have to nerf kickers and punters also I believe the power backs with max VA's were running train on everyone
Which is why you find LB's that are strength and tackling and sub them in against the power backs and sub in your quicker LB's for the elusive backs. The offense will still make their plays but you wont have a HB running over or thru 8 defenders for a TD everytime they get the ball if you have the right personnel in there.
Wouldn't you rather have the option of roster choices over wondering each season what position Bort will nerf? We are spending some serious real money on this game and at the higher levels we cant just change our builds to suit Bort's adjustments.
Rather...allow teams to sign players of mixed talent and then sub accordingly.
Originally posted by whodey08 Wouldn't you rather have the option of roster choices over wondering each season what position Bort will nerf? We are spending some serious real money on this game and at the higher levels we cant just change our builds to suit Bort's adjustments. I would like to have the option of substituting defenders in when the offense makes a change. I would also like to have the option of all player build types (providing they're been build well) performing at roughly the same level. The two are not mutually exclusive, and one is not a replacement for the other. Having the ability to replace players without build balance will just lead to teams having one unit for speed guys and another for power guys - and that's both unrealistic and rather stupid.
Having defenders that are speed built and defenders that are strength built is unrealistic?
Its all over in the NFL!! You have DT's that are slow as shit but stuff the run due to their strength. They put those guys in on run situations. They have DT's that arent as strong but quicker so they put them in on pass situations.
Originally posted by whodey08 Its all over in the NFL!! You have DT's that are slow as shit but stuff the run due to their strength. They put those guys in on run situations. They have DT's that arent as strong but quicker so they put them in on pass situations.
How is that unrealistic and stupid? You're not asking for a chance to bring in guys based on run/pass situations. You're asking for a chance to bring in guys based on the offensive players in the game. Your example is completely invalid. Are you seriously suggesting NFL defenses make 4-5 substitutions just because this 2nd-and-3 play happens to have Reggie Bush in it, rather than Pierre Thomas? No way. *headshake*.
Originally posted by Crawly Originally posted by whodey08
Its all over in the NFL!! You have DT's that are slow as shit but stuff the run due to their strength. They put those guys in on run situations. They have DT's that arent as strong but quicker so they put them in on pass situations.
How is that unrealistic and stupid? You're not asking for a chance to bring in guys based on run/pass situations. You're asking for a chance to bring in guys based on the offensive players in the game. Your example is completely invalid. Are you seriously suggesting NFL defenses make 4-5 substitutions just because this 2nd-and-3 play happens to have Reggie Bush in it, rather than Pierre Thomas? No way. *headshake*.
No, but the corners will sometimes move to cover a specific receiver rather than stay on one side of the field.
Originally posted by Crawly Originally posted by whodey08
Its all over in the NFL!! You have DT's that are slow as shit but stuff the run due to their strength. They put those guys in on run situations. They have DT's that arent as strong but quicker so they put them in on pass situations.
How is that unrealistic and stupid? You're not asking for a chance to bring in guys based on run/pass situations. You're asking for a chance to bring in guys based on the offensive players in the game. Your example is completely invalid. Are you seriously suggesting NFL defenses make 4-5 substitutions just because this 2nd-and-3 play happens to have Reggie Bush in it, rather than Pierre Thomas? No way. *headshake*.
That team has the option to do that if they want too though!!! Thats all I want...is the option to decide who is playing against certain offensive matchups. If you dont want it than dont use it. Some people use the AI and others dont. But they have the option to use the AI if they want.
Give us the option to select who is in and if you dont want to mess with it than dont. But dont keep that option unavailable for those of us who would use the option.
I am totaly agree with this. and it would also stop people from camping an hr before the game and moving thier best WR to the 2nd and 3rd spots where the d is set by a guy who is at work when they made the change!