User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania AAA Leagues > Oceania AAA #2 > Oceania AA power rankings
Page:
 
Ironhead
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Notor
Yeah that would be crazy if the Onslaught and Sharks met in the championship again, especially after how last seasons game ended. Pittsburgh down by 3 with 30 seconds left, rallies back into FG range to tie it up, then wins in overtime. It sucked to lose like that, but damn that was a good game.


Vanuatu has my utmost repesct, not only for the gameplan for that game, but also for the way you guys handled the disappointment of being beat by screwy AI.
 
trojans4me
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vetsgt02
Originally posted by cane__boy

Originally posted by vetsgt02


What no LA Avengers....



that would be like putting the dolphins in the top 10













Ya we are new and building. we understand that this is not our year but we are trying to put the pieces together for the long run. We have not been caught up in the spending spree that has been going on. We are taking our licks but we get better every game. I am happy with our team and now we are close to braking through.


I think you are doing a good job man. It's hard to start a team and jump straight into an AA league, especially since this AA league seems to be as tough as most AAA leagues. Stick with it and I am sure you will have a good team this time next year. Our team is going through some growing pains and in my opinion majorly underachieving so we feel your pain.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by trojans4me
Originally posted by vetsgt02

Originally posted by cane__boy


Originally posted by vetsgt02



What no LA Avengers....



that would be like putting the dolphins in the top 10













Ya we are new and building. we understand that this is not our year but we are trying to put the pieces together for the long run. We have not been caught up in the spending spree that has been going on. We are taking our licks but we get better every game. I am happy with our team and now we are close to braking through.


I think you are doing a good job man. It's hard to start a team and jump straight into an AA league, especially since this AA league seems to be as tough as most AAA leagues. Stick with it and I am sure you will have a good team this time next year. Our team is going through some growing pains and in my opinion majorly underachieving so we feel your pain.


last year with 2 games left the convicts had a couple of lvl 4 or lower human and alot of cpu starters and look at us know. its just important to stick with it and eventialy you will start to get some wins
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Notor
That's not how power rankings work, they work by record, strength of opponent, common opponents, and margin of victory, not what you personally "believe".


Incorrect. That's how the ACTUAL rankings work. Power Rankings are all about perception and opinion.
 
Notor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
Originally posted by Notor

That's not how power rankings work, they work by record, strength of opponent, common opponents, and margin of victory, not what you personally "believe".


Incorrect. That's how the ACTUAL rankings work. Power Rankings are all about perception and opinion.


That's not true. The ACTUAL rankings only factor in your record and margin of victory, they don't include strength of opponent at all. A 4-0 team will be higher in the actual rankings than a 3-1 team even if the 3-1 team has beaten much tougher opponents. That's the whole point of doing power rankings, to determine what the actual rankings aren't telling you about a team by both incorporating what the real ranks tell you while also factoring in all the things they don't, like the records of the opponents you've beaten, or how many points your opponent has scored/allowed on average per game, etc.. There are fairly simple formulas for determining this that are not based on individual perception at all.

Throwing out a random list of teams you like is not a power ranking, or at least it's not a ranking that's worth anything.
Last edited May 4, 2008 20:13:18
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Notor
Originally posted by Zurai

Originally posted by Notor


That's not how power rankings work, they work by record, strength of opponent, common opponents, and margin of victory, not what you personally "believe".


Incorrect. That's how the ACTUAL rankings work. Power Rankings are all about perception and opinion.


That's not true. The ACTUAL rankings only factor in your record and margin of victory, they don't include strength of opponent at all. A 4-0 team will be higher in the actual rankings than a 3-1 team even if the 3-1 team has beaten much tougher opponents. That's what power rankings are supposed to be for, at least any power ranking that is worth anything at all. You factor in who each team has played and how those opponents have performed against the other teams to determine how good they are relative to the other teams in the league. Throwing out a random list of teams you like is not going to give you anything close to an accurate power ranking.


Thats what i tried to do
EX.Villinova wilcats are undeafeated but have played no one and have supper low stats. thats why there at the bottom
 
Notor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Florida__boi08
Originally posted by Notor

Originally posted by Zurai


Originally posted by Notor



That's not how power rankings work, they work by record, strength of opponent, common opponents, and margin of victory, not what you personally "believe".


Incorrect. That's how the ACTUAL rankings work. Power Rankings are all about perception and opinion.


That's not true. The ACTUAL rankings only factor in your record and margin of victory, they don't include strength of opponent at all. A 4-0 team will be higher in the actual rankings than a 3-1 team even if the 3-1 team has beaten much tougher opponents. That's what power rankings are supposed to be for, at least any power ranking that is worth anything at all. You factor in who each team has played and how those opponents have performed against the other teams to determine how good they are relative to the other teams in the league. Throwing out a random list of teams you like is not going to give you anything close to an accurate power ranking.


Thats what i tried to do
EX.Villinova wilcats are undeafeated but have played no one and have supper low stats. thats why there at the bottom


I know, you were headed in the right direction, but you were biased. The Convicts have beaten four 1-3 teams to get where they are and are not noticeably superior to Darwin, Brisbane, or Vanuatu on paper, while all three of those teams have beaten at least one team with a winning record to get where they are now. So I think you have to rank them higher than your team at this point in the season.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Notor
Originally posted by Florida__boi08

Originally posted by Notor


Originally posted by Zurai



Originally posted by Notor




That's not how power rankings work, they work by record, strength of opponent, common opponents, and margin of victory, not what you personally "believe".


Incorrect. That's how the ACTUAL rankings work. Power Rankings are all about perception and opinion.


That's not true. The ACTUAL rankings only factor in your record and margin of victory, they don't include strength of opponent at all. A 4-0 team will be higher in the actual rankings than a 3-1 team even if the 3-1 team has beaten much tougher opponents. That's what power rankings are supposed to be for, at least any power ranking that is worth anything at all. You factor in who each team has played and how those opponents have performed against the other teams to determine how good they are relative to the other teams in the league. Throwing out a random list of teams you like is not going to give you anything close to an accurate power ranking.


Thats what i tried to do
EX.Villinova wilcats are undeafeated but have played no one and have supper low stats. thats why there at the bottom


I know, you were headed in the right direction, but you were biased. The Convicts have beaten four 1-3 teams to get where they are and are not noticeably superior to Darwin, Brisbane, or Vanuatu on paper, while all three of those teams have beaten at least one team with a winning record to get where they are now. So I think you have to rank them higher than your team at this point in the season.

Thats unfair because the Miami dolphins added alot of players before our game including a lvl 14 qb

 
Notor
offline
Link
 

Nah, that QB has been there since the start of the season, he was there when we played them in the opener.

Anyways, I'm tired of talking about this. If we want to make power rankings for our league that actually tell us something we should do something like they do for Oceania AAA, with stats and formulas for strength of victory and whatnot. Otherwise it's just people throwing up arbitrary rankings based on personal opinion, and I guess that's okay if that's what you want to do but it doesn't help us determine much of anything. But it's way too early in the season for these things to be close to accurate, anyways.
 
Sulfadias
offline
Link
 
All I know is...

Theres blood in the water.

Feeding Frenzy!!!!!!!!

 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I have to agree with Notor on this -- the power rankings for any NCAA sport don't simply show the best records top to bottom -- they take into account strength of schedule and strength of conference. It is why you will see a team with a perfect record below teams who may have lost a game or two.

The second list, put together showing point spread + average point spread of opponents is a far better judgement of team strength, but that is just a quick formula. Much better than a list of teams based on one's perception or preference.

And, I think the Mod's have made it quite clear that levels are only part of the game -- in fact, I believe correct game planning and understanding the SIM factor in a lot more then levels.
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Power Rankings are a method of entertainment; they have no purpose other than to entertain. There is no magic formula for them, like Notor is saying there is. There'd be no point to them if there was a magic formula. They are subjective. For an example, take ESPN's power rankings from week 18 of last season:
http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/powerranking
Note how the teams are ordered roughly by record and stats, but how the ranker's opinion is the final word (the Comments)? That's a "real" Power Ranking. They're a way for someone to say "this team is more powerful than the stats indicate" or "this team has gotten lucky and really isn't as strong as they seem".
Last edited May 5, 2008 12:41:35
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
I have to agree with my boy Scace in agreeing with Notor.

We should be calling these "rankings", arbitrary opinion based list of teams or something, anything other then power rankings.

If the idea is to give each other props or measure our respective E-penis then that is totally cool, but it should be understood that at this point all of it is pretty arbitrary.

The guys in AAA seem to have some basic Excel spreadsheets worked out for their power rankings, maybe one of us would be cool enough to talk with them about it and see if we can run the numbers for our league.

For my part I think it is fairly obvious who the contenders are right now and there would seem to be about 6-8 teams who are capable of winning the whole thing. Until more of those teams actually play each other this season, we don't really have enough information to rank them against each other.

Before I finish off this ridiculously long post; I will just say good luck to everyone and win or lose, you should appreciate playing in this conference, this is one of the most balanced and competitive AA leagues around and I for one appreciate the awesome competition.
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
I am not disagreeing with Zur by the way, just saying the truth is somewhere in the middle and thus far it is weighted way more towards opinion then stats.
 
Notor
offline
Link
 
I'm not saying there is absolutely no opinion involved, because obviously there is. But you have to at least back your opinions up with a reasonable argument for why you ranked the teams the way you did, and if your power rankings are meant to represent the actual power structure of the league compared to the real rankings you have to make a good case as to why your rankings are different. To do that, you need to use stats and arguments that aren't accounted for in the real ranks, like strength of opponents for example. Nothing is stopping someone from making a random list of teams they like and calling it a power ranking, it's just not a very good power ranking at all if they don't have good arguments for why they ranked the teams the way they did.

The power ranking posted here originally was not very good, the arguments for why the teams were ranked as such were flawed and I simply pointed those flaws out and stated that if you want to make a better argument for the reality of your power ranking, you need to make better arguments for it, either through stats which the normal rankings ignore or intangible things like coaching ability or whatnot. Otherwise it's just a silly little list that only serves to stroke your own ego.
Last edited May 5, 2008 13:34:38
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.