User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > I suggest a moderator whose sole job is to moderate FFA
Page:
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
i believe that a site can get very complicated when different forums are subject to different rules...

i think that often leads to people in the 'free-er' forums - being upset when their normal behavior isn't received well in the 'standard' forums.

by setting up a forum specific moderator - i think you are creating the above.


The distinction already exists. I think the problem is that the distinction is NOT explicit, though, opposite of what you are saying.

If people were told flat-out that what they are doing is acceptable in FFA but NOT in content-based forums, then it would be easier to control their behavior.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GIEFF

...whether or not you perceive a lot of the rule-breaking in other parts of the site as the fault of FFA is irrelevant.



To the contrary, its central to the fact that FFA should be modded no diffently than any other portion of the site. Goal Line Blitz, at its core, is a FOOTBALL SIMULATION site, not a "entertainment" site. Because moderation in FFA has been lax (to be polite--"nearly non-existent" would be more accurate), much of what passes for "normal" down there has begun to show up more often in other forums (starting threads 3 and 4 different times after repeated locks being only one example).

Its one thing to say "FFA is where folks can go to talk about things not directly related to the game". Its quite another--and a negative one at that, to continue to allow FFA to be the place where screw-ups downgrade the image of the site.

Last edited Dec 17, 2008 14:51:25
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RyanEchtenacher
FFA is ment to be less MOD controled, and you now want more MOD control in it?

I say no, live with it, and learn to love eachother.


I don't want more mod control, I want the mods to control the right things (racism, porn, and harassment). We used to have 2 mods serving this function in FFA, and now we have just one, so another one would help.
 
kevbk6222
offline
Link
 
the only problem would be the person not taking it seriously.
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by GIEFF


...whether or not you perceive a lot of the rule-breaking in other parts of the site as the fault of FFA is irrelevant.



To the contrary, its central to the fact that FFA should be modded no diffently than any other portion of the site. Goal Line Blitz, at its core, is a FOOTBALL SIMULATION site, not a "entertainment" site. Because moderation in FFA has been lax (to be polite--"nearly non-existent" would be more accurate), much of what passes for "normal" down there has begun to show up more often in other forums (starting threads 3 and 4 different times after repeated locks being only one example).

Its one thing to say "FFA is where folks can go to talk about things not directly related to the game". Its quite another--and a negative one at that, to continue to allow FFA to be the place where screw-ups downgrade the image of the site.



And what is the purpose of simulating football games? For a better historical understanding of the game? To increase egos? To cure cancer?


ENTERTAINMENT.

If you think it's anything else, you are taking it way more seriously than you should be.

Last edited Dec 17, 2008 14:54:22
 
DM
offline
Link
 
FFA is looked at as screw ups because you make it out to be that. If you treated FFA as a place to discuss stuff that isn't related to spam, it wouldn't contain much spam. DD endorses actions by making random threads in there. Bort hasn't gone in their and say please act responsible. The people in FFA are a result of a bad moderation group, and if one of our own is added, I feel that things will change for the better for all.
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kevbk6222
the only problem would be the person not taking it seriously.


I agree that could be a problem. Only a few people would do a good job, but those people are pretty easy to spot.
 
JazManXII
offline
Link
 
i agree with OP 100%
 
DM
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kevbk6222
the only problem would be the person not taking it seriously.


understood, which is why you would need to ask FFA who they think would actually do a good job as mod. I know many people have their own opinions, I feel that Firenze would be a great face to represent FFA.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GIEFF
Originally posted by RyanEchtenacher

FFA is ment to be less MOD controled, and you now want more MOD control in it?

I say no, live with it, and learn to love eachother.


I don't want more mod control, I want the mods to control the right things (racism, porn, and harassment). We used to have 2 mods serving this function in FFA, and now we have just one, so another one would help.


Well now, a new book has opened. I never saw you post saying the lines: rules of racism, harassment, porn... in any of your posts, you just came out saying we want him to be mod. If that is going on, that player should not be able to return to the fourms EVER.
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RyanEchtenacher
Originally posted by GIEFF

Originally posted by RyanEchtenacher


FFA is ment to be less MOD controled, and you now want more MOD control in it?

I say no, live with it, and learn to love eachother.


I don't want more mod control, I want the mods to control the right things (racism, porn, and harassment). We used to have 2 mods serving this function in FFA, and now we have just one, so another one would help.


Well now, a new book has opened. I never saw you post saying the lines: rules of racism, harassment, porn... in any of your posts, you just came out saying we want him to be mod. If that is going on, that player should not be able to return to the fourms EVER.


I mentioned those three things in the original post of this thread, in point #3.


What if a poster made a thread in FFA called:

"Has anybody every wondered why Lithuanians eat so many babies?"

Would that warrant a permanent forum-ban? A ban at all? The line isn't as stark as you make it out to be.



 
manning015
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by manning015
may i reccomend darkus black?


 
Link
 
Originally posted by GIEFF
Originally posted by RyanEchtenacher

Originally posted by GIEFF


Originally posted by RyanEchtenacher



FFA is ment to be less MOD controled, and you now want more MOD control in it?

I say no, live with it, and learn to love eachother.


I don't want more mod control, I want the mods to control the right things (racism, porn, and harassment). We used to have 2 mods serving this function in FFA, and now we have just one, so another one would help.


Well now, a new book has opened. I never saw you post saying the lines: rules of racism, harassment, porn... in any of your posts, you just came out saying we want him to be mod. If that is going on, that player should not be able to return to the fourms EVER.


I mentioned those three things in the original post of this thread, in point #3.


What if a poster made a thread in FFA called:

"Has anybody every wondered why Lithuanians eat so many babies?"

Would that warrant a permanent forum-ban? A ban at all? The line isn't as stark as you make it out to be.





YES, Now you included your reasoning, before you came out say: We need this in FFA without explanation of why. What goes on in FFA stays in FFA I dont want any part of it.
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
Then feel free to not post in this thread.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GIEFF



What if a poster made a thread in FFA called:

"Has anybody every wondered why Lithuanians eat so many babies?"








What would a discussion of that topic do to enhance Goal Line Blitz?

You remember "Goal Line Blitz", don't you? Its a football simulation--the reason the site was begun in the first place.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.