And to think after reading this thread, there is 2 minutes in my life I can't get back.
While I don't have the huge experience across so many different leagues as some of the posters here, I would point out a couple of things:
In this league (AA and A for that matter), there are plays you can run that are brutal against an opposing team, depending on where they are at on their builds. (Talking up to mid 20's teams for the most part, but perhaps a bit past that). Those same plays are not run in the higher league because the defenses are so fast and players are very well rounded by then that those plays just won't work.
Screens can work on a ill prepared defense in the upper leagues, but in general, they get killed from what I have seen, especially if the opposition has an idea that you are going to try to do them.
I have issues about calling out I formation runs. If you developed your team as a power running team (Bogota is certainly not that in this league) then why would you limit yourself on what your team was designed to do and that is run the ball a lot just because it is supposedly "broken"? My comment with such a team is our guys are built to run the ball a lot and just because your defense is not built to stop it, that is not my issue and I would point out that defensive football 101 is you stop the run and then worry about the rest of the stuff that may or may not happen in terms of trying to sack the QB, etc. People that don't follow football 101 do so at their own risk and should not be upset when a team promptly shoves the ball down their throat.
I have been involved in a lot of games over the years. I have play tested them and even helped write a set of rules that got published with a group of friends. One of the things that drives me nuts is when "the powers that be" do not allow the community to develop counter tactics to what is the latest rage in the game. One of the reasons that running OT is probably pretty strong right now is there are a lot of LDEs out there that were constructed with the simple idea of exploiting the fact that ROT's don't get to use their "protect" SA. Those guys got to ring up impressive sack numbers and now they get to pay the price for being built for a specific purpose. My point is your LDE better be a run stopper first these days and if he can get some sacks, then so much the better, but if he can't help blunt a run game, I got no use for him.
There are times where adjustments have to be made, but they need to be carefully thought out and not just made on a whim.
Sorry for the book.
