User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America A Leagues > South America A #3 > The Committee's League Wide Pro Bowl Team
Page:
 
MGood030
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pburgh80
and Joey Beck has way better numbers than the one FS


The Safeties your posting, more or less, have the same exact numbers as the Dreadnaught safeties. As far as "Way Better Numbers" Beck only leads Goosemore in tackles, but he also has 14 more missed tackles, which more than makes up the difference. You absolutly have to have a sure tackler at FS.
 
Bridges
offline
Link
 
what about my argument for Bridges Jr.
 
MGood030
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bridges
what about my argument for Bridges Jr.


Sorry, overlooked ya.

Anyway, I actually noticed Bridges Jr. when looking through some of the stats of his teammates, and was quite suprised that he went perfect this season. However, in my view at least, only having 17 attempts (half of what Deablo had) on the season kept him from Kicker of the Year.

Plus, in all honesty, I've never even seen someone go 9/10 from 50+. That's crazy.
 
oakland360
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MGood030

Timmy Brown was an oversight. Good catch. He probably should be the guy.

McDragon, not the case. I'm still not sure what this whole 50/50 arguement is. You do realize that it doesn't mean anything, right? The guy McDragon was beat out by had LESS rushes, and a BETTER yards per rush average than him. That cancels out that entire arguement. How Cape Horn plays is how Cape Horn plays, that's on you guys. Other players don't need to take a backseat to McDragon because of the Cape Horn strategy. It's your own fault if you wanted the stats, but it's worked well for your team in the only thing that matters...wins..


Here's my case for McDragon and what splitting time 50/50 means...

McDragon is the only RB in the league to put up 100 on the ground every game of the season. Not one team was able to stop him. That's not the case with either Paul Thorn or Miles "Tails" Prowler. You need to look no further than the Game logs to see it. McDragon not only led the league in Touchdowns (65), but has the most broken tackles as well (244), was second in total yardage. While only being tackled for a loss a measly 15 times all season (a lower number than the other 2 in the convo). All while averaging 9.6 yards per carry. He wasn't the starting RB. He shared carries 50/50 in a balanced offense where he wasn't the only focus. Remember our QB Drew Bludd also threw for over 4000yds & 41 TD's. Oh and he's helped lead his team to the tune of 16-0. Yes he fumbled the ball 10 times. But only 8 of them count, and none of them hurt his team in any fashion(only 1Td scored off of his 8 fumbles lost). That and 17-0 is a very telling number. For him to be able to put up numbers like that. For him to be dominating in so many stat categories and not be considered shouldn't be possible.

Here I'll break down the numbers for everyone and show the reason why this is a no brainer...

Miles "Tails" Prowler: Lvl 34 65 total Td
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=413099&playoffs=0

333att 219.8ypg 3517yds 10.6ypc 93brTK 16TkdFL 61Td 4FmbLst 694 plays, 43.4 plays/g
22rec 371yds 16.9ypc 4Td 10 drops

games under 100yds rushing: 6
Wk 1 vs. Rio - 55yds 4.2ypc 0Td
Wk 6 vs. Val - 63yds 4.5ypc 0Td 1cth 9yds
Wk 13 vs. Por - 96yds 8.0ypc 0Td 1cth 10yds
Wk 14 vs. San - 28yds 2.5ypc 1Td
Wk 15 vs. Rio - 0yds 0ypc 0Td
Wk 16 vs. 19th - 44yds 4.9ypc 1TD 2cth 31.5yds

***Scored at least 1 TD in 12/16 regular season games

Paul Thorn: Lvl 36 62 total Td
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=116516&playoffs=0

440att 237.6ypg 3802yds 8.6ypc 127brTK 21TkdFL 52Td 1FmbLst 907 plays, 56.7 plays/g
61rec 817yds 13.4ypc 16 drops

games under 100yds rushing: 3
Wk 2 vs. 19th - 67yds 3.9ypc 1Td 3cth 45yds
Wk 15 vs. Por - 92.5yds 4.2ypc 1Td 6cth 48yds
Wk 17 vs. Pun - 55yds 3.7ypc 1Td 4cth 39.5yds

***Scored at least 1 TD in 15/16 regular season games

Darren McDragon: Lvl 33 65 total Td
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=504999&playoffs=0

374att 225.6ypg 3609yds 9.6ypc 244brTK 15TkdFL 65Td 8FmbLst 585 plays, 36.6 plays/g
8rec 100yds 12.5ypc 3 drops

games under 100yds rushing: 1 (1 yard difference doesn't really count but whatever)
Wk 13 vs. Fis - 99yds 5.2ypc 3Td 3cth 49.5yds

***Scored at least 1 TD in 15/16 regular season games

So as you can see. While Paul Thorn is deserving to be in this convo... Darren McDragons numbers are easily better than that of Miles "Tails" Prowler. Especially when you take into account that McDragon is also the most consistant of the three. And is either in 1st or 2nd in all major/minor rushing categories. The only categories he doesn't lead in are fumbles lost, total plays and plays per game. And the plays per game is where the 50/50 argument comes into play. His numbers come on way less plays per game than the other two, being that he's sharing the load at RB with another back that's also a monster. Also if you're going to try to count fumbles lost, than notice that 2 games that "Tails" Prowler lost fumbles in, his team lost as well. Not to mention both Prowler and Thorn had way more drops than McDragon catching outta the backfield.

McDragon is a BEAST!!! CHAMPIONSHIP!
Last edited Dec 16, 2008 02:55:52
 
Bridges
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MGood030
Originally posted by Bridges

what about my argument for Bridges Jr.


Sorry, overlooked ya.

Anyway, I actually noticed Bridges Jr. when looking through some of the stats of his teammates, and was quite suprised that he went perfect this season. However, in my view at least, only having 17 attempts (half of what Deablo had) on the season kept him from Kicker of the Year.

Plus, in all honesty, I've never even seen someone go 9/10 from 50+. That's crazy.


i was just curious as to why, thanks for clearing it up, and his leg is freaky good
 
Rogafella
offline
Link
 
no offence oak but mcdragon caught 8 passes out of the backfield and thorn caught 61, i think thats well worth the 13 more drops and that point to your arguement isnt really helping the cause
 
oakland360
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rogafella
no offence oak but mcdragon caught 8 passes out of the backfield and thorn caught 61, i think thats well worth the 13 more drops and that point to your arguement isnt really helping the cause


same argument as the 8 lost fumbles... non of those fumbles hurt my team. Only 7 points came of of 1 of those turnovers. And we won all of those games. He wasn't held for under 100 yards rushing by anyone this season. I doubt that any other starting RB can boast that here. And he scored a TD in all but 1 game. "Tails' Prowler can't boast that. Matter of fact "Tails" was held under 100yds 5 different times. So dropping the ball does mean something if fumbles mean something. Plus both "Tails" Prowler and P. Thorn averaged way more plays a game than McDragon. That's where the 50/50 argument comes in. Not to mention McDragon is a lower Lvl. than both the other RB's and put up better numbers... Come on dude, you've got to be kidding me. Do the math... I put all the numbers up for ya. The writing is on the wall.

Also I'm pretty sure if that if I had the energy to check it. McDragon would have way more 1st downs gained than either of the other two RB's mentioned here.

Shananigans, I call Shananigans... the Committee has other players ranked above two of my players that should easily be on this list. Shananigans!!! If your going to use the playing time for an Offensive or Defensive lineman... you have to use it for the Running Backs as well. Otherwise your logic doesn't add up and your being hypocritical.
Last edited Dec 16, 2008 04:35:15
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oakland360
Originally posted by Rogafella

no offence oak but mcdragon caught 8 passes out of the backfield and thorn caught 61, i think thats well worth the 13 more drops and that point to your arguement isnt really helping the cause


same argument as the 8 lost fumbles... non of those fumbles hurt my team. Only 7 points came of of 1 of those turnovers. And we won all of those games. He wasn't held for under 100 yards rushing by anyone this season. I doubt that any other starting RB can boast that here. And he scored a TD in all but 1 game. "Tails' Prowler can't boast that. Matter of fact "Tails" was held under 100yds 5 different times. So dropping the ball does mean something if fumbles mean something. Plus both "Tails" Prowler and P. Thorn averaged way more plays a game than McDragon. That's where the 50/50 argument comes in. Not to mention McDragon is a lower Lvl. than both the other RB's and put up better numbers... Come on dude, you've got to be kidding me. Do the math... I put all the numbers up for ya. The writing is on the wall.

Also I'm pretty sure if that if I had the energy to check it. McDragon would have way more 1st downs gained than either of the other two RB's mentioned here.

Shananigans, I call Shananigans... the Committee has other players ranked above two of my players that should easily be on this list. Shananigans!!! If your going to use the playing time for an Offensive or Defensive lineman... you have to use it for the Running Backs as well. Otherwise your logic doesn't add up and your being hypocritical.


Throwout the blowout games, and you have an average RB.

You do realize this right? You are basing your "stats" off of a 174-0 win where you rushed for 500+ yards,
 
oakland360
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by oakland360

Originally posted by Rogafella


no offence oak but mcdragon caught 8 passes out of the backfield and thorn caught 61, i think thats well worth the 13 more drops and that point to your arguement isnt really helping the cause


same argument as the 8 lost fumbles... non of those fumbles hurt my team. Only 7 points came of of 1 of those turnovers. And we won all of those games. He wasn't held for under 100 yards rushing by anyone this season. I doubt that any other starting RB can boast that here. And he scored a TD in all but 1 game. "Tails' Prowler can't boast that. Matter of fact "Tails" was held under 100yds 5 different times. So dropping the ball does mean something if fumbles mean something. Plus both "Tails" Prowler and P. Thorn averaged way more plays a game than McDragon. That's where the 50/50 argument comes in. Not to mention McDragon is a lower Lvl. than both the other RB's and put up better numbers... Come on dude, you've got to be kidding me. Do the math... I put all the numbers up for ya. The writing is on the wall.

Also I'm pretty sure if that if I had the energy to check it. McDragon would have way more 1st downs gained than either of the other two RB's mentioned here.

Shananigans, I call Shananigans... the Committee has other players ranked above two of my players that should easily be on this list. Shananigans!!! If your going to use the playing time for an Offensive or Defensive lineman... you have to use it for the Running Backs as well. Otherwise your logic doesn't add up and your being hypocritical.


Throwout the blowout games, and you have an average RB.

You do realize this right? You are basing your "stats" off of a 174-0 win where you rushed for 500+ yards,


If you want me to throw out my blowout games.... thats all the games we played... we blew everyone out except for Port Royal. Oh and in that case, have them throw out every game not played against the Dreads, Valencia, or San Juan. Both those backs did terrible against those teams. Not to mention that "Tails" P put up a goose egg vs. a CPU team. Dude, you can't use 1 argument against me, and not use that same argument vs. them as well. Once again that'd be hypocritical. McDragon put up great numbers against everyone... Even the common opponents... i.e. United Evo, Dreads, Valencia, Rio. Use your eyes, look at the stats/game film. I did. My argument is rock solid with facts to back it up. I broke down every game these 3 guys had. And Guess what... McDragon wins the battle vs. "Tails" P all day long.

Last edited Dec 16, 2008 04:51:07
 
Mr. Dumass
offline
Link
 
All RB's outside of Port Royal's 'Gruesome Twosome' suck ingrown scrotum hairs in this league.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oakland360
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by oakland360


Originally posted by Rogafella



no offence oak but mcdragon caught 8 passes out of the backfield and thorn caught 61, i think thats well worth the 13 more drops and that point to your arguement isnt really helping the cause


same argument as the 8 lost fumbles... non of those fumbles hurt my team. Only 7 points came of of 1 of those turnovers. And we won all of those games. He wasn't held for under 100 yards rushing by anyone this season. I doubt that any other starting RB can boast that here. And he scored a TD in all but 1 game. "Tails' Prowler can't boast that. Matter of fact "Tails" was held under 100yds 5 different times. So dropping the ball does mean something if fumbles mean something. Plus both "Tails" Prowler and P. Thorn averaged way more plays a game than McDragon. That's where the 50/50 argument comes in. Not to mention McDragon is a lower Lvl. than both the other RB's and put up better numbers... Come on dude, you've got to be kidding me. Do the math... I put all the numbers up for ya. The writing is on the wall.

Also I'm pretty sure if that if I had the energy to check it. McDragon would have way more 1st downs gained than either of the other two RB's mentioned here.

Shananigans, I call Shananigans... the Committee has other players ranked above two of my players that should easily be on this list. Shananigans!!! If your going to use the playing time for an Offensive or Defensive lineman... you have to use it for the Running Backs as well. Otherwise your logic doesn't add up and your being hypocritical.


Throwout the blowout games, and you have an average RB.

You do realize this right? You are basing your "stats" off of a 174-0 win where you rushed for 500+ yards,


If you want me to throw out my blowout games.... thats all the games we played... we blew everyone out except for Port Royal. Oh and in that case, have them throw out every game not played against the Dreads, Valencia, or San Juan. Both those backs did terrible against those teams. Not to mention that "Tails" P put up a goose egg vs. a CPU team. Dude, you can't use 1 argument against me, and not use that same argument vs. them as well. Once again that'd be hypocritical. McDragon put up great numbers against everyone... Even the common opponents... i.e. United Evo, Dreads, Valencia, Rio. Use your eyes, look at the stats/game film. I did. My argument is rock solid with facts to back it up. I broke down every game these 3 guys had. And Guess what... McDragon wins the battle vs. "Tails" P all day long.



Throw out all the games that were 80+ points to 20- less and again, you come out with an AVERAGE back,

I know you don't get that, it's ok, you can think he is the greatest back in all of GLB, point remains, he isn't even on the radar.
 
MGood030
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oakland360
Originally posted by Rogafella

no offence oak but mcdragon caught 8 passes out of the backfield and thorn caught 61, i think thats well worth the 13 more drops and that point to your arguement isnt really helping the cause


same argument as the 8 lost fumbles... non of those fumbles hurt my team. Only 7 points came of of 1 of those turnovers. And we won all of those games. He wasn't held for under 100 yards rushing by anyone this season. I doubt that any other starting RB can boast that here. And he scored a TD in all but 1 game. "Tails' Prowler can't boast that. Matter of fact "Tails" was held under 100yds 5 different times. So dropping the ball does mean something if fumbles mean something. Plus both "Tails" Prowler and P. Thorn averaged way more plays a game than McDragon. That's where the 50/50 argument comes in. Not to mention McDragon is a lower Lvl. than both the other RB's and put up better numbers... Come on dude, you've got to be kidding me. Do the math... I put all the numbers up for ya. The writing is on the wall.

Also I'm pretty sure if that if I had the energy to check it. McDragon would have way more 1st downs gained than either of the other two RB's mentioned here.

Shananigans, I call Shananigans... the Committee has other players ranked above two of my players that should easily be on this list. Shananigans!!! If your going to use the playing time for an Offensive or Defensive lineman... you have to use it for the Running Backs as well. Otherwise your logic doesn't add up and your being hypocritical.


Oak, your running in circles. Your bringing up dumb stuff trying to make a point that isn't there to make. Do I really care what your QB did during the season? You realize Punata's was even better right? This is about McDragon and Prowler. For the last time, I don't care what Cape Horn's strategy was. If you were worried about the Pro Bowl, then you should have changed your teams strategy. The fact is, even though McDragon "split" carries and "played less" Prowler RAN THE BALL LESS. That's..all..that..matters. Your a freaking running back for god's sake.

If you think a guy on the 6th best team in Zeta, routinely facing teams who overpower his offensive line should NOT make the Pro Bowl after averaging an amazing 10.6 yards a carry simply because your back "could" have done better if he "started," then your absolutly nuts. It's your own damn fault he's not "starting." Of course, McDragon DID carry the ball more, and one more time, that's all that matters.

This was in my opinion, and my opinion has been made. I trust that you'll survive, or at least bring some better reasoning to the table.
 
Loco Moco
offline
Link
 
How's that go?
Oh yeah!

PWND

(I'm just learning text lingo, but this one applies here, I believe)

 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Fuck, Oakland, you love your dot.
 
oakland360
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by oakland360

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by oakland360



Originally posted by Rogafella




no offence oak but mcdragon caught 8 passes out of the backfield and thorn caught 61, i think thats well worth the 13 more drops and that point to your arguement isnt really helping the cause


same argument as the 8 lost fumbles... non of those fumbles hurt my team. Only 7 points came of of 1 of those turnovers. And we won all of those games. He wasn't held for under 100 yards rushing by anyone this season. I doubt that any other starting RB can boast that here. And he scored a TD in all but 1 game. "Tails' Prowler can't boast that. Matter of fact "Tails" was held under 100yds 5 different times. So dropping the ball does mean something if fumbles mean something. Plus both "Tails" Prowler and P. Thorn averaged way more plays a game than McDragon. That's where the 50/50 argument comes in. Not to mention McDragon is a lower Lvl. than both the other RB's and put up better numbers... Come on dude, you've got to be kidding me. Do the math... I put all the numbers up for ya. The writing is on the wall.

Also I'm pretty sure if that if I had the energy to check it. McDragon would have way more 1st downs gained than either of the other two RB's mentioned here.

Shananigans, I call Shananigans... the Committee has other players ranked above two of my players that should easily be on this list. Shananigans!!! If your going to use the playing time for an Offensive or Defensive lineman... you have to use it for the Running Backs as well. Otherwise your logic doesn't add up and your being hypocritical.


Throwout the blowout games, and you have an average RB.

You do realize this right? You are basing your "stats" off of a 174-0 win where you rushed for 500+ yards,


If you want me to throw out my blowout games.... thats all the games we played... we blew everyone out except for Port Royal. Oh and in that case, have them throw out every game not played against the Dreads, Valencia, or San Juan. Both those backs did terrible against those teams. Not to mention that "Tails" P put up a goose egg vs. a CPU team. Dude, you can't use 1 argument against me, and not use that same argument vs. them as well. Once again that'd be hypocritical. McDragon put up great numbers against everyone... Even the common opponents... i.e. United Evo, Dreads, Valencia, Rio. Use your eyes, look at the stats/game film. I did. My argument is rock solid with facts to back it up. I broke down every game these 3 guys had. And Guess what... McDragon wins the battle vs. "Tails" P all day long.



Throw out all the games that were 80+ points to 20- less and again, you come out with an AVERAGE back,

I know you don't get that, it's ok, you can think he is the greatest back in all of GLB, point remains, he isn't even on the radar.


on that same token, throw out every game that "Tails" had against a non playoff team except for against Riobamba a CPU team that he put up a goose egg on. A big fat 0. And McDragon still beats him out all day, every day. Dude, do your own math. Or just do it like this. Only count the playoff teams. What's this. McDragons numbers are still better when done that way too? Dude your a tool, and will always be a tool.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.