User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Cornerback SA's
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Originally posted by jared

this is a really good idea, and I agree the speedster abilities kind of blow


I only use the first two in that tree to be honest


because the rest blow gigantic donkey dick right?
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
CB's SAs arn't the only ones in question though. I know I have a hard time putting points into most of my DT's SAs.
Last edited Dec 10, 2008 20:16:55
 
Link
 
I love it
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Bump and run definitely needs to be integrated somehow, but i dont think redoing the trees is going to work.
 
Pete Carroll
offline
Link
 
I love it.
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
They are fine the way they are, the WR and CB SA trees check and balance each other. If the CB SA tree was fixed, they would have to fix the WR one to check and balance it which would inevitablely lead to more complaining about the need to fix it again.
 
simmjer
offline
Link
 
Nice rockstr!!
 
Lockdown U
offline
Link
 
there could be a change in WR tree also. like physical receiver.

Stock Block advanced

Run through(DB's have a hard time trying to slow this guy up)

Catch in traffic

YAC(The receiver is really physical and adapts to breaking that first tackle off the catch, needs a fair amount of strength carrying agility for this to work)

Push back(Corners have a tough time trying to jam and push this guy, we will do whatever means necessary to start off that route with perfect timing between him and the QB)Needs strength for this to work
Last edited Dec 11, 2008 13:49:38
 
kentrol72
offline
Link
 
nice retort rocstrr +1
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rockstrr
there could be a change in WR tree also. like physical receiver.

Stock Block advanced

Run through(DB's have a hard time trying to slow this guy up)

Catch in traffic

YAC(The receiver is really physical and adapts to breaking that first tackle off the catch, needs a fair amount of strength carrying agility for this to work)

Push back(Corners have a tough time trying to jam and push this guy, we will do whatever means necessary to start off that route with perfect timing between him and the QB)Needs strength for this to work


This would essentially be a nerf to WRs and give CBs the upper hand. Strength is not part of the WRs game. If they had to skill point it for the SAs to work, that would take away from skills that are actually useful to them such as speed, agility, catching, etc. I don't see Bort screwing over the WRs like that when they aren't broken.
 
catabowl
offline
Link
 
+1 to idea

Only problem would be: If you have speedster SA's, should the SA's spent there automatically move to the new tree OR get a "refund" on half of SP spent on those SA's and redistribute.
 
Bushido
offline
Link
 
+100000000000000000
 
vladykins
offline
Link
 
Good idea.
 
divinevert
offline
Link
 
These would all be useless until Bort redoes the way corners play defense, because currently they don't jam or play physical at the line at all.
Last edited Dec 11, 2008 14:50:18
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
^ and it would require an overhaul to Speed WRs which isn't going to happen, they are far to popular. The best bet for this idea would be to propose a third SA tree, that way they can implement one for WRs to check and balance the new CB tree without destroying peoples current builds.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.