User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Teams Attempting to Exploit the System
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
I've never understood this argument - if anything you'd want the computer to adjust your players to get them in a better position - thats called auto adjust.

If you players aren't good enough - why should you get the equivalent of a Steroid cycle of Temp Boosts during a game just because you can't stop a play?

It's crazy - it's like saying because my LOT keeps getting beat by the RDE that each time he beats me I get a boost to my stats to the point I can stop him because he's using the same rush technique every time.

Thats like trying to make Jeff Backus into Anthony Munoz over the course of a game just because he's facing Lawrence Taylor.



No, it's because no team could win in football at just about any level by running the same play over and over again, because the other team would figure out it was coming.

"Figure out it was coming" would be the reason for the Vision increase. It's true the OP was wrong in wanting the increase to be across the board, but there should be a very large Vision increase.

Last edited Dec 5, 2008 00:21:29
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Ken1 is right here...in that we need to focus on the argument in this thread. Which is just about teams running the same plays over and over. That's all. Got nothing to do with other analogies or indirect examples. Just about teams running the same plays over and over.

Ie...people should be allowed to run them...but they should be penalized for it...just like it would in real life. All you have to do is watch the Raiders on offense this year to see how predictable they are, running the same plays over and over, the same formations, etc.
Last edited Dec 5, 2008 00:25:51
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Ken1 is right here...in that we need to focus on the argument in this thread. Which is just about teams running the same plays over and over. That's all. Got nothing to do with other analogies or indirect examples. Just about teams running the same plays over and over.

Ie...people should be allowed to run them...but they should be penalized for it...just like it would in real life. All you have to do is watch the Raiders on offense this year to see how predictable they are, running the same plays over and over, the same formations, etc.


Bingo.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by greengoose

I've never understood this argument - if anything you'd want the computer to adjust your players to get them in a better position - thats called auto adjust.

If you players aren't good enough - why should you get the equivalent of a Steroid cycle of Temp Boosts during a game just because you can't stop a play?

It's crazy - it's like saying because my LOT keeps getting beat by the RDE that each time he beats me I get a boost to my stats to the point I can stop him because he's using the same rush technique every time.

Thats like trying to make Jeff Backus into Anthony Munoz over the course of a game just because he's facing Lawrence Taylor.



No, it's because no team could win in football at just about any level by running the same play over and over again, because the other team would figure out it was coming.

"Figure out it was coming" would be the reason for the Vision increase. It's true the OP was wrong in wanting the increase to be across the board, but there should be a very large Vision increase.



Exactly!!!!! They would make FORMATION changes to get overload mismatches - not ship in Albert Haynesworth to replace Cory Redding.....

You guys are trying to change the WRONG element of the game. The players are what they are - they shouldn't get free temp boosts to make them better than they are.
 
trazer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Teams running the same play over and over are the EASIEST teams to game plan for - whats the problem?

If my guys properly places aren't good enough to stop the same play over and over - maybe I need to get better players......


Why do people always post this crap? it makes no sense. Sure thats easy to do if you KNOW they are going to do it.

What happens if i read about a play thats easily exploitable and the next game i run it 45 times? How the hell is the other team going to know i was going to do that? THEY FUCKING DONT. Idiots always thinking they can predict the future and just say OMGZ YOU SHOULD HAVE GAMEPLANNED FOR THAT PLAY THAT YOU DIDNT KNOW THEY WERE GOING TO RUN 78 TIMES!!.. Shut your mouth idiot.


Originally posted by greengoose
I've never understood this argument - if anything you'd want the computer to adjust your players to get them in a better position - thats called auto adjust.

If you players aren't good enough - why should you get the equivalent of a Steroid cycle of Temp Boosts during a game just because you can't stop a play?

It's crazy - it's like saying because my LOT keeps getting beat by the RDE that each time he beats me I get a boost to my stats to the point I can stop him because he's using the same rush technique every time.

Thats like trying to make Jeff Backus into Anthony Munoz over the course of a game just because he's facing Lawrence Taylor. If you need Anthony Munoz to stop Lawrence Taylor then go sign Munoz before the game


This is also stupid. Nobody is saying that just because a PLAYER is better that the other team should get a boost. Thats perfectly reasonable and if he is better he should be better thats that.

They are suggesting that the game (in a way) Adjusts your gameplan effectively (no i didnt say directly changes the gameplan but it has the same overall effect) By letting the team stop that play better and better over the course of the game by making the players better. I realize thats not going to happen IRL but it has the same "Basic effect" as a team being able to change the plays mid game which DOES happen IRL to stop a play thats ran a billion times.

Im willing to bet that you are one of the cheese artists that likes to take advantage of bullshit stuff like the OP is talking about.

While that is your decision, its not very honorable. Im sure you dont care about honor..thats just your crappy upbringing though.
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

not a new idea, but a good one.

the %'s are WAAAAAAAAAY too high though.

All the messing around with the chemistry bar only has a total effect of 6% I think. I don't think it should even be 10% to attributes. In fact, it should be limited to VISION increase.

Something like a 1% increase in vision for all defenders each time a play is run sounds like the best way.


Fully agree. It should be a Vision increase only.

If it's a Vision increase only, then the numbers are reasonable (as long as the "boost for the rest of the game" means only against that play).


For all I care you can boost the defenses vision to 10000 and it still won't stop the Strong I run.

DD laughed last time I suggested something similar to this, and took the thread off track with his bullshit.

I've been posting for 3 or 4 seasons now about that ONE running play that we all know of to no response from any of the Devs.

It's a game and if you can't code it properly to handle certain plays, take them the fuck out of figure a way to penalize the hell out of a team that keeps running that play over and over.

The vision bonus for realism has no place against exploitation but it deserves some merit in regular gameplay against plays run on a fairly consistent basis with the hitch being it makes play calls that are for instance a play action give the defense a vision penalty if the bonus is in affect against the "more common" play.
 
trazer
offline
Link
 
Just to clarify, im not for the temp boosts mid game..im just explaining what they are asking for. While you are just being an idiot.

The Vision increase is a damn Genius idea though, and pretty damn realistic. (though i think the vision increase should only be gained on that play if/when its called.)

Who the hell WOULDNT be looking for that play everytime that formation comes up. haha
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Agree with Flames54 - if the play is overpowered then nerf it or take it out of the game.

The LAST thing we need to be doing is making players better than they are. The point is a players performance level should slowly DETERIORATE as the game goes along - not ELEVATE to levels above what they are possibly even capable of.
 
trazer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Agree with Flames54 - if the play is overpowered then nerf it or take it out of the game.

The LAST thing we need to be doing is making players better than they are. The point is a players performance level should slowly DETERIORATE as the game goes along - not ELEVATE to levels above what they are possibly even capable of.


I agree mostly there. I believe a players Physical abilities should deteriorate over the course of the game. Stats like vision and confidence could go either way.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trazer
Just to clarify, im not for the temp boosts mid game..im just explaining what they are asking for. While you are just being an idiot.

The Vision increase is a damn Genius idea though, and pretty damn realistic. (though i think the vision increase should only be gained on that play if/when its called.)

Who the hell WOULDNT be looking for that play everytime that formation comes up. haha


Seeing a play, knowing it's going to happen isn't the same as stopping it. If your players are otherwise capable of stopping it (i.e. built well) then this will accomplish the objective (if Vision really works like is suggested).

On the other hand if your players aren't built well enough to stop the play to begin with all the Vision in the world isn't gonna help much. Thats the Detroit Lions - they know where they are supposed to be but they don't have the ability to shed blocks and tackle properly.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Originally posted by trazer

Just to clarify, im not for the temp boosts mid game..im just explaining what they are asking for. While you are just being an idiot.

The Vision increase is a damn Genius idea though, and pretty damn realistic. (though i think the vision increase should only be gained on that play if/when its called.)

Who the hell WOULDNT be looking for that play everytime that formation comes up. haha


Seeing a play, knowing it's going to happen isn't the same as stopping it. If your players are otherwise capable of stopping it (i.e. built well) then this will accomplish the objective (if Vision really works like is suggested).

On the other hand if your players aren't built well enough to stop the play to begin with all the Vision in the world isn't gonna help much. Thats the Detroit Lions - they know where they are supposed to be but they don't have the ability to shed blocks and tackle properly.


I think you'd agree, though. If you, as a defensive player, know PRECISELY what play is coming, you've got a significantly higher better chance to cause pressure on that play than if an offense is running a versatile, semi-unpredictable plan. Perhaps not stop it, but you're going to have an impact.

I think the Lions example is a bad analogy with regards to this issue. Lions players are like the OTs with 25 agility, or the CBs with 25 strength, or the OLBs whose speed/agility ratio is hovering around 4:1. They're just not very good players, and they're playing ill-fitting schemes. Their morale is shot, no confidence, etc. And it's not like they're getting beaten 56-0 every game, they keep it respectable. They just don't win.

 
GG
offline
Link
 
Just on play-actions...I notice it doesnt do anything in the game. You dont ever see DBs/LBs biting hard. Instead you just see the fact that a play is a play-action. Just like you see a play is a Shotgun formation. You dont ever see a true change in players on the field. The LBs still run up and down the field all day covering speedy slot receivers. The defense still sticks like glue to the WR during a play-action play, etc.

But yes...the problem which this thread is addressing as well is that whole lack of in-game adjustments. There is none, so exploits are always there. There need to be measures coded in that are like a surrogate brain for each player on the field. In that things like vision increases etc every time a team runs the same plays. Things like bigger momentum shifts when players break up a play they've read/reacted to. Etc. There needs to be more in-game interplay here. Even more measures like when a play is run unsuccessfully the AI tries to look for some other output to run. Because i notice that if I have 10 outputs, the AI often keeps running the same play/output whether it's successful or not. There's a lack of "intelligence" being given to advanced ai, that only exists in the basic ai. It should be there in the advanced ai too.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


not a new idea, but a good one.

the %'s are WAAAAAAAAAY too high though.

All the messing around with the chemistry bar only has a total effect of 6% I think. I don't think it should even be 10% to attributes. In fact, it should be limited to VISION increase.

Something like a 1% increase in vision for all defenders each time a play is run sounds like the best way.


Fully agree. It should be a Vision increase only.

If it's a Vision increase only, then the numbers are reasonable (as long as the "boost for the rest of the game" means only against that play).


For all I care you can boost the defenses vision to 10000 and it still won't stop the Strong I run.


Actually, it depends on how Vision works/is supposed to work.

I'd take anything over 100 as more or less reading the play before it develops, such that if an entire defense had it against the Strong I run the LB's would move directly to that hole, as would the SS, with the FS moving a few yards behind to catch the back if he cut left or right. The CB's would run in that direction, knowing it wasn't a pass, and the weak side linemen would detach from their normal rush, knowing it was a strong side run and moving to stop it.

Doesn't mean the game would actually do that, but that's how it ought to work.

I was talking about repeated plays in general, though; there's nothing to force us to use a variety.

If the problem is a specific play being too powerful, then Greengoose is right; either nerf it or remove it. But that's an entirely different discussion.
 
trazer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Originally posted by trazer

Just to clarify, im not for the temp boosts mid game..im just explaining what they are asking for. While you are just being an idiot.

The Vision increase is a damn Genius idea though, and pretty damn realistic. (though i think the vision increase should only be gained on that play if/when its called.)

Who the hell WOULDNT be looking for that play everytime that formation comes up. haha


Seeing a play, knowing it's going to happen isn't the same as stopping it. If your players are otherwise capable of stopping it (i.e. built well) then this will accomplish the objective (if Vision really works like is suggested).

On the other hand if your players aren't built well enough to stop the play to begin with all the Vision in the world isn't gonna help much. Thats the Detroit Lions - they know where they are supposed to be but they don't have the ability to shed blocks and tackle properly.


I agree totally. Give em the vision. If they still cant stop em..fuck em, they dont deserve to stop the play.

Put 3rd graders vs NFL players and tell the 3rd graders what play they are running every time. They will NEVER stop them. Thats how it SHOULD be. Give them the vision, thats realistic. Dont give them more skills.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by greengoose

Originally posted by trazer


Just to clarify, im not for the temp boosts mid game..im just explaining what they are asking for. While you are just being an idiot.

The Vision increase is a damn Genius idea though, and pretty damn realistic. (though i think the vision increase should only be gained on that play if/when its called.)

Who the hell WOULDNT be looking for that play everytime that formation comes up. haha


Seeing a play, knowing it's going to happen isn't the same as stopping it. If your players are otherwise capable of stopping it (i.e. built well) then this will accomplish the objective (if Vision really works like is suggested).

On the other hand if your players aren't built well enough to stop the play to begin with all the Vision in the world isn't gonna help much. Thats the Detroit Lions - they know where they are supposed to be but they don't have the ability to shed blocks and tackle properly.


I think you'd agree, though. If you, as a defensive player, know PRECISELY what play is coming, you've got a significantly higher better chance to cause pressure on that play than if an offense is running a versatile, semi-unpredictable plan. Perhaps not stop it, but you're going to have an impact.

I think the Lions example is a bad analogy with regards to this issue. Lions players are like the OTs with 25 agility, or the CBs with 25 strength, or the OLBs whose speed/agility ratio is hovering around 4:1. They're just not very good players, and they're playing ill-fitting schemes. Their morale is shot, no confidence, etc. And it's not like they're getting beaten 56-0 every game, they keep it respectable. They just don't win.



I'm talking both ends of the spectrum here - i.e. the GLB landscape. If a team players are built well enough to otherwise stop the play if properly positioned a Vision boost might help. The Detroit Lions analogy is the other end of the spectrum.

This change would affect both types of teams - problem is the latter teams would be looking for this to aid them in stopping the opposition but in reality it won't help much.

The real issue is player positioning. There are only two elements that control that - pre-snap formation and in-game Vision. Any in-game changes to that I'd be all for - any changes which make a player physically better than he'd normally be as the game goes on just to compensate for an inability to otherwise stop a play I'm not.

The argument this thread started with is very much like the SA's that give a boost to WR's on 3rd down plays (Sticky Hands) - I'm against them too.

If a guy who otherwise doesn't have the skillset to consistently catch passes on 1st and 2nd down with Sticky Hands- why is he getting an additional boost on 3rd down to his catching ability? That makes absolutely no sense - a clutch player doesn't suddenly learn how to catch in the clutch, he's an already good player that continues that level of performance in the clutch when others crumble. Increase Morale on 3rd down fine - increase Catching ability on 3rd down - that makes no sense.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.