yea notak's last idea is pretty solid along with the fact that the owners who do post can look past their team and tell you who is worthy. I honestly think that right now SEC has 3 guys who should be "Pro Bowlers", I couldn't honestly tell you the rest but thats why we get nominations. The owners in this league are all very experienced and know who is worthy from their team and who would be a joke.
DarkVirtue
offline
offline
lol totally pointless when we know from the leaders stats who the best players are lol.
Notak
offline
offline
Originally posted by DarkVirtue
lol totally pointless when we know from the leaders stats who the best players are lol.
but that is not always so. I QB from a mid range team that has a ton of yards and what not, might not be as good as a QB that is middle of the pack. INT's play a roll and there is a lot of things. IF you dont want to take part it is fine, but I am not voting for players just because they are the leaders in their category. I mean you have a point, but most is not always the best.
Plus, I think it is a show of respect always. I think that Oliva V, the running back from the commandos is the best back we have seen so far, but Paden McCoy and MArion Barber wrecked house on us too, but as of right now Oliva V would have my vote and he is not at the top.
Plus, there are a lot of positions. I think this will be fun and something more than, oh that guy blow up against the computer team!
lol totally pointless when we know from the leaders stats who the best players are lol.
but that is not always so. I QB from a mid range team that has a ton of yards and what not, might not be as good as a QB that is middle of the pack. INT's play a roll and there is a lot of things. IF you dont want to take part it is fine, but I am not voting for players just because they are the leaders in their category. I mean you have a point, but most is not always the best.
Plus, I think it is a show of respect always. I think that Oliva V, the running back from the commandos is the best back we have seen so far, but Paden McCoy and MArion Barber wrecked house on us too, but as of right now Oliva V would have my vote and he is not at the top.
Plus, there are a lot of positions. I think this will be fun and something more than, oh that guy blow up against the computer team!
TheBuck
offline
offline
Originally posted by DarkVirtue
lol totally pointless when we know from the leaders stats who the best players are lol.
League leaders rarely tell the whole story ... example: Pancakes ... most of the "leaders" in pancakes are because they also play on special teams and have a field day against CB's and LB's ... are those the best lineman?
Also, running backs - the two leaders are both from the Dawgs ... are they the best running backs in the league? Oliva and McCoy both have 75-100 fewer carries and a higher average per carry... are they the two best?
Fullbacks ... you looking at who is the best at blocking ... who is the best at rushing?
and I could continue with every postiion ...
Stats are only an indicator ...
lol totally pointless when we know from the leaders stats who the best players are lol.
League leaders rarely tell the whole story ... example: Pancakes ... most of the "leaders" in pancakes are because they also play on special teams and have a field day against CB's and LB's ... are those the best lineman?
Also, running backs - the two leaders are both from the Dawgs ... are they the best running backs in the league? Oliva and McCoy both have 75-100 fewer carries and a higher average per carry... are they the two best?
Fullbacks ... you looking at who is the best at blocking ... who is the best at rushing?
and I could continue with every postiion ...
Stats are only an indicator ...
DarkVirtue
offline
offline
sounds kinda silly all you have to do is click the stat you liek to see who has the most int or the most of what ever you like. Who cares what other owners think, we know which players are the best. Also you can't really consider anyone the best in this League when most of the teams this year where CPU or gutted teams lol. If your proud of a player because he got great stats form cpu teams then go for it but its not that great lol. Feels like we have 6 lion's teams we all played against.
lvlr Football
offline
offline
Originally posted by TheBuck
Originally posted by DarkVirtue
lol totally pointless when we know from the leaders stats who the best players are lol.
League leaders rarely tell the whole story ... example: Pancakes ... most of the "leaders" in pancakes are because they also play on special teams and have a field day against CB's and LB's ... are those the best lineman?
Also, running backs - the two leaders are both from the Dawgs ... are they the best running backs in the league? Oliva and McCoy both have 75-100 fewer carries and a higher average per carry... are they the two best?
Fullbacks ... you looking at who is the best at blocking ... who is the best at rushing?
and I could continue with every postiion ...
Stats are only an indicator ...
if that's the case include TD we have. plus u would need to look at levels. my hb is a level 23. compared to some that are higher, which should be putting up better stats especially if they are lvl 24 or higher cause they will also have a bigger advantage due to equipment and more SP.
Originally posted by DarkVirtue
lol totally pointless when we know from the leaders stats who the best players are lol.
League leaders rarely tell the whole story ... example: Pancakes ... most of the "leaders" in pancakes are because they also play on special teams and have a field day against CB's and LB's ... are those the best lineman?
Also, running backs - the two leaders are both from the Dawgs ... are they the best running backs in the league? Oliva and McCoy both have 75-100 fewer carries and a higher average per carry... are they the two best?
Fullbacks ... you looking at who is the best at blocking ... who is the best at rushing?
and I could continue with every postiion ...
Stats are only an indicator ...
if that's the case include TD we have. plus u would need to look at levels. my hb is a level 23. compared to some that are higher, which should be putting up better stats especially if they are lvl 24 or higher cause they will also have a bigger advantage due to equipment and more SP.
TheBuck
offline
offline
Originally posted by DarkVirtue
sounds kinda silly all you have to do is click the stat you liek to see who has the most int or the most of what ever you like. Who cares what other owners think, we know which players are the best. Also you can't really consider anyone the best in this League when most of the teams this year where CPU or gutted teams lol. If your proud of a player because he got great stats form cpu teams then go for it but its not that great lol. Feels like we have 6 lion's teams we all played against.
If you don't agree, then just don't do it ... fairly simple.
sounds kinda silly all you have to do is click the stat you liek to see who has the most int or the most of what ever you like. Who cares what other owners think, we know which players are the best. Also you can't really consider anyone the best in this League when most of the teams this year where CPU or gutted teams lol. If your proud of a player because he got great stats form cpu teams then go for it but its not that great lol. Feels like we have 6 lion's teams we all played against.
If you don't agree, then just don't do it ... fairly simple.
lvlr Football
offline
offline
plus u will need to look at goaline carries which could take away from yards per carry, to get a good average. take away in carries from opp 7 yard line that ended up as a TD. all those 1-5 yard TD's I have hurts my yrds per carry.
TheBuck
offline
offline
Originally posted by lvlr Football
plus u will need to look at goaline carries which could take away from yards per carry, to get a good average. take away in carries from opp 7 yard line that ended up as a TD. all those 1-5 yard TD's I have hurts my yrds per carry.
Ivlr ... It was a rhetorical statement to show there are many good backs out there and you can't just look at the stats to say which back is the best - you have to look at the film but you are kinda illustrating the other point that I made.
Originally posted by TheBuck
I'll roll with whatever is decided ... from what I have seen in other leagues though is people can't look past their own team.
plus u will need to look at goaline carries which could take away from yards per carry, to get a good average. take away in carries from opp 7 yard line that ended up as a TD. all those 1-5 yard TD's I have hurts my yrds per carry.
Ivlr ... It was a rhetorical statement to show there are many good backs out there and you can't just look at the stats to say which back is the best - you have to look at the film but you are kinda illustrating the other point that I made.
Originally posted by TheBuck
I'll roll with whatever is decided ... from what I have seen in other leagues though is people can't look past their own team.
Last edited Dec 3, 2008 08:53:22
Notak
offline
offline
Agreed, this is for the owners to decide, not the stats, not Bort, this is awards that we are goign to try and give to our own conference. IF you think it is doen you and your team do not need to take part in it. I have played against a lot of DB's this season and only a few have shutdown my WR's, they may not have TD's, but they took my WR out of the game and to me that is more important. I would rather have a team with crappy stats and W's than a crappy team leading the categories.
OK, so how do we get all the teams envolved? Should I send out a pm to all of them? and see the response?
OK, so how do we get all the teams envolved? Should I send out a pm to all of them? and see the response?
Mobius
offline
offline
I'd say this as a primer, look at your teams toughest games and matchups you played and who continued to excel in those game situations, those are the players that you should hold up and nominate.
Not everyone is going to go through all the play by plays but if you start with your toughest games and who excelled in those and then look to the other games for further confirmation of 'greatness' and consistancy it should also be there as well.
If all you do is look at the stats then you're not taking the quality time to do this right, imo
To notak, thx for taking this on, I'd say send a PM to all owners to see who's involved and post a list of those that reply... It would be nice to see who interested in this.
Not everyone is going to go through all the play by plays but if you start with your toughest games and who excelled in those and then look to the other games for further confirmation of 'greatness' and consistancy it should also be there as well.
If all you do is look at the stats then you're not taking the quality time to do this right, imo
To notak, thx for taking this on, I'd say send a PM to all owners to see who's involved and post a list of those that reply... It would be nice to see who interested in this.
jlusch21
offline
offline
Originally posted by TheBuck
I'll roll with whatever is decided ... from what I have seen in other leagues though is people can't look past their own team.
I would like to study each team and pick who should make the all-star team, but honestly, I don't want to do that. I personally wouldn't mind choosing two players from my team to represent Pretoria in an All-star game (or whatever it is). It makes everything simple and easy.
Let me know *officially* what were doing. Thanks.
I'll roll with whatever is decided ... from what I have seen in other leagues though is people can't look past their own team.
I would like to study each team and pick who should make the all-star team, but honestly, I don't want to do that. I personally wouldn't mind choosing two players from my team to represent Pretoria in an All-star game (or whatever it is). It makes everything simple and easy.
Let me know *officially* what were doing. Thanks.
hwalker34
offline
offline
love the idea if i get a pm i will respond... probably will send a short list of players that i nominate form my team , not a whole list dont have too many
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























