User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Same play decay
Page:
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
-1 to the OP

I'll offer something along the same lines but more realistic...

Take it a step further and tie it into vision by giving each player a built-in 'auto-adjust' based on how much vision they have. That way, players with weak vision don't get an unrealistic boost to reaction time (as the OP suggests) and adjust slower than a player with higher vision would to a play that's being run repeatedly. This would apply to both offense and defense.

This way, the 'play decay' is still achieved but it's far more realistic as it'll be based on the player and not some general, unrealistic boost (or penalty) being granted to an entire unit despite the players' abilities. You'd also achieve more dynamic gameplay.
Last edited Dec 4, 2008 09:38:48
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
I think there should be a setting where you can tell your players to "jump" a play if run X amount of times in a game.

In the case of the Strong I run, that would be similar to the LDE and NT pinching the gap between the OG and OT, SS and LBs coming up faster to that side of the field.

In the case of some of the pass plays, it might lead to safeties playing up closer to where WRs have caught the pass in the past plays, and possibly get a jump on the INT.

The downside being that if the team then throws a different play out of that formation, the defense is totally exposed.

In the case of a screen, it could lead to DEs recognizing the play faster and peeling off to stop it.

I don't know how hard that would be to code, but offhand it seems doable.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by basshound3
Originally posted by OttawaShane

agree entirely. After a play is run 3 or 4 times, there should be a 5% (or whatever) vision boost for the defence each time the play is subsequently run.

Its been discussed before and its an outstanding idea, perfectly fitting in with RL football.


i would have to disagree... How many times did the Dolphins bust out the Wildcat formation successfully on the Patriots earlier in the NFL season. Some plays just confuse the hell out of a defense or a defense is simply unable to stop it


And none of those plays exist in GLB.

Anyone who has played ball knows that once you've seen the same play a couple of times, its much easier to recognize where the ball is heading and get that play shut down. Superior offensive personnel can still make that play effective, its just a bit harder.

RL offence can exploit that - an offence will set up the d by giving them a certain look, running the same play out of that look a couple of times - and then giving them the same look again and have the play be something totally different than the defence is anticipating.

the intent here though is to add more realism, which is that if a team runs the same play x times, the defence is going to be much smarter at reacting to it.

And for that, it gets my +1000 and request to make this suggestion epic.
Last edited Dec 4, 2008 09:40:35
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
-1 to the OP

I'll offer something along the same lines but more realistic...

Take it a step further and tie it into vision by giving each player a built-in 'auto-adjust' based on how much vision they have. That way, players with weak vision don't get an unrealistic boost to reaction time (as the OP suggests) and adjust slower than a player with higher vision would to a play that's being run repeatedly. This would apply to both offense and defense.

This way, the 'play decay' is still achieved but it's far more realistic as it'll be based on the player and not some general, unrealistic boost (or penalty) being granted to an entire unit despite the players' abilities. You'd also achieve more dynamic gameplay.


So the vision boost only happens for players who have hit a certain vision threshold - that makes sense. I wouldn't make the threshold too high though, because its really not that hard to read the same play over and over - and make the vision boost a % of each players existing vision, rather than a simple +5 or whatever - that will give greater reward to higher vision players and reduce the effect on lower vision players.

 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
Originally posted by SAGA45

-1 to the OP

I'll offer something along the same lines but more realistic...

Take it a step further and tie it into vision by giving each player a built-in 'auto-adjust' based on how much vision they have. That way, players with weak vision don't get an unrealistic boost to reaction time (as the OP suggests) and adjust slower than a player with higher vision would to a play that's being run repeatedly. This would apply to both offense and defense.

This way, the 'play decay' is still achieved but it's far more realistic as it'll be based on the player and not some general, unrealistic boost (or penalty) being granted to an entire unit despite the players' abilities. You'd also achieve more dynamic gameplay.


So the vision boost only happens for players who have hit a certain vision threshold - that makes sense.


No, there is no 'vision boost' with what I'm suggesting. I'm proposing every player have an ability to adapt (or 'auto-adjust' as I described earlier) to the tendencies of the opponent based on the amount of vision that player already has.

A player with low vision would still adapt to those tendencies but it'd take him longer to do it than a player with higher vision. That way, the player's own vision is the 'threshold' for how slow or fast they react/adapt to the tendencies of the opponent. That's what I was stating before. Also, this would apply to both offense and defense thus creating gameplay that is dynamic.
Last edited Dec 4, 2008 09:57:39
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
Originally posted by OttawaShane

Originally posted by SAGA45


-1 to the OP

I'll offer something along the same lines but more realistic...

Take it a step further and tie it into vision by giving each player a built-in 'auto-adjust' based on how much vision they have. That way, players with weak vision don't get an unrealistic boost to reaction time (as the OP suggests) and adjust slower than a player with higher vision would to a play that's being run repeatedly. This would apply to both offense and defense.

This way, the 'play decay' is still achieved but it's far more realistic as it'll be based on the player and not some general, unrealistic boost (or penalty) being granted to an entire unit despite the players' abilities. You'd also achieve more dynamic gameplay.


So the vision boost only happens for players who have hit a certain vision threshold - that makes sense.


No, there is no 'vision boost' with what I'm suggesting. I'm proposing every player have an ability to adapt (or 'auto-adjust' as I described earlier) to the tendencies of the opponent based on the amount of vision that player already has.

A player with low vision would still adapt to those tendencies but it'd take him longer to do it than a player with higher vision. That way, the player's own vision is the 'threshold' for how slow or fast they react/adapt to the tendencies of the opponent. That's what I was stating before. Also, this would apply to both offense and defense thus creating gameplay that is dynamic.


Interesting - I'm glad I don't have to program something like this. Math is hard.

In the end, for programming simplicity, a vision boost might suffice, but your idea is solid.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
Originally posted by OttawaShane

Originally posted by SAGA45


-1 to the OP

I'll offer something along the same lines but more realistic...

Take it a step further and tie it into vision by giving each player a built-in 'auto-adjust' based on how much vision they have. That way, players with weak vision don't get an unrealistic boost to reaction time (as the OP suggests) and adjust slower than a player with higher vision would to a play that's being run repeatedly. This would apply to both offense and defense.

This way, the 'play decay' is still achieved but it's far more realistic as it'll be based on the player and not some general, unrealistic boost (or penalty) being granted to an entire unit despite the players' abilities. You'd also achieve more dynamic gameplay.


So the vision boost only happens for players who have hit a certain vision threshold - that makes sense.


No, there is no 'vision boost' with what I'm suggesting. I'm proposing every player have an ability to adapt (or 'auto-adjust' as I described earlier) to the tendencies of the opponent based on the amount of vision that player already has.

A player with low vision would still adapt to those tendencies but it'd take him longer to do it than a player with higher vision. That way, the player's own vision is the 'threshold' for how slow or fast they react/adapt to the tendencies of the opponent. That's what I was stating before. Also, this would apply to both offense and defense thus creating gameplay that is dynamic.


How do you propose they adapt? Is it just that LBs don't back up so far in running downs, or CBs don't bite on fakes on passing plays?

I think it needs to be two things. There needs to be a positive affect and a negative affect. IRL, defenses definitely adapt. However, if a team has been running right all game and then runs a counter left, the defense is left completely exposed. There needs to be this kind of metagame imo
 
Cardinal51
offline
Link
 
Agree. For those that don't agree based on the inability of a defense to stop "some plays", this isn't an RTS where you can even attempt to adjust during a game. The sim is set and there is NO chance to recover unless you give up your whole game plan (a decision made prior to the game) to automatically throw your entire AI out the window and auto-adjust.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bmedders
I think it needs to be two things. There needs to be a positive affect and a negative affect. IRL, defenses definitely adapt. However, if a team has been running right all game and then runs a counter left, the defense is left completely exposed. There needs to be this kind of metagame imo


For one, offenses make adjustments to tendencies as well. Not just defense. Just wanted to make that clear since that point has been overlooked thus far in this thread. There'd need to be balance.

Secondly, GLB playcalling, unlike RL, doesn't happen in real-time which is the source of the problem. I'm a against a simple, general vision boost being given to an entire team or unit. I'm more in favor of an addition/change to how vision works in terms of an individual player's ability to adapt in-game. That's the only realistic solution since, again, GLB playcalling isn't real-time and the gameplan for entire game is already scripted.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
Originally posted by bmedders

I think it needs to be two things. There needs to be a positive affect and a negative affect. IRL, defenses definitely adapt. However, if a team has been running right all game and then runs a counter left, the defense is left completely exposed. There needs to be this kind of metagame imo


For one, offenses make adjustments to tendencies as well. Not just defense. Just wanted to make that clear since that point has been overlooked thus far in this thread. There'd need to be balance.

Secondly, GLB playcalling, unlike RL, doesn't happen in real-time which is the source of the problem. I'm a against a simple, general vision boost being given to an entire team or unit. I'm more in favor of an addition/change to how vision works in terms of an individual player's ability to adapt in-game. That's the only realistic solution since, again, GLB playcalling isn't real-time and the gameplan for entire game is already scripted.


I think a boost of stats is unrealistic and not the right way to do this. IMO, you need things like D-linemen attacking different gaps, LBs and SSs cheating towards different areas of the field, etc.

And absolutely the QB should get a boost if a defense sits in cover 2 all day. IMO if the defense stays in the same shell of the same man/zone call, the QB should start developing a "memory" of who got open with this call before, and have an additional check to go to look for that. However, the flipside is that he suffers when the defenses are constantly changing between zone/man cover 1/cover 2, which LB blitzes, etc.

Both of these are just examples, obviously it needs to work both ways.
Last edited Dec 4, 2008 10:51:53
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
i agree that something needs to be done...

i also think (like others have said) that it should go both ways.

there should be an adjustment so that when an offense runs the same plays repeatedly - it becomes less effective

at the same time - a defense that runs the same play repeatedly should be less effective (as an example; the same CB or LB blitzing every play)
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Epic, please.
 
basshound3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
Epic, please.


lol no way this is going to be epic'd.... has to have about 6 posts to get in.... this one is WAY over the limit
 
manx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
-1 to the OP

I'll offer something along the same lines but more realistic...

Take it a step further and tie it into vision by giving each player a built-in 'auto-adjust' based on how much vision they have. That way, players with weak vision don't get an unrealistic boost to reaction time (as the OP suggests) and adjust slower than a player with higher vision would to a play that's being run repeatedly. This would apply to both offense and defense.

This way, the 'play decay' is still achieved but it's far more realistic as it'll be based on the player and not some general, unrealistic boost (or penalty) being granted to an entire unit despite the players' abilities. You'd also achieve more dynamic gameplay.


I like this. Maybe even change the current AI takeover and substitute this in. You could check it, which would allow your gameplan to adapt if the competition is doing the same thing over and over, however, checking it would leave you more vulnerable to gameplan changes from the opposition.
 
Faux Bear
offline
Link
 
I don't think that a small percent boost to some player's vision is going to have a significant effect on the outcome of plays, tbh.

For all I know, having all the vision of the world may not prevent some of the DL's and LB's from getting knocked on their asses with the Off-Tackle run, for example.

I like the idea, but I think the effect should be more than just boosting the D's vision.
Last edited Dec 4, 2008 13:53:04
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.