User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Too many deflections being caught for completions
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
And in any event this is in the wrong forum; because it's not a bug, regardless.

Yards per pass attempt are a little too high compared to real life (in most leagues, it's by less than a yard), with completion percentage actually lower than real life, although given yards per attempt that's very likely due to more long passes being thrown.

A lot of this is too few bad plays on all sides: Even on long passes, one rarely sees a QB miss his target; if it's not caught and not dropped it's almost always deflected. On longer passes, QB's should sometimes just be offline in their throws.

There also seem to be too few drops, and additionally, too many deflections and too few blown coverages.

So, basically, QB's, WR's, and CB's are all playing too well. QB's should throw some bad passes-- very few with the Throwing levels those above Level 30 tend to have when they're short passes, not so many even with medium passes; but as the pass lengthens (and/or the pressure becomes worse), so should the chance of a bad pass increase.

WR's should drop more passes as well, again more often when they're longer.

And CB's should be fooled more by fakes again, helping to balance the other two points. It seems like an attempt to please everyone, of getting overall fairly close to realistic results (in this season slightly offense skewed), but without anyone making enough mistakes.

And it is only slightly offense skewed. Yards per game is affected by more plays per game. Yards per attempt, by contrast, is just slightly too high.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
And in any event this is in the wrong forum; because it's not a bug, regardless.

Yards per pass attempt are a little too high compared to real life (in most leagues, it's by less than a yard), with completion percentage actually lower than real life, although given yards per attempt that's very likely due to more long passes being thrown.

A lot of this is too few bad plays on all sides: Even on long passes, one rarely sees a QB miss his target; if it's not caught and not dropped it's almost always deflected. On longer passes, QB's should sometimes just be offline in their throws.

There also seem to be too few drops, and additionally, too many deflections and too few blown coverages.

So, basically, QB's, WR's, and CB's are all playing too well. QB's should throw some bad passes-- very few with the Throwing levels those above Level 30 tend to have when they're short passes, not so many even with medium passes; but as the pass lengthens (and/or the pressure becomes worse), so should the chance of a bad pass increase.

WR's should drop more passes as well, again more often when they're longer.

And CB's should be fooled more by fakes again, helping to balance the other two points. It seems like an attempt to please everyone, of getting overall fairly close to realistic results (in this season slightly offense skewed), but without anyone making enough mistakes.

And it is only slightly offense skewed. Yards per game is affected by more plays per game. Yards per attempt, by contrast, is just slightly too high.


I gotta think something has either gone very right or very wrong when I am agreeing with Ken1...

+1
 
Kobra22
offline
Link
 
Y'all make some great points, no doubt. And maybe it's not a bug after all. But I do have to disagree with the point about me rather having a WR catch it instead of having my guy make a play. If the WR is open, he should probably catch the dang ball. If there is single, double or triple coverage and the ball is deflected? That probably shouldn't be caught.

I think we'd all agree that a pass deflection, in any sense of the word, causes the ball to change direction. So why not have that happen here? It doesn't need to fall to the ground right away, as it doesn't always do that in real life. But anytime something interferes with an airborne object, it causes the trajectory of said object to change. Bullets or footballs.

I wouldn't think coding a change of flight if deflection=yes would be that difficult. There might still be some catches, but there will be more incompletions, more INT's, etc. How many times have you seen a replay of a DL or LB getting their fingers on a ball and then seeing it completely change course and the ball going to the left/right of it's target?

 
TehKyou
offline
Link
 
One of the greatest plays I've seen this season was when a LB picked off a pass tipped at the line, it didn't give credit for the deflection though. I've only seen it once though
 
firehazard
offline
Link
 
Agreed. Far too many deflected balls are easily caught.
 
hoyaboy1
offline
Link
 
As others have said, the definition of a PD in GLB is more broad than in the NFL.

The one big problem, however, is when CBs cut in front of a WR, deflect the ball, and the WR a few yards behind them catches it. That should pretty much never happen, but it's actually somewhat frequent in GLB and leads to lots of long TDs.
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
It isn't realistic, true. But neither is the 233-0 last game score from one of the teams I'm on.
 
Firewings
offline
Link
 
I can understand the fact the PDs happen more frequently in GLB than the NFL. I'm fine with that. My only problem is the fact that a lot of PDs that appear to bounce around between players are caught. That needs to be lowered in my opinion. If a ball is deflected enough to change direction like that, it should only be a catch 1/10 times maybe.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.