User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
TyrannyVaunt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbfloyd
Originally posted by GMathiasf

Originally posted by rbfloyd


i would have to disagree with one player from each team.
This is not the baseball all-star game.
This is the All-Pro team, which in the NFL is just the best players.


and this isn't the NFL, this is GLB. I'd rather have players from each team to get participation from ALL teams than run an elitist team filled with all players from the top teams. I believe the forums are about trying to maximize participation rather than accuracy in pro-bowl voting. But again, that's my opinion and you're welcome to your own as well.

irt Toriq, I personally don't like to rely solely on stats like that script does, but if someone wants to set it up and to it as well, they are more than welcome.


I see both sides.
Maybe it should be called Pro-Bowl team.

and both our teams should get plenty of players!


I like the idea of a Pro-Bowl team from each conference. That gives more recognition to teams like ours who have some solid players, but may get lost in the shuffle of a single team made up of all 32 teams versus a team made up of the best from 16. And then that would increase the participation from the league too.

My .02.
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf

irt Toriq, I personally don't like to rely solely on stats like that script does, but if someone wants to set it up and to it as well, they are more than welcome.


I'd just use the script to compile lists of candidates and then have them voted on or something like that.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
ah, that's probably a good idea
 
tntitans21399
offline
Link
 
Maybe have a Pro Bowl Zeta and Pro Bowl Alpha, then you could have a ALL GLB team with the best of both.
 
tntitans21399
offline
Link
 
To bad they wouldn't let pick pro bowls and then have the conferences play each other. But at least they made this site that we are all addicted to.
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
I was actually planning on doing this as the season wound down, but would love to have someone to work with if you'd like to share the workload. I was personally thinking of doing nominations chosen by me and allowing anyone who would like to vote, to vote. I could even set up on online polls as those seem to get more participation for whatever reason. I think it's only fair to do an Alpha AND Zeta squad as comparing across Conferences is pretty much impossible because of the differences in schedule and sometimes one Conference will dominate the voting. I also like to include at least one player from every team (with possible exceptions for the CPU/gutted teams). So bigpimpin, would you like to collaborate on this?


Sure, but I had other things in mind. I was gonna get an empty roster template, send it to all the team owners to fill out themselves or as a team, and combine the total numbers. Rules would be that you can't include more than x amount of players from their own team. At least 1 from every team wouldn't be a good idea cuz this is the best in the league.

Originally posted by Toriq
To make it easier and get rid of biased/tedious voting/tallying, use this script: Pro Bowl Score: http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/35527

adds justafish2002's Pro Bowl scores to full player stats and team leaders pages

Each player gets a hard-score tabulated based on their seasons performance...

Just a suggestion, of course. If you all want to do it by hand then go for it.


I've seen that. Looks good, but it wouldn't create a roster, just a ballot since this is all about voting!
 
rbfloyd
offline
Link
 
it is yo thing..do it up.
you are putting in the time, it all sounds great.
 
bluprintkok
offline
Link
 
neway we decide i'll be down to help also
 
Link
 
sounds great, but you having voting for just the starting line-up and then have the rest of the roster picked by the team owner with the best record at the end of the season. Kinda like MLB except they use the coaches that were in the WS the year before, (it could also be done with the team owners that finished with the best records last season that didnt move up to AAA). It just seems to be a bit easier as far as counting votes. I realize bringing baseball into something football related may confuse, anger, frustrate, stupify, even amuse some folks. Thankfully, I like craziness and cross sport thinking!

You could also have voting done by GM's and owners only, then have defensive and offensive player of the year voting done by popular vote.

Just suggestions. Feel free to blast away!
Last edited Dec 1, 2008 18:09:41
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
From the standpoint of someone who has dealt with these, blank ballots are less likely to be returned. People are lazy and tbh, sorting through the 32+ options at each position can be daunting for the average user. I've never understood how offended people are by allowing a player from every team to be involved. For a strong league, it's important to have ALL teams involved, not just the elite teams. I do believe in Democracy though and would be interested in having votes on how to run this thing. I believe our goals should be maximum participation above anything else. I really don't want any part of a pro-bowl team that is just for the elite teams to pat each other on the back about how great their players are personally. So for the sake of arguing, I'll start some ideas based on what's been posted to see where we can find some agreement or set up a poll to decide.

Ballot options:
Blank
Nominees chosen by team owners/GMs for their own teams
Nominees chosen by myself and/or bigpimpin
Nominees chosen via script based solely on statistical comparison

Rules options:
Limit voting on players from own team
No Limit

Require one player from each team on every ballot
Require one player from each team on final pro-bowl team even if they receive fewer votes
Require one player from each team on final pro-bowl team even if expanding roster to fit them
No Vote Requirement. Require one player from each team to be on the nomination ballot, however.
No requirement at all.

Voting method:

vote via online poll
vote via ballot PM'd to pro-bowl team adminstrator

Voting inclusion:

Limit filled out ballots by one team in some way (i.e. only owner can turn in final ballot)
All agents allowed to vote.

Roster options:

Starters chosen by vote, backups chosen by #1 seed in the playoffs
All players chosen by vote
Last edited Dec 1, 2008 18:09:10
 
Link
 
Also, the number of players per pro bowl team and how many players per position.

Suggestion:
3 QB's
3 RB's
4 WR's
2 TE's
3 OT's
3 G's
2 C's

3 DT's
3 DE's
5 LB's
4 CB's
3 S's(it can be a combo of two SS's and one FS, or vice versa)

K
P

Kick/Punt Returner

total of 41 players
 
xp0
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by raider1480
Also, the number of players per pro bowl team and how many players per position...

...total of 41 players


I have no objections to this. There might be a few special teamers that only do special teams - i.e. a gunner - that might merit a look too.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by xp0
Originally posted by raider1480

Also, the number of players per pro bowl team and how many players per position...

...total of 41 players


I have no objections to this. There might be a few special teamers that only do special teams - i.e. a gunner - that might merit a look too.


I left the gunner out because it seems like a tough position to pick, especially since we may not know the format yet of how everyone will be picked. tough to compile the stats for the gunner as well. Any suggestion on how to pick the gunner or special teamer?

If it proves to be a bigger pain then needed, we could just not have a K/P returner or a gunner/special teamer and stick with a roster of 40 players.
Last edited Dec 1, 2008 18:50:44
 
packers0491
offline
Link
 
every team can nominate their best special teamer(non kicker, punter, and returner)
 
packers0491
offline
Link
 
then the other teams can vote from that
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.