User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AA Leagues > USA AA #4 > I have no love lost for Texas, but...
Page:
 
Freaky
offline
Link
 
And this is why we need a playoff. How about Utah, Boise State, or Ball State, all of which are ALSO UNDEFEATED. They get screwed because they come from smaller conferences. Put in an 8 team playoff.

1 Alabama vs. 8 TT
2 Florida vs. 7 Utah
3 Texas vs. 6 Penn
4 OU vs. 5 USC

Even in this situation boise state and ball state get screwed, but at least 8 teams have a chance at a national championship instead of having voters and computers decide this shit.
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
You do realize that Texas's defense is worse than Oklahoma's, right?

YPP Passing:
Oklahoma 6.58
Texas - 6.86

YPP Rushing:
Texas 2.79
Oklahoma 3.32

YPP Total:
Oklahoma - 5.06
Texas - 5.21

Also- Big 12 does use head to head. It just happened to be a THREE way tie, something Longhorn apologists conveniently forget.
Last edited Dec 1, 2008 15:15:26
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Freaky
And this is why we need a playoff. How about Utah, Boise State, or Ball State, all of which are ALSO UNDEFEATED. They get screwed because they come from smaller conferences. Put in an 8 team playoff.

1 Alabama vs. 8 TT
2 Florida vs. 7 Utah
3 Texas vs. 6 Penn
4 OU vs. 5 USC

Even in this situation boise state and ball state get screwed, but at least 8 teams have a chance at a national championship instead of having voters and computers decide this shit.


Boise and Ball State got screwed because they played NO ONE. Utah scheduled tough and got rewarded for it. Ball State will likely play the #6 Big 10 team... and be an underdog. Ball State doesn't deserve a chance.
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Freaky
And this is why we need a playoff. How about Utah, Boise State, or Ball State, all of which are ALSO UNDEFEATED. They get screwed because they come from smaller conferences. Put in an 8 team playoff.

1 Alabama vs. 8 TT
2 Florida vs. 7 Utah
3 Texas vs. 6 Penn
4 OU vs. 5 USC

Even in this situation boise state and ball state get screwed, but at least 8 teams have a chance at a national championship instead of having voters and computers decide this shit.


How did you decide on those 8? Through the voters and computers?

Major Conference Champions should get a berth. It's too hard to tell how strong conferences are. Two at large, with a provision for a minor conference champ if they are higher than a major conference champ in a BCS-like ranking system, and seed them based on BCS rankings.
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
You do realize that Texas's defense is worse than Oklahoma's, right?

Also- Big 12 does use head to head. It just happened to be a THREE way tie, something Longhorn apologists conveniently forget.


Texas' pass defense is a little suspect, but they started the year with 1 true freshman, 1 RS freshman at safety, and have improved through the season...no Texas' defense is not worse than OUs...

As for the head-2-head, everyone uses h-2-h in 2-way ties. The difference referred to is in the 5th tie-breaker, the SEC takes the higher ranking BCS team UNLESS two teams are within 5 places, then it's h-2-h for the top 2 teams in BCS ranking...NOT the highest BCS ranking team.

I'm not arguing Texas should be in the championship game, only that there is really little difference in either team, and NOT using a head-2-head at a neutral site as the determining point is as wrong as anything else....Texas did not take care of it's business. If it had, there would be no question....

Anyone arguing OU deserves to be there based on whatever is just as useless...but using the BCS ranking is totally a cop out letting computers determine a champion as much as it is a national champion....no one is saying the national champion is the BCS ranking leader after this weekend, but basically, by using the ranking for the south division champion removing Texas from the equation is the same case
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
Originally posted by Freaky

And this is why we need a playoff. How about Utah, Boise State, or Ball State, all of which are ALSO UNDEFEATED. They get screwed because they come from smaller conferences. Put in an 8 team playoff.

1 Alabama vs. 8 TT
2 Florida vs. 7 Utah
3 Texas vs. 6 Penn
4 OU vs. 5 USC

Even in this situation boise state and ball state get screwed, but at least 8 teams have a chance at a national championship instead of having voters and computers decide this shit.


How did you decide on those 8? Through the voters and computers?

Major Conference Champions should get a berth. It's too hard to tell how strong conferences are. Two at large, with a provision for a minor conference champ if they are higher than a major conference champ in a BCS-like ranking system, and seed them based on BCS rankings.


So Cincy deserves a shot but Boise does not? Conference SOS should be used to determine if a league champion is worthy, along with the league champions' ranking and SOS. NO guaranteed slots...would force teams to schedule a little more strength in weaker conferences, or face missing the playoffs.

About the bracket:
That would be one hell of a playoff bracket....can't imagine all those games not being sold out and broadcasting rights being worth a ton...

4 major bowls, winners play the following week at two sites, those winners play the following week at 3rd site.
Last edited Dec 1, 2008 16:03:49
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by im4ut999
Originally posted by tomcollins

Originally posted by Freaky


And this is why we need a playoff. How about Utah, Boise State, or Ball State, all of which are ALSO UNDEFEATED. They get screwed because they come from smaller conferences. Put in an 8 team playoff.

1 Alabama vs. 8 TT
2 Florida vs. 7 Utah
3 Texas vs. 6 Penn
4 OU vs. 5 USC

Even in this situation boise state and ball state get screwed, but at least 8 teams have a chance at a national championship instead of having voters and computers decide this shit.


How did you decide on those 8? Through the voters and computers?

Major Conference Champions should get a berth. It's too hard to tell how strong conferences are. Two at large, with a provision for a minor conference champ if they are higher than a major conference champ in a BCS-like ranking system, and seed them based on BCS rankings.


So Cincy deserves a shot but Boise does not? Conference SOS should be used to determine if a league champion is worthy, along with the league champions' ranking and SOS. NO guaranteed slots...would force teams to schedule a little more strength in weaker conferences, or face missing the playoffs.

About the bracket:
That would be one hell of a playoff bracket....can't imagine all those games not being sold out and broadcasting rights being worth a ton...

4 major bowls, winners play the following week at two sites, those winners play the following week at 3rd site.


Cincy has a much stronger SOS than Boise. Why should a team be punished because other teams in the conference schedule weak? How do you determine SOS? Polls? Absolutely ridiculous to punish a team because another team who happens to be in their conference plays tons of cupcakes.

Boise has a #115 SOS now, and Cincy has #62. If a Conference continues to suck, there should be provisions to award their entry to someone else. Right now, the Big 6 have been pretty solidly ahead, although the MWC is closing the gap (and the only conference that is even close).

If rankings are all that determine the ending teams, if you think its bad now, just wait. There just aren't enough data points to *really* know. How many times have you been certain a team would crush another in a Bowl Game, and then have that team get slaughtered. I can think of quite a few. With conference schedules, most of the time, we have a great deal of evidence about who the best team in each conference is. Sometimes its close, and At-Large Bids and scheduling tough OOC games can help out for other teams. You would ruin the regular season and make it as meaningful as GLB regular season is right now.
 
Freaky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
Originally posted by Freaky

And this is why we need a playoff. How about Utah, Boise State, or Ball State, all of which are ALSO UNDEFEATED. They get screwed because they come from smaller conferences. Put in an 8 team playoff.

1 Alabama vs. 8 TT
2 Florida vs. 7 Utah
3 Texas vs. 6 Penn
4 OU vs. 5 USC

Even in this situation boise state and ball state get screwed, but at least 8 teams have a chance at a national championship instead of having voters and computers decide this shit.


How did you decide on those 8? Through the voters and computers?

Major Conference Champions should get a berth. It's too hard to tell how strong conferences are. Two at large, with a provision for a minor conference champ if they are higher than a major conference champ in a BCS-like ranking system, and seed them based on BCS rankings.


I kinda came up with this myself, but I beleive it resembles the AP vote from this past weekend, although maybe they have Utah and TT switched.

But as im4ut said, these games would be hella fun to watch and would be worth a ton. I mean, you'd probably have good close games in the 1st round, maybe an upset or 2 and then you'd have a sold sold semi-finals with an awesome championship game. If they did a playoff like this, ratings would go through the roof and no school could complain.

I do agree with Tom that conference champions should get a spot as long as they indeed have had a tougher schedule. Then have 2 at large bids and be done with it. These playoff games can still be "sponsered" bowl games, but just in a playoff format.

 
bgm1969
offline
Link
 
I think it would be best to do away with conference playoffs altogether.

16 teams - 2 each from the ACC, SEC, Big 10, Big 12, Pac 10
1 team each from Conference USA, WAC, Big East, Mountain West and Mid America
1 At-Large bid
No conference playoffs, seedings based on record
First Round -Second weekend in December
Second Round -Third Weekend in December
Semifinals - Last Weekend of December
Championship Game - Weekend after the week January 1st falls (in 2009 that would be January 10th, in 2008 it would have been January 12th)

This year that could be something like this:

1 Alabama vs. 16 Oregon
8 Florida vs. 9 Penn State
3 Ball State vs. 14 Boston College
6 Texas vs. 11 Ohio State
4 Boise State vs. 13 Tulsa
5 Oklahoma vs. 12 Cincinnati
7 Texas Tech vs. 10 USC
2 Utah vs. 15 Georgia Tech

There are some fantastic potential matchups in that group.

A second tier of 16 teams could get bowl bids to be played between Christmas and January 1st
Last edited Dec 2, 2008 10:12:21
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Let's just have a 128 team playoff and let everyone in! That will make the most exciting regular season in all sports be even more fun!
 
bgm1969
offline
Link
 
Honestly, at this point, anything to get rid of the polls and BCS is fine with me.
 
Freaky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bgm1969
I think it would be best to do away with conference playoffs altogether.

16 teams - 2 each from the ACC, SEC, Big 10, Big 12, Pac 10
1 team each from Conference USA, WAC, Big East, Mountain West and Mid America
1 At-Large bid
No conference playoffs, seedings based on record
First Round -Second weekend in December
Second Round -Third Weekend in December
Semifinals - Last Weekend of December
Championship Game - Weekend after the week January 1st falls (in 2009 that would be January 10th, in 2008 it would have been January 12th)

This year that could be something like this:

1 Alabama vs. 16 Oregon
8 Florida vs. 9 Penn State
3 Ball State vs. 14 Boston College
6 Texas vs. 11 Ohio State
4 Boise State vs. 13 Tulsa
5 Oklahoma vs. 12 Cincinnati
7 Texas Tech vs. 10 USC
2 Utah vs. 15 Georgia Tech

There are some fantastic potential matchups in that group.

A second tier of 16 teams could get bowl bids to be played between Christmas and January 1st



I am all for this, but I think people would be too hesitant to have 16 teams, thus I went with 8.

But, I'm 100% for what you have here!!! BCS SUCKS, just like Obama. hahaha!
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Why in the world should Oregon, Tulsa, Ohio State, Texas Tech, and Georgia Tech get a second chance to be national champions? They already had their shot and blew it (most multiple times). NCAA Football already has the greatest regular season in all sports, and crowns a better champion than any other sport out there (St. Louis Cardinals in the MLB say hi). While the playoffs would be interesting, it would totally kill the regular season. Does anyone honestly care about the NBA regular season? Do UNC fans really care about their basketball season (besides playing Duke)?

While I do think more can be done to help settle it on the field, giving every team a second chance who already blew it in the playoffs takes all meaning out of the regular season. Look at GLB regular seasons. Its all LOL. No one cares that much until we get to the playoffs. If we only let in 4 teams into the playoffs, regular season games would mean so much more. Why should a team who finishes 8th out of 16 teams have a chance? They already had one and didn't come close. Playoffs should reward excellence, not mediocrity.

 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bgm1969
Honestly, at this point, anything to get rid of the polls and BCS is fine with me.


That's the problem. There are plenty of systems out there that are WORSE than the BCS. The BCS is a lot better than what we used to have. It's better than ridiculous playoffs where any team with 9 wins gets in. No other sport has "better" champions than NCAAF. There are almost never any "underserving champions". No '06 St. Louis Cardinals, '07 New York Giants, or the '95 Houston Rockets- teams that sleptwalk through the regular season, then ran hot for a few games and get declared champion. That cannot happen in the BCS. It is rare to happen in an 8 team playoff decided by conference champions. With a 16 team playoff, it totally opens the door for those kinds of situations, and takes all meaning from regular season game. Teams like Ohio State, USC, and Texas would be virtual locks to make the playoffs every year. Lose a game and the conference? No big deal, you are in anyway! Just win in December/January and we'll forgive you for your 3 conference losses.
 
bgm1969
offline
Link
 
A large scale playoff system worked splendidly for IAA, II and III for years. You will have dynasties and teams that make it nearly every year (historically, Georgia Southern and Texas A&I in IAA, North Dakota State in II, Mount Union and St. John's in III) It was, however, never a foregone conclusion, and thrilling upsets always happened.

Will the best two teams always appear in the Championship Game? No. And it's easily arguable that's not happening under the BCS either.

As for rendering the regular season moot: a team needs to succeed in order to make the playoffs in the first place. Yes, that means that two teams with nine wins would make it some seasons. Welcome to the possibility of upset specials.

Many arguments against a playoff hinge on a playoffs somehow making the regular season an afterthought. That seems a very weak argument to me that has been refuted in practice by three other NCAA Football Divisions.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.