User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Linked attributes, new attributes - follow up to Flames54 suggestion on reworking attributes
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by Ken1


No. It involves a wipe, and that needs to be off the table.


Why no wipe?


I went into it in the one other thread.

All the time that I and others have put into this game, with the expectation of building a team that could last forever, building players that would last 10 seasons, etc. has then been thrown away.

Bort could give me back my FP's, but he could never give me back the time I spent that wasn't fun in and of itself, but rather only fun as part of building something that would never be intentionally destroyed.

I'll quote myself from the other thread:

Originally posted by Ken1

So, someone creates a player in Season 5, figuring, "I know he won't be much now, but around Season 12, when the top players have retired and he's reaching his peak, I'll really be glad I had him, and in Seasons 13-15, when he'll be in the best cohort he'll be tons of fun."

Then it's wiped after Season 10. He never got to have more than a scrub.

He has more than a right to whine if that happened, and I usually don't like whiners.

I do agree with you when you say no first draft or even second draft is perfect. Neither is the third or the fourth. But once this became an open, commercial Beta, the one big thing we had a right to expect is that there would be no wipe.

"But you get the FP's back!" So? I know that unless it were written in the TOS that there would never, ever be another wipe under any circumstances, and that if that were broken I'd get cash back for my FP's, I won't waste time creating new players that the creator has shown he'll destroy on a whim.

And my team, "Oh, you get that back, too!" (Though not really, as the players have been wiped.) But the team's founder doesn't get the time back that he spent recruiting a whole Pro-level team from scratch, nor mine for helping him, nor my great effort when I had a power outage the day we got the team to borrow a laptop with WiFi and head to a hotspot to help fill in the team.

Am I alone in having a story like this? Hell no. A wipe isn't fair to anyone with a similar story, and lots of people have them.

And no, we couldn't do it as well again. The guy who founded it passed it to me precisely because, while still quite involved, he didn't have as much time any more, especially not consistently.
 
dkmfan
offline
Link
 
Some of it does, some of it doesn't.

Splitting, strength and vision doesn't require a wipe (fill both using a position based bias). The current SA system could be removed (SPs credited) with the new system starting at 0. Equipment would be harder to handle, but it is still doable.

Edit: the bias fill would be a % off the players current strenth/vision.
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 17:22:35
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
I think bort dismissed a lot of ideas too quickly as soon as he read "wipe" - and there were perfectly reasonable suggestions on how to re-do attributes without wiping current teams/players.


Yes, some degree of attribute reformulation without a wipe is possible. I'll quote myself again from the other thread as to how I might add acceleration and faster leveling:

Originally posted by Ken1

Two solutions for acceleration (if it's even needed, although I accept the game would be better with such a stat):

1) Players created before Season 7 accelerate as they do now. Those created after use the Acceleration stat, and get enough extra SP's to make them balanced.

2) The Acceleration stat is added, and every player starts with, say, 20 + Level points in it (whatever's balanced). He then can move up to 15 points into Acceleration from other attributes, or up to 15 points out of Acceleration to other attributes (one or the other, as he can't use it to respec other attributes).

Solution for too-slow leveling:

The minimum amount per nightly training is currently 25. Make it 50, and you add one level-up per season. All players' exp is recorded. That's why we can see XP history. Any nightly XP below 50 we gain the difference between it and 50. And then, of course, all future players get at least 50 per night.

If game exp is also raised at high levels, then maybe current players miss out on anything retroactive there, but get it from here on out. That may make it easier for lower players to catch up them, but that's much easier to accept than them being wiped.
 
tordman
offline
Link
 
No wipe, please. We've worked long and hard on our players and in recruiting players.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Bort Inc could woek out new attribute structure, do the programming and all new players/teams go under the new structure. Existing players/teams keep going as is until retirement leads to phaseout of 1.0
 
zachary91119
offline
Link
 
good though will never happen what will the level 40+ do they started this game kinda of but they would be screwed
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
Bort Inc could woek out new attribute structure, do the programming and all new players/teams go under the new structure. Existing players/teams keep going as is until retirement leads to phaseout of 1.0


Nope, that doesn't work, as teams are not meant to be temporary and it would also give the existing players and teams a second class status.

Also, there is no time that all players playing will have peaked, as new ones are made each season.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Ken; I don't quite accept that a 1.0 wind-down isn't possible after a 2.0 introduction, but obviously you've thought about that and while instictively I think it could be done, I know you *could* be right.

So I'll set that aside.

There does seem to be widespread feeling that so much more is understood now both about how the basic sim works and how the human users behave - both add up
to interest in revamping attributes, builds,SA, etc - basically the point of Flames' heroic post - so...

How do we get to 2.0?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
Ken; I don't quite accept that a 1.0 wind-down isn't possible after a 2.0 introduction, but obviously you've thought about that and while instictively I think it could be done, I know you *could* be right.

So I'll set that aside.

There does seem to be widespread feeling that so much more is understood now both about how the basic sim works and how the human users behave - both add up
to interest in revamping attributes, builds,SA, etc - basically the point of Flames' heroic post - so...

How do we get to 2.0?


You saw my ideas about how one might add Acceleration and the speed up the ultra-slow exp. Veteran Abilities will also provide more variety in build types. So will player personalities, in a system that would start from Drifter's lockerroom attributes concept, expanding upon it.

Then, there are SA's: New ones can be added, some could be offered to positions that don't get them now, and they could be freed, or partially freed, from trees.

A long time ago GG and I proposed that the number of SA's available per player be at least doubled and that they could be bought without building up trees. Possibly, some SA's could lock you out of others, or in occasional cases where there really is a correlation, some SA's could be prerequisites for others.

Finally, it would be huge if Bort made balance changes without regard to what people would whine about. That in itself would allow him to balance GLB (e.g. the Speed bias) to make sure there is no "one best build" for a position.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.