User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Bort, Save the game. Fix the Sim!!
Page:
 
ribairral
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Originally posted by ribairral

Originally posted by fightomega


most of these aren't important at all


You're kidding, right??

100% agree with that.


You agree with the OP or that they are not important. Kind of confused by the post.


The second one is my opinion
 
Link
 
Heh, my brain ain't right today. To much leftover turkey.
 
drewd21
offline
Link
 
Is there any point to having CB's on your team, nowadays? Seems to me they may aswell not be on the field, as nearly every pass, no matter how good the coverage is, gets completed Double coverage, triple coverage....no matter the WR will nearly always come up with the catch.
Does not matter how solid your pass defense is or how good your CB's are....you will get toasted through the air

Very depressing!
 
notthegint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aeakers
Unfazed QB - In my last game we got 15 hurries and 4 sacks and my opponent's QB still completed 70% of his passes and threw no INTs. We also deflected 17 passes, which would not necessarily faze a QB but should hurt a QB's completion %.

Deflections - A low percentage of deflections are caught at any level of football...except GLB. There were 7 deflected completions in my last game, one for a TD. This is crazy.

Timeouts - The logic is severely flawed here. Teams that are losing call timeouts on defense. Noone calls a timeout right before they punt. Set up a system (as has been suggested) to allow teams to define for themselves when to call a timeout.

Kickoffs - This is so obvious I cannot believe it still has not been fixed. Returners do not run straight ahead right into a defender.


Whole heartedly agree with these.

Originally posted by aeakers

Pass coverage - Well built corners should sometimes completely shut down WRs. I don't know what the issue is but something is not right here. My secondary is not stopping the pass, and I cannot tell why because the output is non-explanatory. Not giving out builds but I have 4 solid CBs level 38/39 who gave up 561 passing yards to lower level WRs.


It's always going to be difficult to shut down a WR, cause the WR knows where he's going and you don't. I would like to see zone D become viable.

 
fightomega
offline
Link
 
actually i agree only with timeouts and QB fazing, QB fazing is most important right here
 
Link
 
Originally posted by aeakers

Unfazed QB - In my last game we got 15 hurries and 4 sacks and my opponent's QB still completed 70% of his passes and threw no INTs.


+1 Because this game has confidence as a factor this should mater more.

Originally posted by aeakers
Deflections - A low percentage of deflections are caught at any level of football...except GLB. There were 7 deflected completions in my last game, one for a TD. This is crazy.


+1 This is pretty ridiculous

Originally posted by aeakers
Timeouts - The logic is severely flawed here. Teams that are losing call timeouts on defense. Noone calls a timeout right before they punt. Set up a system (as has been suggested) to allow teams to define for themselves when to call a timeout.


+1

Originally posted by aeakers
Kickoffs - This is so obvious I cannot believe it still has not been fixed. Returners do not run straight ahead right into a defender.


+1 I can't believe it has taken this long to fix this.

Originally posted by aeakers
added
Pass coverage - Well built corners should sometimes completely shut down WRs. I don't know what the issue is but something is not right here. My secondary is not stopping the pass, and I cannot tell why because the output is non-explanatory. Not giving out builds but I have 4 solid CBs level 38/39 who gave up 561 passing yards to lower level WRs.




+1 Bort's new change to medium coverage was probably to big of a change. It greatly affected my defense's performance.


 
seanb1979
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by John Waylon
Yeah, the sim has a few quirky issues... Take for instance this play where a DE ends up with an INT and really isnt even close to the play at all. It almost looks like the WR catches it and laterals it to him...


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=252849&pbp_id=6663978

my de had an interesting interception today caught it while standing right in front of the qb
 
Link
 
Originally posted by seanb1979
Originally posted by John Waylon

Yeah, the sim has a few quirky issues... Take for instance this play where a DE ends up with an INT and really isnt even close to the play at all. It almost looks like the WR catches it and laterals it to him...


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=252849&pbp_id=6663978

my de had an interesting interception today caught it while standing right in front of the qb


Looked more like a handoff


So, no one else see's these as important issues?
 
buccityboy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by notthegint
Originally posted by aeakers

Unfazed QB - In my last game we got 15 hurries and 4 sacks and my opponent's QB still completed 70% of his passes and threw no INTs. We also deflected 17 passes, which would not necessarily faze a QB but should hurt a QB's completion %.

Deflections - A low percentage of deflections are caught at any level of football...except GLB. There were 7 deflected completions in my last game, one for a TD. This is crazy.

Timeouts - The logic is severely flawed here. Teams that are losing call timeouts on defense. Noone calls a timeout right before they punt. Set up a system (as has been suggested) to allow teams to define for themselves when to call a timeout.

Kickoffs - This is so obvious I cannot believe it still has not been fixed. Returners do not run straight ahead right into a defender.


Whole heartedly agree with these.

Originally posted by aeakers


Pass coverage - Well built corners should sometimes completely shut down WRs. I don't know what the issue is but something is not right here. My secondary is not stopping the pass, and I cannot tell why because the output is non-explanatory. Not giving out builds but I have 4 solid CBs level 38/39 who gave up 561 passing yards to lower level WRs.


It's always going to be difficult to shut down a WR, cause the WR knows where he's going and you don't. I would like to see zone D become viable.



this is also my concern
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
because he's not trying to fix the sim

/thread
 
Link
 
Which is why this is a suggestion.

These are things that need to be looked at and worked on. I could care less about fame and vet skills right now. Just check that game I posted, 8sacks and 5 hurries should of lead to a lot more missed passes and a pick or so.
 
Yard Dog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drewd21
Is there any point to having CB's on your team, nowadays? Seems to me they may aswell not be on the field, as nearly every pass, no matter how good the coverage is, gets completed Double coverage, triple coverage....no matter the WR will nearly always come up with the catch.
Does not matter how solid your pass defense is or how good your CB's are....you will get toasted through the air

Very depressing!


exactly, I have been struggling to find an answer this season. My CB's are the closest thing to the ball and the WR's 5 yards away are still making the grabs.
 
Link
 
I agree with the OP, if this game wants to make serious strides it will continue to advance and further develop the sim. this is high priority, not fame or vet skills as most guys will still slow build players anyway. fixing the issues in the sim, will make for a better overall product, and if the graphics guy could redo the sim as well so it can more accurately reflect what is going on, that would be nice as well
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aeakers
There are a huge number of sim bugs that are beyond infuriating. I see a lot of suggestions but all pale in comparison in priority to fixing the sim.

I'm sure there are more than these but I have noticed the following issues in my games.

Unfazed QB - In my last game we got 15 hurries and 4 sacks and my opponent's QB still completed 70% of his passes and threw no INTs. We also deflected 17 passes, which would not necessarily faze a QB but should hurt a QB's completion %.

Deflections - A low percentage of deflections are caught at any level of football...except GLB. There were 7 deflected completions in my last game, one for a TD. This is crazy.

Timeouts - The logic is severely flawed here. Teams that are losing call timeouts on defense. Noone calls a timeout right before they punt. Set up a system (as has been suggested) to allow teams to define for themselves when to call a timeout.

Kickoffs - This is so obvious I cannot believe it still has not been fixed. Returners do not run straight ahead right into a defender.

added
Pass coverage - Well built corners should sometimes completely shut down WRs. I don't know what the issue is but something is not right here. My secondary is not stopping the pass, and I cannot tell why because the output is non-explanatory. Not giving out builds but I have 4 solid CBs level 38/39 who gave up 561 passing yards to lower level WRs.



I agree with each of these. And would add some things.

Like...

- the way O-linemen line-up in a straight line. Th OGs and OTs should be a step back already. In some formations, the OTs should be another half setp back of the OGs.

I think that this is the reason that the 'fixes' for Sacks seem so mildly effective. Sack totals are down. But I think that the league realignment can be credited for a big portion of that.

- The STRENGTH effects of linemen. The SPEED/AGILITY DE builds aren't a liability in the running game. They are actually the best run defenders on the field.

- Blocking is far too easy. I have shown the play many times. < http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=270451&pbp_id=4256029 > While the play is obviously a QB bug (Been addressed) the blocking is completely ridiculous.

I don't think that there is a quick-fix to this problem.

I think that players need to have a face, to know rather they are being blocked from behind, or not.

the most effective block, short of a pancake, should only last a few seconds.

Defenders should be able to dictate which direction the block moves. (And they should move faster than hey currently are.) The better a DT is against the blocker he faces, the quicker he should be able to "move the block".

There are more, but I am busy right now. I think that the blocking situation is a very big project, as it needs many changes made to it.

I have done a couple of studies on Hurries - completion % before. There was no change in a QBs efficiency on plays that there was a Hurry, than plays where there was no Hurry. Sometimes a bit better, sometimes a bit worse.

A DB making contact with a pass should be making the pass extremely unlikely to be caught. And that just doesn't seem to be the case.

There are alot of problems that go unnoticed. People post things in the 'Bugs' and 'Suggestions' forums, but they get shoved back pages, unless there is alot of opposition. So those that are heavily agreed upon get lost quickly, because noone has anything to say.

The threads that get all of the attention are the ones that everybody doesn't agree with. Because then you get alot of back and fourth, keeping the thread near the top of the list, and mounting a high number of replies.
 
aeakers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by aeakers

There are a huge number of sim bugs that are beyond infuriating. I see a lot of suggestions but all pale in comparison in priority to fixing the sim.

I'm sure there are more than these but I have noticed the following issues in my games.

Unfazed QB - In my last game we got 15 hurries and 4 sacks and my opponent's QB still completed 70% of his passes and threw no INTs. We also deflected 17 passes, which would not necessarily faze a QB but should hurt a QB's completion %.

Deflections - A low percentage of deflections are caught at any level of football...except GLB. There were 7 deflected completions in my last game, one for a TD. This is crazy.

Timeouts - The logic is severely flawed here. Teams that are losing call timeouts on defense. Noone calls a timeout right before they punt. Set up a system (as has been suggested) to allow teams to define for themselves when to call a timeout.

Kickoffs - This is so obvious I cannot believe it still has not been fixed. Returners do not run straight ahead right into a defender.

added
Pass coverage - Well built corners should sometimes completely shut down WRs. I don't know what the issue is but something is not right here. My secondary is not stopping the pass, and I cannot tell why because the output is non-explanatory. Not giving out builds but I have 4 solid CBs level 38/39 who gave up 561 passing yards to lower level WRs.



I agree with each of these. And would add some things.

Like...

- the way O-linemen line-up in a straight line. Th OGs and OTs should be a step back already. In some formations, the OTs should be another half setp back of the OGs.

I think that this is the reason that the 'fixes' for Sacks seem so mildly effective. Sack totals are down. But I think that the league realignment can be credited for a big portion of that.

- The STRENGTH effects of linemen. The SPEED/AGILITY DE builds aren't a liability in the running game. They are actually the best run defenders on the field.

- Blocking is far too easy. I have shown the play many times. < http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=270451&pbp_id=4256029 > While the play is obviously a QB bug (Been addressed) the blocking is completely ridiculous.

I don't think that there is a quick-fix to this problem.

I think that players need to have a face, to know rather they are being blocked from behind, or not.

the most effective block, short of a pancake, should only last a few seconds.

Defenders should be able to dictate which direction the block moves. (And they should move faster than hey currently are.) The better a DT is against the blocker he faces, the quicker he should be able to "move the block".

There are more, but I am busy right now. I think that the blocking situation is a very big project, as it needs many changes made to it.

I have done a couple of studies on Hurries - completion % before. There was no change in a QBs efficiency on plays that there was a Hurry, than plays where there was no Hurry. Sometimes a bit better, sometimes a bit worse.

A DB making contact with a pass should be making the pass extremely unlikely to be caught. And that just doesn't seem to be the case.

There are alot of problems that go unnoticed. People post things in the 'Bugs' and 'Suggestions' forums, but they get shoved back pages, unless there is alot of opposition. So those that are heavily agreed upon get lost quickly, because noone has anything to say.

The threads that get all of the attention are the ones that everybody doesn't agree with. Because then you get alot of back and fourth, keeping the thread near the top of the list, and mounting a high number of replies.


I agree with you on everything, and I'd add defensive pursuit/pathing but I was hoping this was something that could be fixed easy.The blocking system needs overhauled and defensive pathing is not far behind in terms of needing scrapped.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.