User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Have "Superstars" and "All-Pros"
Page:
 
Pete Carroll
offline
Link
 
+1. Will take some refining and stuff, but good base idea and something i would like to see.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Epic-worthy idea. With more thought put into parameters to avoid exploitation, and tying up any potential general problems, this would be a great addition imo.
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by John Waylon
Actually, the Superstar idea shoots itself in the foot...

Think about it... You create a SS QB. It's going to take 2700 FP to boost, which basic math tells us is about 27 dollars, and that is simply too much for one player in one season. That means the boosting of other players is going to fall by the wayside, because you naturally want to boost your stat maker, and not the FS who gets 3 tackles a game.

But with his SP and training advantage, you can still keep him unboosted, and be on par with other players in your league due to the bonuses.

It could actually lead to the game making LESS money, because like I said, if there is no penalty at all for me not boosting my SS QB at the end of the season, then I am NOT going to be buying 2700 FP to do it, and I am also going to be buying 900 LESS to boost my other players.


I disagree based on one point.

The new player is simply not going to be able to afford to make a superstar quarterback, so he won't do it.

The vet will know just how hard it is to get a job as a quarterback and balk at the idea unless he knows where he's going to play or is very confident in it.

Quarterback is really the only position I can see difficulty with this idea though but I don't see it any different than now, everybody wants to be a QB now but not many can be.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Could not existing players be converted to Superstars at the extra cost? That way you would have a lot of existing players at all sorts of levels and already starting on teams to be able to make the jump straight to Superstars.
 
John Waylon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by christianhall
The thing I can see now (and I find it pretty funny) would be if there were so many of these players (I think a lot of people will bite the bullet and pay the extra) that there aren't enough spaces on teams for them all, and we get an influx of "I can't get my Superstar signed!!!!!!" threads


If guys buy FP to boost SS players, then chances are they won't be buying for FP to boost the rest of their players.

What you say is right... 110% correct.

Say it cost 35 dollars to boost your players per season. You create a SS glamor player that it costs 2700 alone to boost a season. You just damn near doubled your old expenditure. Come seasons end, boosting your SS player WILL take precedence over your other players because he is the more important player to his team. Now chances are, and especially in today's tight economic times, your going to say fuckall to your other players for the season and boost your SS, and use whats left to boost the others, because your not going to shell out 35 bucks like the days of old for the rest of the group.

Then your other players start to fall behind the starters who they should be par with, and you eventually decide to retire them to help boost your SS, and because they are unboosted backup players.

Now the player market will really be in the shitter.

What this would lead to is everyone having only one or two players, simply out of inability to afford to keep anything else and make it competitive. You spend 27 bucks to boost one player every season, you are only going to want one, MAYBE two more to look after past that.

It will never work.

Good idea in theory, but the cause and effect are too much to handle.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Why not then reduce the cost of creating a Superstar so it's not equivalent to $27. Something reasonable like double the cost of creating a current player.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
APF 2k8 is a hell of a game.
 
John Waylon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
Originally posted by John Waylon

Actually, the Superstar idea shoots itself in the foot...

Think about it... You create a SS QB. It's going to take 2700 FP to boost, which basic math tells us is about 27 dollars, and that is simply too much for one player in one season. That means the boosting of other players is going to fall by the wayside, because you naturally want to boost your stat maker, and not the FS who gets 3 tackles a game.

But with his SP and training advantage, you can still keep him unboosted, and be on par with other players in your league due to the bonuses.

It could actually lead to the game making LESS money, because like I said, if there is no penalty at all for me not boosting my SS QB at the end of the season, then I am NOT going to be buying 2700 FP to do it, and I am also going to be buying 900 LESS to boost my other players.


I disagree based on one point.

The new player is simply not going to be able to afford to make a superstar quarterback, so he won't do it.

The vet will know just how hard it is to get a job as a quarterback and balk at the idea unless he knows where he's going to play or is very confident in it.

Quarterback is really the only position I can see difficulty with this idea though but I don't see it any different than now, everybody wants to be a QB now but not many can be.


You don't understood what I meant... You CAN afford to create a SS player. But you CAN'T afford much more than that. That's going to create a depression in the players market, especially once some of the vets out there already start retiring in a few seasons time and the agents decide to make a SS with the now free FP they have per season. Your going to have less players coming in than you have players retiring, and Bort is going to keep releasing leagues and teams until we have a massive player market depression as it is now... Why speed that up?


It's not just the QB position that will make this a problem... Naturally teams are going to want SS players who are PLAYMAKERS and can put points on the board. You'll see some DE's (Which would REALLY make everyone start crying, pissing, and moaning "NERF!") but SS players who aren't players capable of making an offense score will be few and far between, which is then going to ruin the defensive side of the game...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
APF 2k8 is a hell of a game.


+1
 
John Waylon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Why not then reduce the cost of creating a Superstar so it's not equivalent to $27. Something reasonable like double the cost of creating a current player.


It would make it a little less of a burden, but it would still lead to an overall decrease in regular players.

The original idea was like trying to fix an amputated leg with a band-aid. Your losing WAY more than your saving.

Cutting it down to double is still like trying to fix a gunshot wound with a band-aid.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
ehhh I think we'd end up w/ too many people building superstars/all pros, no matter what the cost. Also, the limit on the superstars is only going to spur multi-accounting.


this
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
love the idea (though i agree multi accounting would need to be stopped somehow)

not sure about SS being 3x flex - but that could possibly be reduced to 2x?



unfortunately; i'm feeling jaded and beginning to feel like the major changes this game needs will never be implemented
 
cain141
offline
Link
 
This is freaking retarted...
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cain141
This is freaking retarted...


says the guy who doesn't have a player higher than level 26...




we desperately need a way to make players more differentiated in the 30+ levels; this would be one idea that could work...

 
ProfessionalKop
Gangstalicious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
I'd like to see the limit on AllPros set at around 5 per agent and maybe 10 per team.

However I like this idea.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.