I'll give you a real world example. If you were 10-0 and had played the Detriot Lions every week, no one would care or think you were good. If you were 5-5 but had 5 losses to the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints, people would say "Well they are 5-5 but they are probably better then that team that only beats the Lions.
Androth
offline
offline
Originally posted by rogers2000
whats the negative strength of play mean?? This still confuses me.....
-25 for my squad?
Quality of play has to do with 2 things.
First is beating people who have a worse record then you do. Losing to a team "worse" then you is the biggest contributor to negative Quality.
Second is the amount of points scored, vs your opponents record. For instance losing to a 10-0 team by 1 point would get you positive points, while beating a 0-10 team by 1 point would get you negative points.
whats the negative strength of play mean?? This still confuses me.....
-25 for my squad?
Quality of play has to do with 2 things.
First is beating people who have a worse record then you do. Losing to a team "worse" then you is the biggest contributor to negative Quality.
Second is the amount of points scored, vs your opponents record. For instance losing to a 10-0 team by 1 point would get you positive points, while beating a 0-10 team by 1 point would get you negative points.
Doomsday
offline
offline
I use somewhat of a similar point system with my rankings but I award points for record as well as strength of schedule and quality of win. Not including pre-season. I don't go into alot of detail though, like by yards and all that. I just go by the final scores.
RunningMn9
offline
offline
Originally posted by Androth
I'll give you a real world example. If you were 10-0 and had played the Detriot Lions every week, no one would care or think you were good. If you were 5-5 but had 5 losses to the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints, people would say "Well they are 5-5 but they are probably better then that team that only beats the Lions.
You aren't seriously going to try to explain the concept of strength of schedule to me, are you?
If I was 5-5 and had losses to the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints - I would have an awfully hard time using any system that concluded that I was a stronger team than the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints. Better than some? Certainly that's possible. But better than all? That's a bad ranking system.
I don't say this to criticize you personally. I think it's great that people have ranking systems. But I would think that you would be interested in creating a better ranking system. Your ranking system appears to favor stats more than they should (since games are won by scoring points, not throwing for 260 yards in the 4th Quarter of a game you were losing by 2 TDs).
The Hammer might be a better team than the PAIN. Or the Warpath. Or the Roughnecks. But if they were a better team than all three of us, they would probably have beaten at least one of us, no?
I'll give you a real world example. If you were 10-0 and had played the Detriot Lions every week, no one would care or think you were good. If you were 5-5 but had 5 losses to the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints, people would say "Well they are 5-5 but they are probably better then that team that only beats the Lions.
You aren't seriously going to try to explain the concept of strength of schedule to me, are you?
If I was 5-5 and had losses to the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints - I would have an awfully hard time using any system that concluded that I was a stronger team than the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints. Better than some? Certainly that's possible. But better than all? That's a bad ranking system.
I don't say this to criticize you personally. I think it's great that people have ranking systems. But I would think that you would be interested in creating a better ranking system. Your ranking system appears to favor stats more than they should (since games are won by scoring points, not throwing for 260 yards in the 4th Quarter of a game you were losing by 2 TDs).
The Hammer might be a better team than the PAIN. Or the Warpath. Or the Roughnecks. But if they were a better team than all three of us, they would probably have beaten at least one of us, no?
Androth
offline
offline
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by Androth
I'll give you a real world example. If you were 10-0 and had played the Detriot Lions every week, no one would care or think you were good. If you were 5-5 but had 5 losses to the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints, people would say "Well they are 5-5 but they are probably better then that team that only beats the Lions.
You aren't seriously going to try to explain the concept of strength of schedule to me, are you?
If I was 5-5 and had losses to the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints - I would have an awfully hard time using any system that concluded that I was a stronger team than the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints. Better than some? Certainly that's possible. But better than all? That's a bad ranking system.
I don't say this to criticize you personally. I think it's great that people have ranking systems. But I would think that you would be interested in creating a better ranking system. Your ranking system appears to favor stats more than they should (since games are won by scoring points, not throwing for 260 yards in the 4th Quarter of a game you were losing by 2 TDs).
The Hammer might be a better team than the PAIN. Or the Warpath. Or the Roughnecks. But if they were a better team than all three of us, they would probably have beaten at least one of us, no?
Apparently you need it explained to you cause what you said isn't even close to what I explained or how my ranking system, or probably any other ranking system, works.
Originally posted by Androth
I'll give you a real world example. If you were 10-0 and had played the Detriot Lions every week, no one would care or think you were good. If you were 5-5 but had 5 losses to the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints, people would say "Well they are 5-5 but they are probably better then that team that only beats the Lions.
You aren't seriously going to try to explain the concept of strength of schedule to me, are you?
If I was 5-5 and had losses to the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints - I would have an awfully hard time using any system that concluded that I was a stronger team than the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints. Better than some? Certainly that's possible. But better than all? That's a bad ranking system.
I don't say this to criticize you personally. I think it's great that people have ranking systems. But I would think that you would be interested in creating a better ranking system. Your ranking system appears to favor stats more than they should (since games are won by scoring points, not throwing for 260 yards in the 4th Quarter of a game you were losing by 2 TDs).
The Hammer might be a better team than the PAIN. Or the Warpath. Or the Roughnecks. But if they were a better team than all three of us, they would probably have beaten at least one of us, no?
Apparently you need it explained to you cause what you said isn't even close to what I explained or how my ranking system, or probably any other ranking system, works.
shaun123987
offline
offline
These rankings pretty much show you how well a team is playing despite the record and can predict some upsets.
shaun123987
offline
offline
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by Androth
I'll give you a real world example. If you were 10-0 and had played the Detriot Lions every week, no one would care or think you were good. If you were 5-5 but had 5 losses to the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints, people would say "Well they are 5-5 but they are probably better then that team that only beats the Lions.
You aren't seriously going to try to explain the concept of strength of schedule to me, are you?
If I was 5-5 and had losses to the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints - I would have an awfully hard time using any system that concluded that I was a stronger team than the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints. Better than some? Certainly that's possible. But better than all? That's a bad ranking system.
I don't say this to criticize you personally. I think it's great that people have ranking systems. But I would think that you would be interested in creating a better ranking system. Your ranking system appears to favor stats more than they should (since games are won by scoring points, not throwing for 260 yards in the 4th Quarter of a game you were losing by 2 TDs).
The Hammer might be a better team than the PAIN. Or the Warpath. Or the Roughnecks. But if they were a better team than all three of us, they would probably have beaten at least one of us, no?
That's not how it works.
Team 1 - 10-0
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Team 2 - 5-5
Steelers W
Titans W
Giants L
Patriots L
Bucs W
Dallas Cowboys W
Carolina Panthers L
Colts L
Jets L
Falcons W
Which team is better, team one or two?
Originally posted by Androth
I'll give you a real world example. If you were 10-0 and had played the Detriot Lions every week, no one would care or think you were good. If you were 5-5 but had 5 losses to the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints, people would say "Well they are 5-5 but they are probably better then that team that only beats the Lions.
You aren't seriously going to try to explain the concept of strength of schedule to me, are you?
If I was 5-5 and had losses to the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints - I would have an awfully hard time using any system that concluded that I was a stronger team than the Titans, Steelers, Patriots, Giants and Saints. Better than some? Certainly that's possible. But better than all? That's a bad ranking system.
I don't say this to criticize you personally. I think it's great that people have ranking systems. But I would think that you would be interested in creating a better ranking system. Your ranking system appears to favor stats more than they should (since games are won by scoring points, not throwing for 260 yards in the 4th Quarter of a game you were losing by 2 TDs).
The Hammer might be a better team than the PAIN. Or the Warpath. Or the Roughnecks. But if they were a better team than all three of us, they would probably have beaten at least one of us, no?
That's not how it works.
Team 1 - 10-0
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Vs Detroit Lions W
Team 2 - 5-5
Steelers W
Titans W
Giants L
Patriots L
Bucs W
Dallas Cowboys W
Carolina Panthers L
Colts L
Jets L
Falcons W
Which team is better, team one or two?
RHIT Legend
offline
offline
Not to mention, Team 1 beats detriot only by a small to decent amount and team two loses most of their games by under 7 points.
RunningMn9
offline
offline
Originally posted by shaun123987
Which team is better, team one or two?
The problem with contrived examples is that they are contrived, and thus useless. We are not examining a situation where one team played the worst NFL franchise in history for 10 straight weeks, while another team played 10 real NFL teams. We are examining teams that have several games in common, and have played each other head-to-head. Coming up with a ridiculous strawman to try and illustrate the concept of strength of schedule at a 2nd grade level doesn't serve to help anyone.
The question isn't about whether or not Team 2 is better than Team 1. That question is not answerable because Team 1 hasn't played anyone other than the Detroit Lions, and Team 2 hasn't played the Lions. There is no reference point to compare.
The question is whether or not a ranking system that concludes that Team 2 is better than all of the teams that beat them is a useful ranking system. Not all ranking systems are accurate and useful. This one appears to favor something that it shouldn't be favoring as much as it does. That's the problem that all statistics-based ranking systems have when there isn't any analytical foundation in the weighting of the statistics used.
This is the problem that all producers of rankings must face. Does their system produce credible results among the consumers of the rankings? Are there people that still think that the Hammer is the second best team in the entire league? I suppose if a majority of people agree with that, then good for your system. I'd be shocked if a majority of people still thought that the Hammer was the second best team in the league.
My advice to Androth isn't to abandon his ranking system. It's to continue to examine it and tweak it when it starts producing questionable results.
If the BCS rankings were released yesterday, and they had Oklahoma State as the #2 team in the country, do you think that eyebrows would be raised? Especially if they were ranked above Oklahoma?
Which team is better, team one or two?
The problem with contrived examples is that they are contrived, and thus useless. We are not examining a situation where one team played the worst NFL franchise in history for 10 straight weeks, while another team played 10 real NFL teams. We are examining teams that have several games in common, and have played each other head-to-head. Coming up with a ridiculous strawman to try and illustrate the concept of strength of schedule at a 2nd grade level doesn't serve to help anyone.
The question isn't about whether or not Team 2 is better than Team 1. That question is not answerable because Team 1 hasn't played anyone other than the Detroit Lions, and Team 2 hasn't played the Lions. There is no reference point to compare.
The question is whether or not a ranking system that concludes that Team 2 is better than all of the teams that beat them is a useful ranking system. Not all ranking systems are accurate and useful. This one appears to favor something that it shouldn't be favoring as much as it does. That's the problem that all statistics-based ranking systems have when there isn't any analytical foundation in the weighting of the statistics used.
This is the problem that all producers of rankings must face. Does their system produce credible results among the consumers of the rankings? Are there people that still think that the Hammer is the second best team in the entire league? I suppose if a majority of people agree with that, then good for your system. I'd be shocked if a majority of people still thought that the Hammer was the second best team in the league.
My advice to Androth isn't to abandon his ranking system. It's to continue to examine it and tweak it when it starts producing questionable results.
If the BCS rankings were released yesterday, and they had Oklahoma State as the #2 team in the country, do you think that eyebrows would be raised? Especially if they were ranked above Oklahoma?
RunningMn9
offline
offline
I was surprised to note that we only have two games in common with the Hammer. This far into the season, I expected more. Anyway, we've got a head-to-head matchup, which the PAIN won by 10 points. And we've got two common opponents - the Louisville Warpath and the Kaiser Cougars.
The Hammer was -6 against the Warpath, while the PAIN were +7. The Hammer was +9 against the Cougars, while the PAIN were +25.
The PAIN won the head-to-head matchup by 10 points, and has outperformed the Hammer against common opponents (so far) by an average differential of 13.5 points per game.
Which is the stronger team?
Of course, I make this argument, knowing that I don't want to play the Hammer again because I don't think we can beat them twice.
The Hammer was -6 against the Warpath, while the PAIN were +7. The Hammer was +9 against the Cougars, while the PAIN were +25.
The PAIN won the head-to-head matchup by 10 points, and has outperformed the Hammer against common opponents (so far) by an average differential of 13.5 points per game.
Which is the stronger team?
Of course, I make this argument, knowing that I don't want to play the Hammer again because I don't think we can beat them twice.

Tijuana Glove
offline
offline
Man I'm glad we have a playoff system. Can you imagine how frustrating it would be to have championships decided by formulas?
octones
offline
offline
Yeah power rankings suck (I did them for AA2). Can never really get them fully right, but to have us below Carolina just means the formula you are using needs to be looked at because there is something wrong with it. Only option where we would still be below Carolina is if we had a worse record (see Jets beating Titans and not moving above them in most NFL power rankings).
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























