User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > timeout bug - why are we calling timeout in the dying minutes when the score is tied?
Page:
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
In real-life, you would never have seen the ball fyi. They would have run whatever they wanted with that kind of time left, whatever they felt they could gain yards with, and just spiked the ball to stop the clock and kicked the FG as time expired.

In GLB, the timeouts are taken automatically. There are issues with how the timeouts are taken (or aren't taken) but this isn't a good example of that.
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
1:35 1st & 10 OPP 18.5 Devan Lewis rush to the right (12.5 yd gain) [tackle: The Dymo] Replay
1:10 1st & G OPP 6 Delaney Lewis pitch to Devan Lewis to the right (0.5 yd loss) [tackle: Oliver Porter] Replay

Between those two plays, no timeouts called, 25 seconds elapsed. 40 seconds is the playclock, so obviously a hurry up offense is faster than 40 seconds.

As for when you took the timeouts -- they were taken assuming you could actually make a stop on defense. You lost because you couldn't stop their running game, not because of the TO's.


you mean as a coach you will call a timeout at that point? game tied and offense is trying to go forward with the littlest time possible? come on...i give you more credit than that

 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
In real-life, you would never have seen the ball fyi. They would have run whatever they wanted with that kind of time left, whatever they felt they could gain yards with, and just spiked the ball to stop the clock and kicked the FG as time expired.

In GLB, the timeouts are taken automatically. There are issues with how the timeouts are taken (or aren't taken) but this isn't a good example of that.


then it is a bug...

lots of things could've happened without those timeouts. that is the point.

 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by Mightyhalo


I see where he is going now. The Htmen had blown all their timeouts with the ball on the 48 yard line and with Ottawa calling the time out after the 1st down it gave the Hitmen more time to still run the ball into FG range when they didn't have any time outs left.

They probably would have been forced to pass which may or may not have affected the outcome.

Just one of those things you have to chalk up to the defense not being able to stop the run late, and not converting a beautiful opportunity to win the game with that throw to the WR on the last play of the game. O so close. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224390&pbp_id=6346462


It was on the 38 yard line (so a 55 yard field goal) with 1:40 left -- plenty of time, even if they wanted to run it, without timeouts to get to FG range, esp. the way they were running.

The timeouts saved time for the other team to get a shot to win the game, which they otherwise wouldn't have had.


first timeout was at 1:39 at 38 yard line (should have been a 55-56 yard fg at that point). the sim will be forced to either try a fg at that point or put a play in with 1 minute left.

also, the offense get to "breath" with a timeout, right? without that "breather" could they have made a long gain?

a lot of big things affected those timeouts. so don't belittle it.



1st timeout: 1:43 left, 38 yard line
2nd timeout: 1:39 left, 29 yard line
3rd timeout: 1:35 left, 18.5 yard line

Without calling those timeouts, they still get into FG range based on the way your defense is playing (guess what -- defense gets a "breather" as well, so that is a false argument) and they kick the FG to win anyways. The only difference is that you may have been able to use the timeouts on offense, assuming they left you enough time on the clock.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
Originally posted by SCACE

1:35 1st & 10 OPP 18.5 Devan Lewis rush to the right (12.5 yd gain) [tackle: The Dymo] Replay
1:10 1st & G OPP 6 Delaney Lewis pitch to Devan Lewis to the right (0.5 yd loss) [tackle: Oliver Porter] Replay

Between those two plays, no timeouts called, 25 seconds elapsed. 40 seconds is the playclock, so obviously a hurry up offense is faster than 40 seconds.

As for when you took the timeouts -- they were taken assuming you could actually make a stop on defense. You lost because you couldn't stop their running game, not because of the TO's.


you mean as a coach you will call a timeout at that point? game tied and offense is trying to go forward with the littlest time possible? come on...i give you more credit than that



With your swiss cheese defense, I don't think it mattered.
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by PaqMarq11

Originally posted by SCACE


Originally posted by Mightyhalo



I see where he is going now. The Htmen had blown all their timeouts with the ball on the 48 yard line and with Ottawa calling the time out after the 1st down it gave the Hitmen more time to still run the ball into FG range when they didn't have any time outs left.

They probably would have been forced to pass which may or may not have affected the outcome.

Just one of those things you have to chalk up to the defense not being able to stop the run late, and not converting a beautiful opportunity to win the game with that throw to the WR on the last play of the game. O so close. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224390&pbp_id=6346462


It was on the 38 yard line (so a 55 yard field goal) with 1:40 left -- plenty of time, even if they wanted to run it, without timeouts to get to FG range, esp. the way they were running.

The timeouts saved time for the other team to get a shot to win the game, which they otherwise wouldn't have had.


first timeout was at 1:39 at 38 yard line (should have been a 55-56 yard fg at that point). the sim will be forced to either try a fg at that point or put a play in with 1 minute left.

also, the offense get to "breath" with a timeout, right? without that "breather" could they have made a long gain?

a lot of big things affected those timeouts. so don't belittle it.



1st timeout: 1:43 left, 38 yard line
2nd timeout: 1:39 left, 29 yard line
3rd timeout: 1:35 left, 18.5 yard line

Without calling those timeouts, they still get into FG range based on the way your defense is playing (guess what -- defense gets a "breather" as well, so that is a false argument) and they kick the FG to win anyways. The only difference is that you may have been able to use the timeouts on offense, assuming they left you enough time on the clock.


1st time out: 1:43 left, 46 YARD LINE - don't muddle it

defense sucked. yeah...

but you wouldn't call that timeout as a coach. why would you make the sim call a timeout here? it's a bug.

using the timeout for the offense is another matter. which makes this whole argument more important, don't you think?

Last edited Nov 27, 2008 13:28:21
 
lunchbox6186
offline
Link
 
Maybe you saw a bad matchup and had to call timeout so you didnt get burned?
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lunchbox6186
Maybe you saw a bad matchup and had to call timeout so you didnt get burned?


lol. seriously?
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
PM - check your box score again please. The timeout is called AFTER the play is over. The play started on the 46-yard line and ended on the 38.

You are the one who is muddling it.
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
PM - check your box score again please. The timeout is called AFTER the play is over. The play started on the 46-yard line and ended on the 38.

You are the one who is muddling it.


you wouldn't still call a timeout at that point. no one would

 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Assuming the same plays are run, but the timeouts are not called:

1:48 - 8.5-yard rush to the 38 (5 seconds for the play according to the clock)

--Knock off 20 seconds to the next play--

1:23 - 9-yard rush to the 29 (4 seconds for the play according to the clock)

--Knock off 20 seconds to the next play--

0:59 - 10.5-yard gain to the 18.5 (4 seconds for the play according to the clock)

--Knock off 35 seconds leading up to kicking the FG--

0:20 - 35.5 FG attempted (assume it is made)

--12 second run-off as per the kick-off play from your game--

You get the ball with 0:08 left and 3 timeouts on your 17.5 yard line
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Assuming the same plays are run, but the timeouts are not called:

1:48 - 8.5-yard rush to the 38 (5 seconds for the play according to the clock)

--Knock off 20 seconds to the next play--

1:23 - 9-yard rush to the 29 (4 seconds for the play according to the clock)

--Knock off 20 seconds to the next play--

0:59 - 10.5-yard gain to the 18.5 (4 seconds for the play according to the clock)

--Knock off 35 seconds leading up to kicking the FG--

0:20 - 35.5 FG attempted (assume it is made)

--12 second run-off as per the kick-off play from your game--

You get the ball with 0:08 left and 3 timeouts on your 17.5 yard line


can you give proof of how long a "hurry up" is?

you say we got a "breather" too. but the "breather" was needed by them more to gain more yards. we are on defense. we are not trying to gain yards against the clock.

you cannot take out the timeouts because that is the whole point!
Last edited Nov 27, 2008 13:46:07
 
lunchbox6186
offline
Link
 
Yea but you do get a breather to play better defense or in your case any defense. Maybe you should just move on because the timeouts where not that bad and asking for a re-sim is absolutely ridiculous. Get off the bug forums and go look for some defensive players
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
Originally posted by SCACE

Assuming the same plays are run, but the timeouts are not called:

1:48 - 8.5-yard rush to the 38 (5 seconds for the play according to the clock)

--Knock off 20 seconds to the next play--

1:23 - 9-yard rush to the 29 (4 seconds for the play according to the clock)

--Knock off 20 seconds to the next play--

0:59 - 10.5-yard gain to the 18.5 (4 seconds for the play according to the clock)

--Knock off 35 seconds leading up to kicking the FG--

0:20 - 35.5 FG attempted (assume it is made)

--12 second run-off as per the kick-off play from your game--

You get the ball with 0:08 left and 3 timeouts on your 17.5 yard line


can you give proof of how long a "hurry up" is?

you say we got a "breather" too. but the "breather" was needed by them more to gain more yards. we are on defense. we are not trying to gain yards against the clock.

you cannot take out the timeouts because that is the whole point!


I'm sure the hurry up varies from play to play. When you were out of timeouts, they ran a rush play and ran another play 25 seconds later. Then they ran off between 30-40 seconds before kicking their FG.

Here is a game my own team played:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=214394&mode=pbp

They ran a play late in the 4th with no timeouts at 26 seconds left and were able to kick a FG with 6 seconds on the clock. 20 seconds is a reasonable "best guess", which is why I used it in the example above.

If you are going to say the offense gets a breather, you have to admit that the defense gets a breather as well. You say they need the breather to gain more yards -- you get the breather to make the play faster and not allow them to gain the yards -- its a bad argument and you should realize that. And unless Bort states it, I have no idea if you get a breather when you take a timeout, that was out of your mouth first, not mine.

Finally, I am taking the timeouts out to show you that you were in trouble either way -- you called the timeouts in the hopes that your defense could contain their offense and to give your offense as much time as possible for a final drive. If you don't take the timeouts and they still get first downs, your in a worse situation.
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lunchbox6186
Yea but you do get a breather to play better defense or in your case any defense. Maybe you should just move on because the timeouts where not that bad and asking for a re-sim is absolutely ridiculous. Get off the bug forums and go look for some defensive players


get off my thread, troll.

timeouts are wrong at that situation. do you think at that time it was the right call?

i was calling for a re-sim because what happened wasn't something we have control of. timeouts were called. it was wrong. it's a bug!

would you like your playoff chances determined by a bug? think about that for a bit before posting again, please.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.