User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Accepting a friendly challenge COSTS 25 flex points
Page:
 
mykel
offline
Link
 
i saw the link. doesnt change the fact that what the challenge page says does not reflect accurately what happens. ill admit i didnt read the wiki previously, nor did i read that post by bort. frankly i have better things to do then scour the boards for everythoing he posts. also that statement is not recorded in an official manner in the rules or on the challenge page. plus your logic of using the wiki as an official system of record is fundamentally flawed as i have already pointed out and demonstrated.

with all the being said, ill concede it may be working as intended based on borts post, however its is NOT working as described on the challenge description page
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
The Wiki is there for everyone's benefit. If you don't like it, don't use it. Nowhere on the Wiki does it say that everything you read is 100% true/correct. Everyone being able to edit/create pages is what makes it a Wiki. It becomes a huge hub of knowledge and is a valuable tool for each and every member of this community.
 
PjSanford
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by mykel

Originally posted by bmedders


I doesn't say challenging a team to a scrimmage cost 25 FP, just scheduling it.

Working as intended.


A few things...

1 - read the rest of the sentence.

"which will be deducted when the other team accepts your offer"

This implies that it will charge the challenging team otherwise it would say something along the lines of "Which will be deducted when both teams have agreed to the challenge"

2 - It specifically states it costs 25 flex points. By both parties paying for the game it costs 50 flex, not 25


Actually, it implies it will be deducted once the challenged team accepts.


Just gonna point out, the wording and the arguement wouldn't hold up in court in the UK. The way it is worded and costs make it sound as though it is one person paying, for 25 flex points.

The linguistics is off.
 
mykel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
The Wiki is there for everyone's benefit. If you don't like it, don't use it. Nowhere on the Wiki does it say that everything you read is 100% true/correct. Everyone being able to edit/create pages is what makes it a Wiki. It becomes a huge hub of knowledge and is a valuable tool for each and every member of this community.


I am not saying that the Wiki is not a good source of knowledge - my point which you seem to miss, is exactly what you said - there is no guarantee that what it states is correct, so if I am looking for an answer, which should I believe? That which Bort (or whoever designed the Challenge page) ON the GLB site says, or that which I can change to read as I personally see fit? I will refer you to my original posts - on the challenge page it states that the cost per scrimmage is 25 flex, however the way it is working is that the cost is 50 flex. Now this is a bug. Now what IS the bug can be up for debate. Is it that the cost should only be 25 or is it that the page is not stating the correct cost and THAT is the bug. It would appear that the second be the case due to Bort's post (as Nixx pointed out)
 
mykel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PjSanford
Originally posted by Voltron

Originally posted by mykel


Originally posted by bmedders



I doesn't say challenging a team to a scrimmage cost 25 FP, just scheduling it.

Working as intended.


A few things...

1 - read the rest of the sentence.

"which will be deducted when the other team accepts your offer"

This implies that it will charge the challenging team otherwise it would say something along the lines of "Which will be deducted when both teams have agreed to the challenge"

2 - It specifically states it costs 25 flex points. By both parties paying for the game it costs 50 flex, not 25


Actually, it implies it will be deducted once the challenged team accepts.


Just gonna point out, the wording and the arguement wouldn't hold up in court in the UK. The way it is worded and costs make it sound as though it is one person paying, for 25 flex points.

The linguistics is off.


To play devils advocate - its the US not the UK

But this is my point - the page states the cost is 25, not 50 and when I accept a challenge I would expect not to pay as the person issuing the challenge is already charged that 25...
 
mykel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by musky5
Originally posted by Nixx

Originally posted by mykel


And Nixx, the glbwiki is not an official GLB site - it is a wiki meaning that I could go in there and change it to state "all challenges cost 25 flex which are charged directly to Nixx". As a matter of fact, while writing this I changed it to say "the challenging owner pays" so really - that would prove me to be right now wouldnt it....


If you read what I said, the link in number 2, which goes to a post by Bort stating that both teams pay.


boom.


Oh and one last thing - how cute is it that someone that hasn't contributed to a conversation feels as if they need to come post a one word response and miss the entire gist of the rest of the conversation (just caught this as I was replying to his response while musky responded)
 
mykel
offline
Link
 
and this makes 4 in a row
 
PjSanford
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mykel
To play devils advocate - its the US not the UK

But this is my point - the page states the cost is 25, not 50 and when I accept a challenge I would expect not to pay as the person issuing the challenge is already charged that 25...


He accepts money from all over the World.
 
mykel
offline
Link
 
i know.....i was having fun with you
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Not sure that this is a Bug per se, as much as badly worded sentance and a lack of clarity about T&C's.

1) When making a Challenge you are informed officially that the cost is 25 Flex and is charged once the Challenge is accepted.

2) When informed of a challenge being recieved you are not informed you will be charged.
Originally posted by

Dear Mike Rogers,

This is an automated message.

Your team, the Draft Class, has just received an offer from the Babyface Monarchs to play a friendly scrimmage match on day 19 at 18:00.

You can view and accept or reject this offer by going to the proposed scrimmage match's status page.

If you do not respond within 5 days, or by the day of the match, the match will be automatically rejected.

If you would like to send a message to the owner of the Babyface Monarchs you may simply reply to this message.


3) WHEN ACCEPTING A CHALLENGE, the following information is given.

Originally posted by
Friendly Scrimmage Status
Scheduling a friendly scrimmage costs 25 Flex Points, however you are allowed up to two free friendly scrimmages per team per season.

Once a friendly scrimmage game has been agreed to, it is LOCKED IN for the day and time specified.

Free Friendlies Remaining this Season: 2



The issue is that at no point does the information declare that the charge is per team.

The term scheduling is ambiguous, and could apply to both teams or just the challenging team.

However that is made redundant by the total cost being defined as 25 Flex.

The simple fix is to add the words for each team. to the end of the bolded sentances in 3)
Last edited Nov 27, 2008 06:07:24
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
And for future reference fr all those Legal Eagles out there who always argue which set of laws are enforced etc....

In the terms of Use....

10. GENERAL PROVISIONS

These terms will be governed by and construed solely in accordance with the laws of the United States and the State of Oregon, excluding that body of law governing conflict of laws. Both you and GoalLineBlitz.com agree that any legal action or proceeding relating to or arising out of these Terms of Use or your use of GoalLineBlitz.com's Web site or services will be brought exclusively in a federal or state court in Oregon, and by agreeing to these Terms of Use you submit to the personal jurisdiction of, and venue in, such courts.
Last edited Nov 27, 2008 06:11:17
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
The OP and the guy above are correct. This is an instance where the text fails. It needs to add the words "for each team"
 
mykel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Not sure that this is a Bug per se, as much as badly worded sentance and a lack of clarity about T&C's.

1) When making a Challenge you are informed officially that the cost is 25 Flex and is charged once the Challenge is accepted.

2) When informed of a challenge being recieved you are not informed you will be charged.
Originally posted by


Dear Mike Rogers,

This is an automated message.

Your team, the Draft Class, has just received an offer from the Babyface Monarchs to play a friendly scrimmage match on day 19 at 18:00.

You can view and accept or reject this offer by going to the proposed scrimmage match's status page.

If you do not respond within 5 days, or by the day of the match, the match will be automatically rejected.

If you would like to send a message to the owner of the Babyface Monarchs you may simply reply to this message.


3) WHEN ACCEPTING A CHALLENGE, the following information is given.

Originally posted by

Friendly Scrimmage Status
Scheduling a friendly scrimmage costs 25 Flex Points, however you are allowed up to two free friendly scrimmages per team per season.

Once a friendly scrimmage game has been agreed to, it is LOCKED IN for the day and time specified.

Free Friendlies Remaining this Season: 2



The issue is that at no point does the information declare that the charge is per team.

The term scheduling is ambiguous, and could apply to both teams or just the challenging team.

However that is made redundant by the total cost being defined as 25 Flex.

The simple fix is to add the words for each team. to the end of the bolded sentances in 3)


+1 - as stated earlier - I conceeded that it is working as intended based on Bort's post - however the wording is misleading
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
Well, scheduling it costs 25 flex points. That's right. But it takes 2 teams to schedule it. One proposes, and one accepts, sure, but they work together and both teams schedule the friendly. So both teams are charged
 
mykel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
Well, scheduling it costs 25 flex points. That's right. But it takes 2 teams to schedule it. One proposes, and one accepts, sure, but they work together and both teams schedule the friendly. So both teams are charged


Way to jump in and repeat what has already been stated in the thread. Let me know when you catch up to the current topic!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.