User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Wrap up tackling....still overpowered
Page:
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
I agree with you that it should be minimal fumbles if set on wrap up. But my team does not play on wrap up. Our players who have high tackling and strength play on balanced at the lowest unless we're in a big game in which we play on wrap up. Usually we'll play on force fumble, and I'm sure there are teams out there like this as well.
 
treee
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
NFL - less than 0.5 fumbles per game

Canada PRO - 1.15 fumbles per game, 0.79 fumbles lost per game

USA PRO - 1.15 fumbles per game, 0.73 fumbles lost per game

Africa PRO - 1.13 fumbles per game, 0.78 fumbles lost per game

South America PRO - 1.13 fumbles per game, 0.75 fumbles lost per game

Western Europe Pro - 1.13 fumbles per game, 0.70 fumbles lost per game

Oceania PRO - 1.05 fumbles per game, 0.74 fumbles lost per game

Eastern Europe PRO - 1.04 fumbles per game, 0.63 fumbles lost per game

South East Asia PRO - 0.98 fumbles per game, 0.63 fumbles lost per game

I'll get the other PRO leagues later -- it is well known that the majority of players play on wrap up because it is the safest (least missed tackles) while still providing a very good chance of forcing a fumble.

All I am saying is that there needs to be a trade-off between playing on wrap-up, combo or power, because right now there really isn't a reason to play on anything but wrap up -- you get the best of both worlds from the setting.



This game is ment to be a fantasy football game, not an NFL replica.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
*yawn* old argument.

It is meant to be a football simulation game and should, to its best ability, try to reflect similar (not exact, similar) statistics when compared to real-life football leagues -- the NFL being the top level we have to compare to.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
*yawn* old argument.

It is meant to be a football simulation game and should, to its best ability, try to reflect similar (not exact, similar) statistics when compared to real-life football leagues -- the NFL being the top level we have to compare to.


well honestly with that statement said I would have to say it does compare VERY closely to the NFL. QBs don't fumble nearly as often as they do in the NFL, RBs fumble a little more often. Equaling itself out in my opinion. Fumbles lost, we hardly lose fumbles in GLB while in the NFL if you fumble, you're more than likely going to lose that ball.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by SCACE

*yawn* old argument.

It is meant to be a football simulation game and should, to its best ability, try to reflect similar (not exact, similar) statistics when compared to real-life football leagues -- the NFL being the top level we have to compare to.


well honestly with that statement said I would have to say it does compare VERY closely to the NFL. QBs don't fumble nearly as often as they do in the NFL, RBs fumble a little more often. Equaling itself out in my opinion. Fumbles lost, we hardly lose fumbles in GLB while in the NFL if you fumble, you're more than likely going to lose that ball.


Did you bother to read the GLB fumbling statistics from the PRO leagues? Teams here are losing around 60-70% of their fumbles. Probably a bit too low, but not as ridiculous as I might have thought.

I will agree that QB's don't fumble enough on sacks however, but that is without looking at the numbers.
Last edited Nov 26, 2008 20:52:07
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Schaffer05

Originally posted by SCACE


*yawn* old argument.

It
is meant to be a football simulation game and should, to its best
ability, try to reflect similar (not exact, similar) statistics when
compared to real-life football leagues -- the NFL being the top level
we have to compare to.


well honestly with that statement
said I would have to say it does compare VERY closely to the NFL. QBs
don't fumble nearly as often as they do in the NFL, RBs fumble a little
more often. Equaling itself out in my opinion. Fumbles lost, we hardly
lose fumbles in GLB while in the NFL if you fumble, you're more than
likely going to lose that ball.


Did you bother to read
the GLB fumbling statistics from the PRO leagues? Teams here are losing
around 60-70% of their fumbles. Probably a bit too low, but not as
ridiculous as I might have thought.

I will agree that QB's don't fumble enough on sacks however, but that is without looking at the numbers.


Actually, I think teams losing about 60% of their fumbles is about right.
 
Tobysmith6922
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by mocfam10


I don't get
what you're saying. I know some backs that break over 10 tackles a game
while everyone is set to wrap-up tackling. It doesn't no good against
them.


Sorry, let me clarify. Wrap Up tackling is the
lowest setting, meant to mean a better chance of making a tackle and a
lower chance of causing a fumble. Broken tackles aren't out of hand vs.
even competition. Fumbles however appear to be. Knowing that most
people play on wrap up, one would think fumbles would be occurring at a
lower rate.


Exactly.

I do know that my team plays exclusively wrap-up on defense, and we cause a fumble a game or thereabouts.

A team playing Wrap-Up should basically never cause a fumble.


My FS has two forced fumbles and he is always set to wrap-up tackling...
 
MudBugs
offline
Link
 
My level 34 DT which I have set to Power Tackle has only caused four fumbles this season. His strength is 92, speed 55, agility 64 and tackling 52! I also use the run stuffer SAs! Through 8 games he has only missed 1 tackle. I wanted to see if power tackling works. Im not sure it does with 4 fumbles 27 tackles and 1 missed.
 
Link
 
Maybe GLB HB's are modeled after Marcus Allen and Ronnie Harmon, LOL!
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
Thanks for the clarification SCACE. I see your point and I agree with you.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE


Did you bother to read the GLB fumbling statistics from the PRO leagues? Teams here are losing around 60-70% of their fumbles. Probably a bit too low, but not as ridiculous as I might have thought.

I will agree that QB's don't fumble enough on sacks however, but that is without looking at the numbers.


I did read your post, and I don't think that .65 MORE fumbles a game in the pro leagues than the NFL is outrageous. We're still getting better, like I said before. What would we have to look forward to if we were playing on the NFL leagues now in season 6 when we still have 4 seasons to go before we start our decline? Season 10 should be your peek, not season 5-6.

Last edited Nov 27, 2008 06:24:28
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Hell, I'd be happy to see players with low strength set to wrap up tackling get dragged down the field until they can get help with the tackle by a team mate if they hit a high strength target.

I'm picturing Larry Csonka, John Riggins, and Earl Campbell and their ability to simply move the pile for 5 yards or more before anyone but the best tacklers could bring them down.

PinTBC
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Hell, I'd be happy to see players with low strength set to wrap up tackling get dragged down the field until they can get help with the tackle by a team mate if they hit a high strength target.

I'm picturing Larry Csonka, John Riggins, and Earl Campbell and their ability to simply move the pile for 5 yards or more before anyone but the best tacklers could bring them down.

PinTBC


I support that idea. Not really missing the tackle, but allowing the ball carrier some yards after the hit.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 

Wrap Up Tackling is just Form tackling, ie break down, plant feet, good body position, tackle low, hold on.

Should be almost no chance at a fumble given almost equal strengths.

But by the same token should be very few 'Broken' Tackles, and all ball carriers should be falling forwards (and gaining a yard or two.)

There should be more 'missed' Tackles though as the technique stops your momentum and allows a quick cut/spin to trick you more often.


 
supersoul
offline
Link
 
If I'm not mistaken, form tackling also involves putting your hat wherever the ball carrier is cradling it. So there's some chance to cause a fumble.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.