User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Mobius Man
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ilok
Originally posted by Painmaker

Why is everyone so convinced the CBs are engaged with the blocking WR? Not on the ground, not picked, not pancaked... engaged. Have so few people seen "pick" plays designed to cause DBs to interfere with one another because they're not paying attention?

Hard to insist that what the dots are doing is stupid when all you see is dots that are basically staying in one place.


because people rather call a play a bug than figure out how to stop it. I'm just going to keep taking advantage of people who insist on blitzing every play. If I had a RB that can catch I would run a Hb screen too and really eat up these defense.


What does blitzing the LBs have to do with the WR's ability to block 2 CBs? That sure doesn't happen very often in real life, nor should it in GLB.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Why is everyone so convinced the CBs are engaged with the blocking WR? Not on the ground, not picked, not pancaked... engaged. Have so few people seen "pick" plays designed to cause DBs to interfere with one another because they're not paying attention?

Hard to insist that what the dots are doing is stupid when all you see is dots that are basically staying in one place.





Originally posted by Jazzpelli
Like this...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=231304&pbp_id=5470504
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
Originally posted by Painmaker

Why is everyone so convinced the CBs are engaged with the blocking WR? Not on the ground, not picked, not pancaked... engaged. Have so few people seen "pick" plays designed to cause DBs to interfere with one another because they're not paying attention?

Hard to insist that what the dots are doing is stupid when all you see is dots that are basically staying in one place.





Originally posted by Jazzpelli

Like this...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=231304&pbp_id=5470504


One man's "dot reading" fwiw: WR blocked the LB and the CB had to run around the two of them. That's not two guys getting blocked by one player at all.

Do people think there's no traffic on screen plays in real life? o_0
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Gee that's funny, i can't recall a single time in real life when a guy actually gets stuck on an already-engaged blocker while trying to make his way around.

Yes, there's traffic on screen plays in real life, and i'm familiar with the concept of the natural pick, but it takes far too long for the defender to get around the blocker in this instance. All the CB has to do is make a quick jump to the side and he'd be out of the way, but instead he hugs the WR all the way.

If you want to talk realism, then this is not it.
Last edited Nov 24, 2008 23:02:22
 
dboys194
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Why is everyone so convinced the CBs are engaged with the blocking WR? Not on the ground, not picked, not pancaked... engaged. Have so few people seen "pick" plays designed to cause DBs to interfere with one another because they're not paying attention?

Hard to insist that what the dots are doing is stupid when all you see is dots that are basically staying in one place.


its not a pick play, its a screen. the guy is not pancaked because no one touched him until he gets blocked by a WR who is already blocking another guy. your argument that he is on the ground could work except that it only happens on this screen play and only when he comes close to the CB.

and to llok, we would be able to defend it if the WR wasnt blocking 2 guys.

i am an OC so this play could be helping me but i dont like to win by bugs.
 
Xelstyle
offline
Link
 
It could be worse...or better depending on your position.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=246741&pbp_id=5448246

Man, he must've been standing on 1 foot blocking all 3 guys.
 
dboys194
offline
Link
 
thats a perfect example right there. lets see what stupid explanations people come up with to say its not a bug
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
I'm not saying it's cool that a wr can block two CBs like the replay show. I just think it's not a coincidence that a play designed to counter act blitzes is hugely effective against blitzes and not very effective against plays where no one blitzes. When a blitz happens the WR can block two guys, when there isn't a blitz, the WR can't block anyone.

Yes you can give me replays of successful screens with no blitzes, but a good 90% of the time no blitz stuffs the play. You can also give me examples of blitzes stuffing the WR screen but 90% of the time it gets big yardage.

I don't think this is a bug, it's how the play is designed to work against the blitz.
 
Jazzpelli
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ilok
I'm not saying it's cool that a wr can block two CBs like the replay show. I just think it's not a coincidence that a play designed to counter act blitzes is hugely effective against blitzes and not very effective against plays where no one blitzes. When a blitz happens the WR can block two guys, when there isn't a blitz, the WR can't block anyone.

Yes you can give me replays of successful screens with no blitzes, but a good 90% of the time no blitz stuffs the play. You can also give me examples of blitzes stuffing the WR screen but 90% of the time it gets big yardage.

I don't think this is a bug, it's how the play is designed to work against the blitz.


Then you don't understand the argument. The play is designed to counter blitzes but it is showing a huge blocking bug in the sim program. This bug also appears in run plays but it is less apparent.

All offensive players are demonstrating that there is no distinction for a blocking one defender or multiple defenders. Why do you think that defenses blitz so much? Its cause one tackle or guard can block a DE and LB while the FB can take out another LB and safety. Basically, a defense has to send twice as many people since there is no penalty for having to block multiple defenders which is the ENTIRE issue.
 
cotterill101
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dboys194
title explains the bug. im sure this isnt the first time this has happened either.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=257616&pbp_id=5235718


1-hand each
-Chuckles-
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jazzpelli
Originally posted by Ilok

I'm not saying it's cool that a wr can block two CBs like the replay show. I just think it's not a coincidence that a play designed to counter act blitzes is hugely effective against blitzes and not very effective against plays where no one blitzes. When a blitz happens the WR can block two guys, when there isn't a blitz, the WR can't block anyone.

Yes you can give me replays of successful screens with no blitzes, but a good 90% of the time no blitz stuffs the play. You can also give me examples of blitzes stuffing the WR screen but 90% of the time it gets big yardage.

I don't think this is a bug, it's how the play is designed to work against the blitz.


Then you don't understand the argument. The play is designed to counter blitzes but it is showing a huge blocking bug in the sim program. This bug also appears in run plays but it is less apparent.

All offensive players are demonstrating that there is no distinction for a blocking one defender or multiple defenders. Why do you think that defenses blitz so much? Its cause one tackle or guard can block a DE and LB while the FB can take out another LB and safety. Basically, a defense has to send twice as many people since there is no penalty for having to block multiple defenders which is the ENTIRE issue.


Preach it!
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.