Originally posted by Bort
So the real suggestion here breaks down to:
Stop listening to the squeaky wheels, and just do what you originally intended to do?
LOL, I'm going to try and figure out some of what squeaky wheels got since season 1's version:
1) It was harder to make tackles on high strength backs without high tackling skill. People complained there were too many broken tackles. Tackling became easier.
2) Leagues had a much larger disparity in ticket prices (bottom league was less than half of Pro) because we wanted to separate talent for later levels. People complained they were not all getting the same product when they bought a team. Ticket prices in low leagues got raised.
3) Catching was harder without high catching skill, even when wide open. People complained about too many drops. "Wide Open" got a larger bonus.
4) Weak OL got trucked by high strength DT and DE's. People complained that D Line was too good. Run blocking got a boost.
I'm sure there's more.
I'm seeing a trend...
You've built a game that lets us try to adapt to it and make something that works. Then we have the added challenge of adapting to the players around us. So long as a person plays smart, its a fun and enriching experience. I'd say you do have to let things play out a bit while only tweaking things here and there. Complaints will come but its the fact that those OLs needed strength, that those WRs needed catching and those defenders needed tackling that kept those attributes even with speed/agility in value. Sure, you have to watch out for the 90str/35spd Running Back running everyone over but thats a mechanics fix for how running over people is done, not necessarily a need to change the value of strength.
Let the complaints come, watch the smart players evolve to play against each other. Watch people take advantage of small things in the system to make beasts and others counter those beasts. Step in only when something is very ridiculous (like the afforementioned Running Back).
So the real suggestion here breaks down to:
Stop listening to the squeaky wheels, and just do what you originally intended to do?

LOL, I'm going to try and figure out some of what squeaky wheels got since season 1's version:
1) It was harder to make tackles on high strength backs without high tackling skill. People complained there were too many broken tackles. Tackling became easier.
2) Leagues had a much larger disparity in ticket prices (bottom league was less than half of Pro) because we wanted to separate talent for later levels. People complained they were not all getting the same product when they bought a team. Ticket prices in low leagues got raised.
3) Catching was harder without high catching skill, even when wide open. People complained about too many drops. "Wide Open" got a larger bonus.
4) Weak OL got trucked by high strength DT and DE's. People complained that D Line was too good. Run blocking got a boost.
I'm sure there's more.
I'm seeing a trend...

You've built a game that lets us try to adapt to it and make something that works. Then we have the added challenge of adapting to the players around us. So long as a person plays smart, its a fun and enriching experience. I'd say you do have to let things play out a bit while only tweaking things here and there. Complaints will come but its the fact that those OLs needed strength, that those WRs needed catching and those defenders needed tackling that kept those attributes even with speed/agility in value. Sure, you have to watch out for the 90str/35spd Running Back running everyone over but thats a mechanics fix for how running over people is done, not necessarily a need to change the value of strength.
Let the complaints come, watch the smart players evolve to play against each other. Watch people take advantage of small things in the system to make beasts and others counter those beasts. Step in only when something is very ridiculous (like the afforementioned Running Back).




























