User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > is anybody suspicious that "go for int only if help over the top" isn't working anymore?
Page:
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NotRippedYet
Originally posted by supgreg

I fail to see how a CB making a bad play on the ball is a bug. It's a bad read. What is his Vision? Jumping? Swat Ball? 50 Vision isn't that good in the grand scheme of things. If 50 Vision was the standard for a near perfect CB, what is 75 Vision, or 100 going to be like?

Jumping a route and missing, misplaying the ball, not being able to jump higher than the WR are all normal plays in football at all levels.


Except for this completely ignores the tactics the user sets. If I set my CB to play medium and only go after the ball when I have over the top help the CB shouldn't ever attempt to jump the route and get underneath, unless he has over the top help.

Just like if I set my safeties to play a cover 2 shell, they shouldn't be coming in underneath and helping to double or triple team already covered receivers, they should play a zone over the top of the coverage.


I know what you are saying, and I get it. But are you suggesting that our players play everything flawless? Personally, I like that a player can screw up, that way it's not just about my speed vs. your speed. If players always did exactly what they were told, then speed would be the only separation. I can do what you can do only faster.

It sucks when your guy screws up, but haven't you ever seen a real football player go for the big play and screw it up? Players make the wrong zone reads in the NFL all the time, don't you think it's frustrating to NFL and college coaches, too?
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Players make mistakes, that's to be expected.

I find my players do what I expect most of the time, moreso when they are properly built and gameplanned appropriately.

Working as intended, from my perspective.
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Players make mistakes, that's to be expected.

I find my players do what I expect most of the time, moreso when they are properly built and gameplanned appropriately.

Working as intended, from my perspective.


Thank you.
 
Darkstrand
offline
Link
 
I think you guys are badly overestimating the complexity of bort's simulation.
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkstrand
I think you guys are badly overestimating the complexity of bort's simulation.


For one thing, you haven't provided any examples to support your claim, you "just feel like it's been bugging out lately."

I'm sure he's going to jump on a fix, just cuz you feel something.

Not to mention you admitted you don't run Cover 2, so how can you accurately measure if something where help over the top is working if you don't ever have help over the top?
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkstrand
I think you guys are badly overestimating the complexity of bort's simulation.


Simulations and AI are actually areas in which I have a passable level of expertise, and I happen to disagree strongly. In fact, I would say that most people misunderstand both the nature of this simulation, and the qualitative properties upon which it is premised.
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
I've been seeing some strangeness myself. Times where someone was set for Medium, clearly didn't have help over the top, went for the INT, missed, and got burned for a long reception.

I've also seen times where a player is on Aggressive, cuts right in front of the WR (with 50 Jumping) and somehow misses.

I wasn't sure these were bugs, but man, are they annoying.


Same here and it is aggravating as hell to have your CB jump a route when you have no help over the top.
 
Darkstrand
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by supgreg
Originally posted by Darkstrand

I think you guys are badly overestimating the complexity of bort's simulation.


For one thing, you haven't provided any examples to support your claim, you "just feel like it's been bugging out lately."

I'm sure he's going to jump on a fix, just cuz you feel something.

Not to mention you admitted you don't run Cover 2, so how can you accurately measure if something where help over the top is working if you don't ever have help over the top?


hahahahaha angry forum posters lol.

"how can I tell if help over the top is working if they never have help over the top?"

gee because they act like they have help over the top?

maybe this thread is here to see if other people are having the same kind of feelings? if there is a consensus that stuff has been weird lately then it's a pretty good indicator that stuff has been weird lately. But of course you don't think in those kind of terms.
Last edited Nov 20, 2008 19:04:04
 
NotRippedYet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by supgreg
Originally posted by NotRippedYet

Originally posted by supgreg


I fail to see how a CB making a bad play on the ball is a bug. It's a bad read. What is his Vision? Jumping? Swat Ball? 50 Vision isn't that good in the grand scheme of things. If 50 Vision was the standard for a near perfect CB, what is 75 Vision, or 100 going to be like?

Jumping a route and missing, misplaying the ball, not being able to jump higher than the WR are all normal plays in football at all levels.


Except for this completely ignores the tactics the user sets. If I set my CB to play medium and only go after the ball when I have over the top help the CB shouldn't ever attempt to jump the route and get underneath, unless he has over the top help.

Just like if I set my safeties to play a cover 2 shell, they shouldn't be coming in underneath and helping to double or triple team already covered receivers, they should play a zone over the top of the coverage.


I know what you are saying, and I get it. But are you suggesting that our players play everything flawless? Personally, I like that a player can screw up, that way it's not just about my speed vs. your speed. If players always did exactly what they were told, then speed would be the only separation. I can do what you can do only faster.

It sucks when your guy screws up, but haven't you ever seen a real football player go for the big play and screw it up? Players make the wrong zone reads in the NFL all the time, don't you think it's frustrating to NFL and college coaches, too?


I agree there needs to be some margin of error on the players part.

That said, have you ever seen an NFL SS that bites on an inside TE post when the WR on his side streaks nearly every single time the play is run?

I went through ONE of your games. On every one of these plays your safeties are in Cv 2 and AT LEAST one of them has a receiver behind or even with him prior to the release from the QB.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2566992
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2567067
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2568292
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2568902
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2569516
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2569709
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2569938
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2569960
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2570650
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2570822
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=233016&pbp_id=2571464

That is NOT Cover 2.


 
Tobysmith6922
offline
Link
 
Edit...
Last edited Nov 21, 2008 00:08:21
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tobysmith6922
Are your players getting PD's every game???...if they are, then put some skill points into Catching and Jumping and they might get an Int instead of a PD or getting burned when they "miss" the Int attempt....


This is a great idea! Gosh... why didn't we all just come up with that one! We're so dumb... but thanks to your experience with your lv. 22 FS we're enlightened now!



(if one of your guys ever plays in a AAA or pro league, you will understand that your post was funny)

________________________________________________


Now let's get back to topic:

Why don't do CBs just what they're set to? How do you order the CB to play it safe when playing one-on-one while going for the pick when another defender offers help over the top?
 
bacardi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by supgreg
I fail to see how a CB making a bad play on the ball is a bug. It's a bad read. What is his Vision? Jumping? Swat Ball? 50 Vision isn't that good in the grand scheme of things. If 50 Vision was the standard for a near perfect CB, what is 75 Vision, or 100 going to be like?

Jumping a route and missing, misplaying the ball, not being able to jump higher than the WR are all normal plays in football at all levels.

holy crap i was going to respond to the complete retardedness of this post but i see 10 other people already have.

it isnt about making the play on the ball at all. i already mentioned i EXPECT cbs to get beat occasionally. its about playing according to tactics.

do you know what happens to the QB when you set "never dump off" ? THEY NEVER DUMP OFF. if their vision is 10, THEY STILL NEVER DUMP OFF. lower vision doesnt make you do the opposite of tactical settings.

if i set a CB to not go for INT without over the top help, guess what i expect? NOT GOING FOR THE INT WITHOUT OVER THE TOP HELP. if the CB gets beat, fine. if he misses a tackle, ok. if he bit on a pump fake, it happens. but he should NOT be going for an INT without help.
 
Tobysmith6922
offline
Link
 
Edit....
Last edited Nov 21, 2008 00:06:15
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by Tobysmith6922

Are your players getting PD's every game???...if they are, then put some skill points into Catching and Jumping and they might get an Int instead of a PD or getting burned when they "miss" the Int attempt....


This is a great idea! Gosh... why didn't we all just come up with that one! We're so dumb... but thanks to your experience with your lv. 22 FS we're enlightened now!

(if one of your guys ever plays in a AAA or pro league, you will understand that your post was funny)



wtf does playing in a AAA or Pro League have anything to do with it? Your level 37 FS appears to be a joke of a player, so you might need to follow some advice since you obviously have little to no clue. I've seen level 28 FS's with better builds.

 
Buxx
offline
Link
 
ive noticed
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.