User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania > Oceania AAA Power Rankings - Week 3
Page:
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
I'm sorry, the "SOV Rank" I've been referring to was your original post (I just gave it a name - Strength Of Victory - rather than calling it "the method in the original post" all the time).

For the "Production Rank" (another made up name) I used ...

1. Total Points Scored and Total Yardage Gained (Rushing + Passing). I ranked teams in each of the two categories, then combined the ranks and ranked them again for an overall offensive rank.

2. Total Points Allowed and Total Yardage Allowed (Rushing + Passing). Did the same with these, ranked teams 1-32 in each category, combined the rankings and re-ranked again for an overall defensive rank.

3. Took the overall offensive rank + the overall defensive rank and added it to your rankings in the original post to come up with a 3-rank combo score.


edit: so,

OFF_RK = RK(RK(TotPtsFor) + RK(TotYdsFor))
DEF_RK = RK(RK(TotPtsAll) + RK(TotYdsAll))

SCORE = OFF_RK + DEF_RK + SOV_RK


Clear as mud?

Last edited May 1, 2008 13:07:29
 
stevegamer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shutd0wn
That one is actually pretty cool and displays similar results like Ranking the Flying Foxes as the worst 2-1 team and putting the Sewer Rats up in the top 10 even though they're 1-2.


It's a big improvement, as the 2-1 teams are ahead of all the 0-3 teams.
 
DaSaintFan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stevegamer
Originally posted by shutd0wn

That one is actually pretty cool and displays similar results like Ranking the Flying Foxes as the worst 2-1 team and putting the Sewer Rats up in the top 10 even though they're 1-2.


It's a big improvement, as the 2-1 teams are ahead of all the 0-3 teams.


Gotta disagree (unless it really changes over the course of a season)... one bad game is going to screw you over big time, no matter if you're a 3-0 team or an 0-3 team.

 
stevegamer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DaSaintFan
Originally posted by stevegamer

Originally posted by shutd0wn


That one is actually pretty cool and displays similar results like Ranking the Flying Foxes as the worst 2-1 team and putting the Sewer Rats up in the top 10 even though they're 1-2.


It's a big improvement, as the 2-1 teams are ahead of all the 0-3 teams.


Gotta disagree (unless it really changes over the course of a season)... one bad game is going to screw you over big time, no matter if you're a 3-0 team or an 0-3 team.



It's a dynamic thing, so I'm sure it will change. My take on these things, is that if you haven't won anything after 3 games, you should be perceived as worse than teams who've won more than half of the games.

When the winless start winning, they will move up, and there be more to debate.
 
shutd0wn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stevegamer
It's a dynamic thing, so I'm sure it will change. My take on these things, is that if you haven't won anything after 3 games, you should be perceived as worse than teams who've won more than half of the games.

When the winless start winning, they will move up, and there be more to debate.


This is a power rankings though, not a "who has a better record".

We're calculating who you beat and who you lost to. Beating 0-1 and 0-2 teams is not as impressive as beating a 1-0 or 2-0 team.

The teams who beat the tougher oppenents will be ranked higher than the ones who beat nobodies. And the teams who lose to nobodies don't deserve to be ranked up there. The reason there are 0-3 teams ranked higher than a 2-1 is because those teams are getting smashed by teams alot better than them. Its not like they're losing to fellow 0-3 teams, which would then effect them greatly.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
I think half of the fun with these things is in looking at the transition points and overlap between record groups ... seeing how the 0-3's compare to the the 1-2's, etc. when you look at more than just wins & losses.

... of course, the other half of the fun is often in debating the ranking system itself .
 
IrishEyes
offline
Link
 
So, what you're saying is that regardless of what stats you use and independent of when it's run (now or at the 1/2 way point) the bottom line is my Port Moresby team sucks? Ok, got it. Thanks. Can't wait for the mid-year report...
 
shutd0wn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IrishEyes
So, what you're saying is that regardless of what stats you use and independent of when it's run (now or at the 1/2 way point) the bottom line is my Port Moresby team sucks? Ok, got it. Thanks. Can't wait for the mid-year report...


Dont see where anyone said that, but if its what you want to believe go for it
 
DaSaintFan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
... of course, the other half of the fun is often in debating the ranking system itself .


Very true.. but then again, I'm a huge fan of the Yards Per Point system.

1. The Bomb Squad 8.884615385
2. FFLW Caninites 12
3. So Cal BDC 13.64285714
4. Dunedin Beavers 15.13953488
5. Tonga Strikers 18.23134328
6. Tonga Ikale Tahi 18.62903226
7. Arctic Panthers 19.66428571
8. Utopia Kangaroos 19.828125
9. Samoa Flying Foxes 20.72321429
10. Port Moresby Demons 21.49122807
11. Cajun Crushers 21.6754386
12. Sth Queensland Crushers 22.33636364
13. Sydney Sharks 22.54901961
14. Toowoomba (OTF) Centurions 23.16964286
15. Gold Coast Crocs 23.79166667
16. Melbourne SWG 25.01136364
17. Barossa Grapestompers 26.23255814
18. PUMPED UP PISTONS 27.25925926
19. Newcastle Surfers 30
20. Avondell's Raiders 30.04285714
21. Oregon Flat Backers 32.43421053
22. Sparta Spartans 35.91935484
23. Springfield Sewer Rats 37.4
24. Canberra Stingers 38.875
25. Brantford Mustangs 38.97222222
26. Le Thor Bulls 47.1
27. Los Cabolo Sharks 49.32692308
28. Sydney Thunder 63.96875
29. District 5 Ducks 64.52631579
30. Fiji Storm 73.431818183
31. Sunshine Coast Wallabies 75.5
32. The Practice Squad 375.3333333

For instance, every time the Bomb Squad makes 8.88 yards in a game, give them one point.

Defensive YPP: (Number of yards you have to get against a defense to get 1 point)
1. Sydney Sharks 50.73333333
2. Brantford Mustangs 48.85714286
3. PUMPED UP PISTONS 47.5
4. Toowoomba (OTF) Centurions 39.76190476
5. Newcastle Surfers 34.01666667
6. FFLW Caninites 31.88888889
7. District 5 Ducks 29.85185185
8. Tonga Ikale Tahi 29.71428571
9. So Cal BDC 29.30952381
10. Sparta Spartans 26.63333333
11. Utopia Kangaroos 26.5
12. Sth Queensland Crushers 25.33333333
13. Cajun Crushers 25.14583333
14. Arctic Panthers 24.51666667
15. The Bomb Squad 22.59259259
16. Springfield Sewer Rats 22.10606061
17. Le Thor Bulls 19.77083333
18. Sunshine Coast Wallabies 19.25438596
19. Avondell's Raiders 18.44791667
20. Dunedin Beavers 18.36111111
21. Samoa Flying Foxes 18.32352941
22. Tonga Strikers 18.08333333
23. Sydney Thunder 18.08333333
24. Gold Coast Crocs 17.71052632
25. Canberra Stingers 16.94230769
26. Barossa Grapestompers 16.30833333
27. The Practice Squad 16.20512821
28. Oregon Flat Backers 15.85632184
29. Melbourne SWG 15.36363636
30. Los Cabolo Sharks 15.06521739
31. Port Moresby Demons 14.50694444
32. Fiji Storm 13.93434343

So if you were playing the Fiji storm, and you got 83.58 yards at any point in the game, you were assured of getting 6 points on the scoreboard...




So if you average 'em out... (I use this more for trying to pick NFL games more so than ranking teams, as an average kinda of narrows things down to far for rankings)

1. FFLW Caninites (3-0)
2. So Cal BDC (3-0)
3. Tonga Ikale Tahi (2-1)
Sydney Sharks (3-0)
5. The Bomb Squad (3-0)
6. Toowoomba (OTF) Centurions (2-1)
7. Utopia Kangaroos (2-1)
8. Arctic Panthers (3-0)
PUMPED UP PISTONS (3-0)
10. Dunedin Beavers (3-0)
Cajun Crushers (2-1)
Sth Queensland Crushers (2-0-1)
Newcastle Surfers (2-1-0)
14. Tonga Strikers (2-1-0)
Brantford Mustangs (3-0-0)
16. Samoa Flying Foxes (2-1-0)
17. Sparta Spartans (1-2-0)
18. District 5 Ducks (0-3-0)
19. Gold Coast Crocs (1-1-1)
Avondell's Raiders (0-3-0)
Springfield Sewer Rats (1-2-0)
22. Port Moresby Demons (1-2-0)
23 Barossa Grapestompers (0-3-0)
Le Thor Bulls (0-3-0)
25. Melbourne SWG (1-2-0)
26. Oregon Flat Backers (0-3-0)
Canberra Stingers (1-2-0)
Sunshine Coast Wallabies (1-2-0)
29. Sydney Thunder (0-3-0)
30. Los Cabolo Sharks (0-3-0)
31. The Practice Squad (0-3-0)
32. Fiji Storm (0-3-0)
Last edited May 1, 2008 17:37:26
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Hmmm ... that's interesting, not sure I'm following it, but it's interesting.
 
Mickgolden
offline
Link
 
Very interesting and surprising ranking system there SaintFan....I never would have guessed the Sharks were up there like that....
 
DaSaintFan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Hmmm ... that's interesting, not sure I'm following it, but it's interesting.


Basically, it's total yards/total points vs. Total Yards allowed/total points allowed.

So if a team such as the Sharks for instance, have a total of 50.333 YPP against average.. for you to score the equivalent of a Touchdown (6 points), they're going to force you to drive the field 3 times before they'll let you score.

50x6 = 300 / 100 = 3 times.

IF you go on the idea that teams will almost always start at the 20 (80 yard drive), then you actually have to drive the field
300/80 or 3.75 times before they'll let you score...

But again, i tend to use it for "point spreads".. so for instance.. IMO, the big game of the week is the Bomb squad vs. the Sharks... so if teams play "up to their usual standards"..

Step 1: Average Yards Per Game by the Bomb Squad + Average Yards Allowed Per Game by the Sharks / 2
(303.3 passing + 202.7 Rushing) + (Allows 166.8 Rushing + 37.5 passing) / 2
506.0 + 204.3 = 710.3/2 = 355.15 yards.
This should be how many yards the Bomb Squad get in this game.
Step 2: YPP by the Bomb Squad (8.88) + YPP by the Sharks (50.73) / 2 = 59.61/2 = 29.805 YPP total for the Squad

SO the Bomb Squad, if both games play up to their standards whoudl score 355.15/29.805 YPP or 11.91 points.

Now repeat the process for the Sharks:
(59.5 + 143.8) Yards the Bomb Squad allows per game + (167.2 + 121) Yards the Sharks get per game / 2
203.3 + 289.2 = 492.5/2 = 246.25 yards gained

22.54 YPP (Sharks) + 22.59 DYPP (Squad) = 45.13/2 = 22.57

246.25/22.57 = 10.91 points

So the prediction would be for the Bomb Squad to win by 1 point....(11.91 > 10.91).

It needs a few more weeks for it to fall into place, as things are still changing... (it tends for it to take 5 weeks to get close to keeping up with tendencies in the NFL...and even then, there are games in the NFL that completely screws it up

The practice has some flaws.. for instance if a team scores 0 points in week 1, and I try to use it, they''d NEVER score another point...
Last edited May 1, 2008 17:46:10
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
OK, I don't know how well it applies here, like you mentioned it's probably best used for other reasons than rankings, but I'm curious ... Why do you add the yards gained per game of one team to the yards allowed per game of the other and divide by two instead of subtracting the yards allowed from the yards gained?

And, once you feel like it's hitting stride (and of course if you have the time), you should post some point spreads for our games, that would be one more fun element for the AAA to go along with shutdown's ranking project and Haplos' Power 5.

 
DaSaintFan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
OK, I don't know how well it applies here, like you mentioned it's probably best used for other reasons than rankings, but I'm curious ... Why do you add the yards gained per game of one team to the yards allowed per game of the other and divide by two instead of subtracting the yards allowed from the yards gained?


Basically the general idea is that TEAM A is going to give up some yards... it's just a question of how many, compared with how many TEAM B is usually going to score. If you have a TEAM A that basically allows fewer yards total than TEAM B usually gets, then if you did a subtraction: Team A yardage would be negative, even if both teams were "high" on their respective charts.

Let's just say Team A only allows 280 yards per game.. but Team B gets 300 on average per game. Now do I go with Team B is going to only gain 20 yards per game (Playing better than A) or will they have a total of -20 yards per game (playing worse than A).

So if both teams play up to par, Team B's total will possibly come down, but by 10 yards (and should get 290 yards).

I've got the excel spreadsheet at work for the whole thing.. I just forgot to mail it to myself today for the games on Sunday.
OH WAIT.. i might be able to get it in time for this weeks games!! (We'll try it tonight!)

My pride of the whole thing was when I used it to predict college conferences: And the last year that Northwestern and Wisconsin each won the Big 10 (respectively), I nailed those predictions dead on... (But it has a lot more requirements for me to make those kind of predictions *grin*)
Last edited May 1, 2008 18:03:21
 
stevegamer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shutd0wn
Originally posted by stevegamer

It's a dynamic thing, so I'm sure it will change. My take on these things, is that if you haven't won anything after 3 games, you should be perceived as worse than teams who've won more than half of the games.

When the winless start winning, they will move up, and there be more to debate.


This is a power rankings though, not a "who has a better record".

We're calculating who you beat and who you lost to. Beating 0-1 and 0-2 teams is not as impressive as beating a 1-0 or 2-0 team.

The teams who beat the tougher oppenents will be ranked higher than the ones who beat nobodies. And the teams who lose to nobodies don't deserve to be ranked up there. The reason there are 0-3 teams ranked higher than a 2-1 is because those teams are getting smashed by teams alot better than them. Its not like they're losing to fellow 0-3 teams, which would then effect them greatly.


I hear you, but until you beat someone, anyone, you are a complete nobody. And that's an issue with rankings that come out early when it's too early to tell.

I think beating an 0-3 team is generally more impressive than losing. It's why I suggested the slight tweak involving the rounding, and a very slight reward for a win.

The difference between 0.333 & 0.334 is essenitally none, and at this time, the margin of error is significant, but the rankings don't have all those teams as essentially the same. At a variance of .001, take the 2-1 team over the 0-3 team as being "better".

More time will help this, though, as might breaking up the conferences.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.