Does anyone have a sense as to whether the First Step SA overrides the vision delay, or whether it only comes into play after the delay?
grugnur
offline
offline
in any football game you can expect a few plays that are out of the ordinary... but the defensive line has been nerfed to the point that it is non-existent... if we are promoting the glory positions then it's good business sense... if we are making a game where everybody has fun, it's shaky
Last edited Nov 19, 2008 07:43:44
Gyuri1
offline
offline
Originally posted by chief31
I see. So 47/100 on VISION should make for a perfect jump on the snap count on every play.
Ok. Just as long as my OTs 47 AGILITY ensures that he will never bet blown-by from a DE.
I think the issue that Voltron is pointing out is that if 47 vision only occasionally gets you a 1-tick reduction of the 3-tick delay, then it makes spending points in vision fairly inefficient. If, for example, a DE's vision is currently at 20, then spending 28 SPs to get to the 2:1 threshold which will only sometimes yield a slightly shorter delay may be a worse way to spend SPs than to put them into First Step or Tunnel Vision (30 SPs will get you from 0 to 10 in any of the relevant SAs), or to put them into speed or agility (where, if you are just at the 4:1 threshold, you can use 29 SPs to get 7 attribute points).
I see. So 47/100 on VISION should make for a perfect jump on the snap count on every play.
Ok. Just as long as my OTs 47 AGILITY ensures that he will never bet blown-by from a DE.
I think the issue that Voltron is pointing out is that if 47 vision only occasionally gets you a 1-tick reduction of the 3-tick delay, then it makes spending points in vision fairly inefficient. If, for example, a DE's vision is currently at 20, then spending 28 SPs to get to the 2:1 threshold which will only sometimes yield a slightly shorter delay may be a worse way to spend SPs than to put them into First Step or Tunnel Vision (30 SPs will get you from 0 to 10 in any of the relevant SAs), or to put them into speed or agility (where, if you are just at the 4:1 threshold, you can use 29 SPs to get 7 attribute points).
Last edited Nov 19, 2008 07:55:29
PackMan97
offline
offline
I think the biggest issue in this is that the OL has no delay. Even when they know the snap count, sometimes crowd noise, jitters, inattentiveness, whatever causes the OL to be slow off the ball...especially if it's a silent snap count.
Why not give the OL a chance at a delay that the DL can on a rare occasion, beat?
OL = 0-1.5 tick delay
DL = 0.5-3 tick delay
...or something like that. On a perfect snap read by both, OL wins by a hair, even on a very good read by the D they will only beat a poor read by the OL. I don't think any is asking for the defense to ALWAYS get the jump, they just don't want the offense always being perfect.
Why not give the OL a chance at a delay that the DL can on a rare occasion, beat?
OL = 0-1.5 tick delay
DL = 0.5-3 tick delay
...or something like that. On a perfect snap read by both, OL wins by a hair, even on a very good read by the D they will only beat a poor read by the OL. I don't think any is asking for the defense to ALWAYS get the jump, they just don't want the offense always being perfect.
tjsexkitten82
offline
offline
Originally posted by PackMan97
I think the biggest issue in this is that the OL has no delay. Even when they know the snap count, sometimes crowd noise, jitters, inattentiveness, whatever causes the OL to be slow off the ball...especially if it's a silent snap count.
Why not give the OL a chance at a delay that the DL can on a rare occasion, beat?
OL = 0-1.5 tick delay
DL = 0.5-3 tick delay
...or something like that. On a perfect snap read by both, OL wins by a hair, even on a very good read by the D they will only beat a poor read by the OL. I don't think any is asking for the defense to ALWAYS get the jump, they just don't want the offense always being perfect.
I agree. OTs and OGs should always have a 1 tick delay, as they have to hear the snap count. The DL can watch for movement, so their delay should be more vision based, and from 1-2 ticks imo. So best vision DEs see movement from the QB/C before the OT starts to move, and get off at same time as OTs. Terrible vision means most DEs wait until the OT moves, and only get off a tick later.
I think the biggest issue in this is that the OL has no delay. Even when they know the snap count, sometimes crowd noise, jitters, inattentiveness, whatever causes the OL to be slow off the ball...especially if it's a silent snap count.
Why not give the OL a chance at a delay that the DL can on a rare occasion, beat?
OL = 0-1.5 tick delay
DL = 0.5-3 tick delay
...or something like that. On a perfect snap read by both, OL wins by a hair, even on a very good read by the D they will only beat a poor read by the OL. I don't think any is asking for the defense to ALWAYS get the jump, they just don't want the offense always being perfect.
I agree. OTs and OGs should always have a 1 tick delay, as they have to hear the snap count. The DL can watch for movement, so their delay should be more vision based, and from 1-2 ticks imo. So best vision DEs see movement from the QB/C before the OT starts to move, and get off at same time as OTs. Terrible vision means most DEs wait until the OT moves, and only get off a tick later.
Last edited Nov 19, 2008 09:13:04
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























