User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
tycoon34
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by itsme4
think hell just froze over a bit when you referred to noodle arm Chad Pennington as "decent"


noodle arm chad pennington is the most efficient passer in NFL history. I'd call that decent.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by itsme4
think hell just froze over a bit when you referred to noodle arm Chad Pennington as "decent"


Long ball he sucks... Short quick passes that keep drives alive, he's great. That makes him a decent passer. I'd throw him in the same ball park as Favre. He's got a long ball, but he can't throw it without getting it INTed which is why he holds the record for most INTs in NFL history. But, when he throws a short pass he throws a lazer.
 
itsme420
offline
Link
 
he is very average. look at his career #'s. He's had injuries and only thrown for more than 20 TD's once since 2000.

granted he didn't have much to work with in NY and being in Miami has given him a chance to make some noise. But the only way he's getting into Canton is if he buys a ticket!!
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by itsme4
he is very average. look at his career #'s. He's had injuries and only thrown for more than 20 TD's once since 2000.

granted he didn't have much to work with in NY and being in Miami has given him a chance to make some noise. But the only way he's getting into Canton is if he buys a ticket!!


I never said he was great or hall of famer... I said he was decent, not sure where the breakdown is coming. He's no Dan Marino that's for sure. However he's helped turn this team around while under Bill Parcells.
 
Tentitans
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
I'd throw him in the same ball park as Favre.


Thats when I stopped reading.

 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tentitans
Originally posted by Schaffer05

I'd throw him in the same ball park as Favre.


Thats when I stopped reading.



 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tentitans
Originally posted by Schaffer05

I'd throw him in the same ball park as Favre.


Thats when I stopped reading.



Favre is over rated. He's not the all star that Green Bay made him out to be... Which is why he had SEVERAL horrible seasona before he finally had a good one. He owns the INT record, is he really that good?
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by Tentitans

Originally posted by Schaffer05


I'd throw him in the same ball park as Favre.


Thats when I stopped reading.



Favre is over rated. He's not the all star that Green Bay made him out to be... Which is why he had SEVERAL horrible seasona before he finally had a good one. He owns the INT record, is he really that good?


He's not as good as Madden believes him to be. But Pennington is still not on Favre's level either. Remove the fan glasses and re-think it.

Pennington is not a bad QB, however.
 
itsme420
offline
Link
 
In hindsight, I guess "not bad" does equal "decent"
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by panther17


He's not as good as Madden believes him to be. But Pennington is still not on Favre's level either. Remove the fan glasses and re-think it.

Pennington is not a bad QB, however.


I'm a Phins fan, but I'm not a Pennington fan. I don't think he's great, don't think he's really all that good, but he is damn accurate on those short throws. Favre is good, but not great either. I don't think Pennington is on the same level as Favre, but I also don't think you can compare them because Pennington has never had the team Favre had to work with, so he's not been able to prove himself.
 
SouthernPride
offline
Link
 
they both suck. but im extremely partial to Matt Schuab and Tony Romo
 
Tentitans
offline
Link
 
Vince Young still a god to UT fans?
 
DotWars
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tentitans
Originally posted by Schaffer05

I'd throw him in the same ball park as Favre.


Thats when I stopped reading.



+1
 
DotWars
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by panther17



He's not as good as Madden believes him to be. But Pennington is still not on Favre's level either. Remove the fan glasses and re-think it.

Pennington is not a bad QB, however.


I'm a Phins fan, but I'm not a Pennington fan. I don't think he's great, don't think he's really all that good, but he is damn accurate on those short throws. Favre is good, but not great either. I don't think Pennington is on the same level as Favre, but I also don't think you can compare them because Pennington has never had the team Favre had to work with, so he's not been able to prove himself.


How much talent did Green Bay put around him none. The only wr he has ever had was Sterling Sharpe and that was short lived. He made all those teams if you don't believe that go look at the games, did he lose some games because of his gunners mentality you bet, but he won way more than he lost playing his style. Farve is in the top ten of QBs of all time.

By the way I am a Viking fan, and I hate the Packers.
 
SouthernPride
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tentitans
Vince Young still a god to UT fans?


Vince was somethin special at UT. And every Horns fan i know roots for him in the NFL. its kinda a shame what happened too him. im sure he will get a chance either with the titans or elsewhere next season. But honestly, i think Colt McCoy is makin a lot of UT fans forget all about Vince.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.