User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Laying in the Team AI (Also Solves League Parity)
Page:
 
Lucius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Oh there's more. The logic that a 35 level LB will shy away from A league's because the DEF AI won't get him his sacks? By that logic, the same league's offensive AI won't be able to plan proper pass protection. It's a wash.


No it isn't. Basic AI doesn't allow for fancy LBer blitzes. You just play football, at a more basic level. No trick plays, etc. It's like, you know, playing at a lower level.

If done correctly, it would simulate a major reason star NFLers don't go play in the CFL for fun. The game is different and the coaches might not have the ability to use them most effectively.

It wouldn't solve the parity issue, but it would help. Proper financial systems would solve the parity issue. The fact that my AA (was A last year) team has 25 million in the bank and a maxed out stadium next year tells you all you need to know about what's wrong with the game's finances


Originally posted by didymus
Oh wait, there's more. I played 2 seasons before I got my team and acted as GM prior as well. I would have been handcuffed as to what I could or couldn't try?

I am confident that nothing like this will ever be considered.


My only point about older players is that I think we're seeing a rapid decline in intelligent owners as a result of all the confusion. The reason is that older owners effectively played under this system. We had basic AI, then advanced, etc. We get a little more each year, thus there are more of us who better understand it.

When you hit people with it all at once, you lose a lot of potential long term customers by overwhelming them.

I am almost 100% certain that if I'd bought my team in Season 6, I'd have immediately sold it back. I wouldn't have time, the knowledgeable friends, or the know-how to do it. Yet, I am an owner who puts a lot of money in this game because I was able to learn over time.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 00:20:19
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Oh there's more. The logic that a 35 level LB will shy away from A league's because the DEF AI won't get him his sacks? By that logic, the same league's offensive AI won't be able to plan proper pass protection. It's a wash.

Oh wait, there's more. I played 2 seasons before I got my team and acted as GM prior as well. I would have been handcuffed as to what I could or couldn't try?

I am confident that nothing like this will ever be considered.


Bort has stated many times the reason equip costs are so high is so a bottom league team can't afford the highest leveled players.

And if a player is super worried about stats, he's not there for the team.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Wow, and I thought I had covered everything.

You want to make sure the owners who work hard don't achieve any additional success.


You're making ridiculously vague comments. Please elaborate, or discussion is completely pointless.
 
Lucius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Wow, and I thought I had covered everything.

You want to make sure the owners who work hard don't achieve any additional success.


This keeps getting better.


As the poster above said, that makes no sense.

If I was suggesting the level of AI be based on your registration date, I'd see your point, but that is NOT what I am suggesting. It would be the same for everyone in the same league. All BBB would be the same, etc. The best team would still win in each league.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 00:26:35
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by didymus

Wow, and I thought I had covered everything.

You want to make sure the owners who work hard don't achieve any additional success.


You're making ridiculously vague comments. Please elaborate, or discussion is completely pointless.



Reference to post at 00:08:48

"It's not demeaning. I am not saying new players CANNOT grasp it. I am saying that new players should not be forced to grasp it. It's a 32 team league. In every league, if all options are there, someone WILL grasp it and win"

 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lucius

If I was suggesting the level of AI be based on your registration date, I'd see your point. It would be the same for everyone in the same league. The best team would still win in each league.


See and I don't like that.

I've been here since Season 2 Day like 3, and I've yet to play with anything past basic AI.

I'm looking into getting a team next season, and I'd like to learn how to use it, but due to my ADD nature I'll probably miss out on ALOT of things.

Learning gradually would be nice.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Originally posted by Knick

Originally posted by didymus


Wow, and I thought I had covered everything.

You want to make sure the owners who work hard don't achieve any additional success.


You're making ridiculously vague comments. Please elaborate, or discussion is completely pointless.

Reference to post at 00:08:48

"It's not demeaning. I am not saying new players CANNOT grasp it. I am saying that new players should not be forced to grasp it. It's a 32 team league. In every league, if all options are there, someone WILL grasp it and win"


Stressing the importance of OWNERS knowing how to do things vs just delegating out.
An owner who only pays for a team is 1 step above a trophy whore GM.
 
Lucius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Originally posted by Knick

Originally posted by didymus


Wow, and I thought I had covered everything.

You want to make sure the owners who work hard don't achieve any additional success.


You're making ridiculously vague comments. Please elaborate, or discussion is completely pointless.



Reference to post at 00:08:48

"It's not demeaning. I am not saying new players CANNOT grasp it. I am saying that new players should not be forced to grasp it. It's a 32 team league. In every league, if all options are there, someone WILL grasp it and win"



What's your point?

The game forces all new owners to grasp concepts that only a small percentage of them have the time, energy or ability to do on day one. Yet, this system FORCES them to do it or they have no chance at success.

I suspect Bort would like more than a 1 or 2 in 32 retention rate among new owners.
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Learn gradually by GMing before you buy a team.

If any person thinks they are in a position to determine what someone else can or can't manage to do, then I do not have a polite word for them.


It must be accepted that any person wanting to own a team wants to run that team to the best of his ability. Any owner at any time may choose the base settings and let it be.

To intentionally deprive GLB participants is an awful idea.

Edit:
So now 30 of 32 owners are going to quit because the AI is too hard?
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 00:32:48
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Learn gradually by GMing before you buy a team.

If any person thinks they are in a position to determine what someone else can or can't manage to do, then I do not have a polite word for them.


It must be accepted that any person wanting to own a team wants to run that team to the best of his ability. Any owner at any time may choose the base settings and let it be.

To intentionally deprive GLB participants is an awful idea.


I see where you're coming from. But with the lack of actual GUIDES and threats such as malicious GM's, I think this would be nice.
 
Lucius
offline
Link
 
It's not depriving anyone of anything.

It's a progression system. Every MMO has them, including this one.

Right now, we all make what is the equivalent to "level 50" teams. We can do whatever. By your logic, we should all roll players with 500 skill points to assign, because not to do so is to deprive players of the ability to cap their speed.

I just think it should be extended to the teams. Why do you have to progress as a player, but get all the tools instantly as a team.

Instead of giving teams level and experience, which would be another mechanism to accomplish the same goal I have here, you make the league their level. That's all I'm suggesting. An alternative version would be to give teams XP for wins, etc. and make more options unlock as you get more XP.

Telling someone if they want to learn to apprentice on another team is not immediately obvious to new players and means lost players.

Telling someone to use the basic AI is absurd. If they do, they WILL lose to someone who is using the advanced AI. That means that learning one step at a time is a guarantee for failure.

Anyway, that's my last try on you, I suspect you and I will never agree on this one
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 00:35:44
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Personality wise, I do not have any patience for this training wheel approach.

Throw the damn kid in the water and make him swim.

I made a ton of mistakes with the AI my first year. My punting was screwed up, and other crap. I got burned bad but that is how you learn. Pre-season and friendlys. Study, work hard. If you screw the pooch with your AI, it will blow up in your face and your players are gonna wonder why your going for it from your own 1.

Baby pampering new owners isn't doing them any favors. Coddling only sets them up for failure later. I happen to have more respect for my fellow GLB'ers determination and will to succeed.

The most realistic damn think at GLB is the effort required at the owner / coach level.
 
VenomCoach
offline
Link
 
Same here if I didn't get enough control I wouldn't be an owner or GM.
 
Lucius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Personality wise, I do not have any patience for this training wheel approach.

Throw the damn kid in the water and make him swim.


Right, which is a very fair point.

The question is, which group does GLB ultimately need to appeal to?

They can cater to the hardcore base, like yourself, or they can risk annoying that base to reach a broader audience and perhaps bring more people into the game.

That's the absolute toughest thing for them to balance, it's not an easy decision by any means. You have to be very careful, if they go too extreme in either direction, it blows up. However, I think the above's biggest flaw is that it wasn't like this from the start and if it was going to be the way I am suggesting, it likely should have been from day one. Nonetheless, they do call it beta
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
I truly believe the owner who is going to be overwhelmed his first year, is better off for it. He will be that much smarter his second year.

He might not like struggling and bearing it out. But he will be thankful afterwards.



Pain is weakness leaving the body.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.