User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Control Over Timeouts, Part Deux
Page:
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
What happened to that other thread? I was asking for the logic you'd like to see in there. Guess it got bumped.


It got lost. Since forum search doesn't work, I started a new one with yesterday's game results.

People would rather post in the Who's The Biggest Attention Whore in GLB? thread than one that affects their games.

I had to just get this one back on the first page.



Originally posted by seayjoel
Still the timeouts have always been here this is the first time we've seen them


Yeah, we read that when Bort typed it before. But since half the games were meaningless, there was less a chance of it affecting the outcome of a game.

Some leagues are a little more competitive now. This could make a big difference in a game.

Last edited Nov 16, 2008 21:28:42
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Hm, well the question still stands:

If you had the options in AI of "time remaining," "quarter," "timeouts left," and "score difference," what would you set them to for a good default? Even if I add the option to the AI to allow for setting when to call timeouts, I still need to come up with some settings for the people using basic settings.
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
Leave it like it is for default. Let GMs figure out what to do for themselves.

 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Say 2nd Q I get the ball on my own 15 with 90 seconds remaining. All I want to do is run the clock out to get to halftime. Currently I cant because the AI takes my 3 timeouts.
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
If you want to make a basic improvement for the people who don't really care about owning a team, I guess you could take into account....

Score difference doesn't matter in the second quarter. You have the ball, and you should try to score.

Save one timeout for a FG attempt.

You can probably wait to call timeouts for the final minute in GLB.

Use whatever you use now for the fourth quarter.


Beyond that, make GMs figure out if they call a timeout on their own 40 yard line with only two remaining and 50 seconds left in the half.

Good coaches will manage the clock well. Bad ones will mess up.

 
AirMcMVP
Mod
offline
Link
 
One thing that really annoys me is how the third timeout is used. The first, fine...use it on the first play where the clock in running after the 2 minute warning. The second...ok, I can see calling it when the clock is running after the first TO.

The third, however, should be held for a last second FG attempt. There's nothing more frustrating than having to set your AI to kick a FG inside 40 second if you're in range just to make sure you get the attempt in.
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
Or you could default it to not use timeouts at all in the second quarter and leave the fourth quarter settings at what you have now.


I'm just saying give us control over them. At least it will be the coach's fault and not the simulator.

Last edited Nov 16, 2008 21:12:11
 
navytexas1
offline
Link
 
when something is broken you fix? Now is it Broke? or is it FIXed is the game fair and = for new players to have chance to start fresh and win. I KNOW BORT not Leting same boring teams win season after season. so what is broke that needs fixed? I dont get your question ?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Hm, well the question still stands:

If you had the options in AI of "time remaining," "quarter," "timeouts left," and "score difference," what would you set them to for a good default? Even if I add the option to the AI to allow for setting when to call timeouts, I still need to come up with some settings for the people using basic settings.


Time: <=2:00 in 2nd Quarter

Yardline (at least):
If down by more than one score: OWN 30
If down by one score or less: OWN 40
If up: OWN 50

Down:
1st-3rd
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 00:03:24
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Bort

Hm, well the question still stands:

If you had the options in AI of "time remaining," "quarter," "timeouts left," and "score difference," what would you set them to for a good default? Even if I add the option to the AI to allow for setting when to call timeouts, I still need to come up with some settings for the people using basic settings.


Time: <=2:00 in 2nd Quarter

Yardline (at least):
If down by more than one score: OWN 30
If down by one score or less: OWN 40
If up: OWN 50

Down:
1st-3rd


one score = 3 pts or 6?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by Bort


Hm, well the question still stands:

If you had the options in AI of "time remaining," "quarter," "timeouts left," and "score difference," what would you set them to for a good default? Even if I add the option to the AI to allow for setting when to call timeouts, I still need to come up with some settings for the people using basic settings.


Time: <=2:00 in 2nd Quarter

Yardline (at least):
If down by more than one score: OWN 30
If down by one score or less: OWN 40
If up: OWN 50

Down:
1st-3rd


one score = 3 pts or 6?


In the second quarter: 3
Forth quarter:6

Basically, this avoids doing what my team did today. That is, calling timeouts from your OWN 1 with :36 left in the half. Plus, it lets teams with the lead, any lead, and good field position, have a chance to add another score with reasonably little risk.

Also, "Time" should probably be (in the second quarter) <=2:00, >:20 or something there abouts. That prevents the useless, "no gain, possible turnover" timeout calls with :02 on the clock on your own 40. Obviously, in the 4th, there is no min. time.
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 00:13:48
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Ok, i'm going to write some sorta-code here for Q2 to flesh out the logic:


if (quarter == 2 && down <= 3 && time > 20 && time <= 120 && i_have_ball()) {

if (score_difference <= -3 && within(own 30)) {
timeout();
}
else if (score_difference < 0 && within(own 40)) {
timeout();
}
else if (score_difference > 0 && within(50)) {
timeout();
}

}

seems about right for your suggestion VT (assuming you can decipher that LOL)? What about when you're tied?
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 00:26:15
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
Ok, so you've got something for basic users.

Can we expect control over timeouts for the rest of us?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, i'm going to write some sorta-code here for Q2 to flesh out the logic:


if (quarter == 2 && down <= 3 && time > 20 && time <= 120 && i_have_ball()) {

if (score_difference <= -3 && within(own 30)) {
timeout();
}
else if (score_difference < 0 && within(own 40)) {
timeout();
}
else if (score_difference > 0 && within(50)) {
timeout();
}

}

seems about right for your suggestion VT (assuming you can decipher that LOL)? What about when you're tied?


Well, based on what little I can read of programming speak (admittedly very little), it looks pretty close to correct.

As for being tied, assuming that we're still on the "what-to-do-for-those-using-basic-AI" topic, then I would suggest erring on the side of caution and not calling time outs.

If they'd rather not take it to the locker room, then they'll use the Adv. AI.

I suppose you could get really cute and determine it based on who scored last, as that would ostensibly equal momentum, but I'd recommend against that in favor of the simple approach above.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gott
Ok, so you've got something for basic users.

Can we expect control over timeouts for the rest of us?


Not immediately. I'll have to figure out the best way to add it to the interface. Since calling a timeout isn't a "play call," it might have to be its own separate thing.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.