User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
OUTLAW77
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hemprobot
This is a problem with having the wrong settings, not of the setting being deletede on save. Completely separate issue.


The issue is with the AI..period
any attention brought up about the AI is an issue
 
merlin olsen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SunsDbacksCardsFan
Simple answer, learn how to build a good one.


again...this is not our real AI this was just something we wanted to
try. Why am i responding to trolls? ugh
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
Were your settings the exact ones I listed? If they were and if the Input was set correctly and if the QB Draw play was in your playbook it should have done it 100% of the time.

I don't think it would have worked anyway though.
 
merlin olsen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hemprobot
The Devil is in the details dude. I'm not prepared to spend all day exchanging posts with you when 2 minutes looking at your AI, if you wanted to let me see it, would do.


let you see our AI? how do you propose that? I pretty much told you how it was set.
Nevermind people i found the problems...it was in the playbook...the
outside QB runs were taken out. An oversight...thanks for the input
to those of you that werent being total flametards...
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
Not really man, you weren't even close to specific enough. For example, you may have been using outputs that are broken, such as random run, which would cause issues like you described.

And you would let someone look at your Ai by making them a GM temporarily. No offence intended whatsoever but it's not like I would be stealing the idea or anything, given I know it doesn't work. Personally I've probably helped 30-40 people in such a way but many don't like to give up the access for some reason, which is fair enough, nut in truth makes it impossible to help people. How can you know where to start without having a proper example of how much someone knows?
 
merlin olsen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hemprobot
Not really man, you weren't even close to specific enough. For example, you may have been using outputs that are broken, such as random run, which would cause issues like you described.

And you would let someone look at your Ai by making them a GM temporarily. No offence intended whatsoever but it's not like I would be stealing the idea or anything, given I know it doesn't work. Personally I've probably helped 30-40 people in such a way but many don't like to give up the access for some reason, which is fair enough, nut in truth makes it impossible to help people. How can you know where to start without having a proper example of how much someone knows?


understood, and if it was something we didnt solve i dont think the owner
would mind granting temp access i just thought maybe you wanted a screen shot or
something... anyways thanks for trying to help. I understand that it can be difficult to solve problems without direct access to things..I am a software engineer and frequently
asked to solve problems over the phone or via email..no fun!

Also where did you get the 50 percent penalty from HB to QB? that seems drastic. Its not uncommon for HBs to throw the ball on trick plays or backup QBs in HS etc..And certainly
there have been QBs at the pro level that could have been HBs.

As to whether or not it could work...well we may try in a friendly for the sake of
academics but doubtful we'll do it in a real game again

 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merlin olsen
Originally posted by hemprobot

Not really man, you weren't even close to specific enough. For example, you may have been using outputs that are broken, such as random run, which would cause issues like you described.

And you would let someone look at your Ai by making them a GM temporarily. No offence intended whatsoever but it's not like I would be stealing the idea or anything, given I know it doesn't work. Personally I've probably helped 30-40 people in such a way but many don't like to give up the access for some reason, which is fair enough, nut in truth makes it impossible to help people. How can you know where to start without having a proper example of how much someone knows?


understood, and if it was something we didnt solve i dont think the owner
would mind granting temp access i just thought maybe you wanted a screen shot or
something... anyways thanks for trying to help. I understand that it can be difficult to solve problems without direct access to things..I am a software engineer and frequently
asked to solve problems over the phone or via email..no fun!

Also where did you get the 50 percent penalty from HB to QB? that seems drastic. Its not uncommon for HBs to throw the ball on trick plays or backup QBs in HS etc..And certainly
there have been QBs at the pro level that could have been HBs.

As to whether or not it could work...well we may try in a friendly for the sake of
academics but doubtful we'll do it in a real game again



From the mouth of Bort -- any position playing QB (other than a QB) takes a massive attribute hit. Similarly, a QB playing anywhere else takes a massive hit.
 
merlin olsen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by merlin olsen

Originally posted by hemprobot


Not really man, you weren't even close to specific enough. For example, you may have been using outputs that are broken, such as random run, which would cause issues like you described.

And you would let someone look at your Ai by making them a GM temporarily. No offence intended whatsoever but it's not like I would be stealing the idea or anything, given I know it doesn't work. Personally I've probably helped 30-40 people in such a way but many don't like to give up the access for some reason, which is fair enough, nut in truth makes it impossible to help people. How can you know where to start without having a proper example of how much someone knows?


understood, and if it was something we didnt solve i dont think the owner
would mind granting temp access i just thought maybe you wanted a screen shot or
something... anyways thanks for trying to help. I understand that it can be difficult to solve problems without direct access to things..I am a software engineer and frequently
asked to solve problems over the phone or via email..no fun!

Also where did you get the 50 percent penalty from HB to QB? that seems drastic. Its not uncommon for HBs to throw the ball on trick plays or backup QBs in HS etc..And certainly
there have been QBs at the pro level that could have been HBs.

As to whether or not it could work...well we may try in a friendly for the sake of
academics but doubtful we'll do it in a real game again



From the mouth of Bort -- any position playing QB (other than a QB) takes a massive attribute hit. Similarly, a QB playing anywhere else takes a massive hit.


Thanks, now that is something i didnt know, but it caused me to remember an offseason
scrim we had to play between QBs :
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=207149

Yes thats our kicker at QB...and he had a game alot of glb QBs would be jealous of
 
BRAWLER
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SunsDbacksCardsFan
Simple answer, learn how to build a good one.


haha you gm three teams thats got smoked with your good built AI as we had with one the didnt work at all..
I think you should try not to be so internet tough .. sweetie.
To those off you with sincere interest we hope that we can help with anything that we have done wrong or that maybe wrong as we learn.
Last edited Nov 15, 2008 21:43:35
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.