User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
broadwayg
offline
Link
 
That and it's not even a penalty in the first place.
 
gbnk82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by E-A-G-L-E-S
A blocker in the NFL cannot progress past the LOS on a downfield passing play.

In college, the linemen can progress as far forward as they want, but if a lineman progresses past the line, than the pass must be caught behind him.



they have a box which is two yards past the line of scrimage they can not cross so a lineman can go 2 yards upfield but no more on a pass paly
 
gbnk82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by broadwayg
That and it's not even a penalty in the first place.



actaully there are 2 penalties on that play illeigal man upfield and offensive pass interfernce..you cant block a guy in coverage outside the box it is the same for defensse you cnat tougch the guy after the 5 yard jam area or it is pebalty same goes for offense so yes it is a penalty and it would have been a negative 15 yeard and loss of down situation
 
broadwayg
offline
Link
 
The CB wasn't in coverage, he was on a blitz. The block occurred about .5 yards past the LoS if that. Chiggity check the play again. Still no penalty.
 
gbnk82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by broadwayg
The CB wasn't in coverage, he was on a blitz. The block occurred about .5 yards past the LoS if that. Chiggity check the play again. Still no penalty.


ok still 5 yards doiwn field a linamn in pass protection is only alowed 2 tards down field and the tackle would pick up the blitz and the gaurd would transition to the defensive end or the half back or full back would pick him up so either way you look at it it is a penalty and the offensive line screwed up on assignments
 
broadwayg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gbnk82
Originally posted by broadwayg

The CB wasn't in coverage, he was on a blitz. The block occurred about .5 yards past the LoS if that. Chiggity check the play again. Still no penalty.


ok still 5 yards doiwn field a linamn in pass protection is only alowed 2 tards down field and the tackle would pick up the blitz and the gaurd would transition to the defensive end or the half back or full back would pick him up so either way you look at it it is a penalty and the offensive line screwed up on assignments


Dude, the LOS was the 49.5. The block occured at the 49. That's half a yard downfield. What's up with your 2 tards down field? Still no penalty. It's ok to admit you're wrong.

As far as why the G picked up the blitz, I don't know about that, but that's a totally different issue unrelated to the whole penalty non-issue.
 
gbnk82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by broadwayg
Originally posted by gbnk82

Originally posted by broadwayg


The CB wasn't in coverage, he was on a blitz. The block occurred about .5 yards past the LoS if that. Chiggity check the play again. Still no penalty.


ok still 5 yards doiwn field a linamn in pass protection is only alowed 2 tards down field and the tackle would pick up the blitz and the gaurd would transition to the defensive end or the half back or full back would pick him up so either way you look at it it is a penalty and the offensive line screwed up on assignments


Dude, the LOS was the 49.5. The block occured at the 49. That's half a yard downfield. What's up with your 2 tards down field? Still no penalty. It's ok to admit you're wrong.

As far as why the G picked up the blitz, I don't know about that, but that's a totally different issue unrelated to the whole penalty non-issue.



haha my bad i meant to say yards..i said 5 yards because just in your last post you said 5 yards donw field

The block occurred about .5 yards past the LoS

thats where i got it..i dont know how far it was exactly i couldnt tell on the computer it looked to me to be more like 3 yards past the los either way it doesnt really matter because there are no penalties so it isnt worth arguing



edit sorry i just noticed in that post there was a . and you said .5 yards my mistake i thought you said 5 yards donwfeild
Last edited May 1, 2008 10:18:47
 
VikesRule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IronMike
You guys are missing the point "The right guard runs down to block a CB on this play past the line of scrimmage." the fact is penalties are not in the game now so it doesn't matter who know more about football penalties or at what level they are applied. The truth of the matter is they are not in the game which is why O-lineman could do that if they wanted. End of discussion.


That's not the point of this, though. Yes, penalties are not in the game. But this is more of a question of would it be a penalty or not.

In my opinion, because it occurred so close to the LOS, the player (in real life, of course) would not have been called for inelligble receiver downfield.

Obviously a lineman cannot possibly know exactly where the LOS is at all times and the refs can't just call him for merely being a few inches or a few feet past the line, the only time that this gets called is if it's really blatant.

And, because the CB was blitzing, he really wasn't trying to go block someone who was in coverage. The inelligible receiver downfield penalty is implemented to prevent downfield blocking on a pass play when a lineman could affect the coverage.

In this example, the lineman did not have any intent to block a defender in coverage and was close enough to the LOS that it probably would not have been called (and if he got called for it, so would the TE, who was also blocking the CB).
 
VikesRule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gbnk82
Originally posted by broadwayg

That and it's not even a penalty in the first place.



actaully there are 2 penalties on that play illeigal man upfield and offensive pass interfernce..you cant block a guy in coverage outside the box it is the same for defensse you cnat tougch the guy after the 5 yard jam area or it is pebalty same goes for offense so yes it is a penalty and it would have been a negative 15 yeard and loss of down situation


I don't see offensive pass interference in this play. That is rarely called, and when it is, its usually quite obvious. This play the ball was thrown short and to the right, where there was really no defender even close to the ball. The fact that the pass occurred so quickly didn't really even give the defender a chance to make a play on the ball.

Perhaps you've heard the term "uncatchable" when referring to times when a defender is not called for PI because the ball was deemed to be thrown in a way that the receiver did not have a chance to catch the ball even if he had not been interfered with. The same thing would occur here for this defender. He had no chance to catch that ball, even if he had not been interfered with (which, in this case, he was being blocked legally).

Furthermore, the ball doesn't really travel past the LOS, so any blocking upfield would have actually been legal. For the sake of argument, though, let's say the ball did travel past the LOS. I still don't think you would get an Offensive PI called by one of the two players blocking the CB (which is what I assume you want to call the PI on, because it doesn't occur anywhere else).

And last but not least, the PI and illegal man downfield penalties would not result in a loss of down. The only time penalties do result in loss of down are on intentional grounding calls.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.