User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America A Leagues > South America A #3 > Zeta Vs. Alpha Week 1 Take your Pick
Page:
 
Killer_Elite
offline
Link
 
lol.. its ok.. I guess its a complement.. you have to go to extream messures to get your team up to par to have a shot at us. I get it

I'm done crying.. time to do some playing. Good luck tomorrow.

As for this thread I see it 9-7 Alpha. Punata and Sao Paulo should lose.
 
PeeJJK
SM4LL
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Killer_Elite
lol.. its ok.. I guess its a complement.. you have to go to extream messures to get your team up to par to have a shot at us. I get it

I'm done crying.. time to do some playing. Good luck tomorrow.

As for this thread I see it 9-7 Alpha. Punata and Sao Paulo should lose.


Week 2....week 2.
 
rellascout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Butternuts
Originally posted by Killer_Elite

Ah he has the Cheater* Punata Primates with their 29 CB victorious.. nice.

*cheater assuming they play him of course

The Titans still get no respect Ah well whatcha gunna do.


please tell us how we are cheating.
we are going to play him, we paid for him and he is on our roster - if the trade isn't reversed he can't go back to his original team for 20 days remember. We're not sitting a player for 10 games, he's a victim as well and we're not planning on letting him go 10 games without exp. we may as well use him if he is on the team.
We have asked for the trade to be reversed, that's all we can do - we're not the bad guys here.
And i predict you're going to moan even more after rollover


The issue is that someone who was/is part of your organization cheated. By playing the guy you got from this deception is a furthering that cheating. It is condoning it and it is using it to your advantage.

That is how you are cheating. In the end you will do what you think is right but you are not taking the high ground here and your attempt to make it an arguement about the player is nothing more then a red herring. It detracts from the real issue which is that you acquired this player by cheating.

I will let it go at that. I don;t have a dog in the fight. I don't play you until late in the year. If you have not gotten that player back to his real team by then I will be disappointed but will not bring it up.

 
SCDurwood
offline
Link
 
I agree with the notion that you shouldn't punish the player for the actions of a manager....

...why should the player lose XP, money, and stats due to something beyond his control.

Unless you can prove the agent was involved with the scandal, the player should play without any restrictions.



Last edited Nov 12, 2008 07:59:49
 
rellascout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCDurwood
I agree with the notion that you shouldn't punish the player for the actions of a manager....

...why should the player lose XP, money, and stats due to something beyond his control.

Unless you can prove the agent was involved with the scandal, the player should play without any restrictions.





Why should a team benefit from a trade that was a fraud? Why do people continue with the Red Herring about the player will be hurt. If its all about the player then trade him to someone else for the exact amount of cash you paid.

Let the player choose the new team...

The rest of the its in the best interest of the player stuff is bullshit.
 
SCDurwood
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rellascout
Why should a team benefit from a trade that was a fraud? Why do people continue with the Red Herring about the player will be hurt. If its all about the player then trade him to someone else for the exact amount of cash you paid.

Let the player choose the new team...

The rest of the its in the best interest of the player stuff is bullshit.

Has any collusion been been proven on the part of the agent?

I'd be more than ticked if I got a message saying I was going to be benched until I found a adequate trade or another team to go to because someone on the staff wasn't playing nice...

That is an unrealistic expectation to ask of an agent who was not involved in the scandal.

It's not a red herring....it's closer to envy, or whatever biased motivation you may have, to even think an innocent bystander must be put through the ringer because of the idiocy of a manager.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Are you guys still going on about this?

Seriously? No...seriously?

There are still people in here who would bench the player though he did absolutely nothing wrong, just because he was traded to a team that wanted him?

Wow, my players must be loving the way I run the team by now if they are reading this BS.
 
Killer_Elite
offline
Link
 
I think we all settled on bumping the guy down the depth chart and having him play STs.. They have him at #1 on the depth chart at CB#1 and CB#2 so the guy will end up get like 80 plays.

Sure doesn't sound like they care that they had a GM who cheated to get him. Whatever it takes to win I guess.

It will be sad if after all this they still lose. Then they lose the game and their integrity.

 
Butternuts
offline
Link
 
The player is happy playing for us until the trade is reversed or 20 days if it isn't reversed. We don't need to find him a new team
 
Killer_Elite
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Butternuts
The player is happy playing for us until the trade is reversed or 20 days if it isn't reversed. We don't need to find him a new team


well congrats on cheating to get a player on your roster then. Well done.
 
rellascout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCDurwood
Originally posted by rellascout

Why should a team benefit from a trade that was a fraud? Why do people continue with the Red Herring about the player will be hurt. If its all about the player then trade him to someone else for the exact amount of cash you paid.

Let the player choose the new team...

The rest of the its in the best interest of the player stuff is bullshit.

Has any collusion been been proven on the part of the agent?

I'd be more than ticked if I got a message saying I was going to be benched until I found a adequate trade or another team to go to because someone on the staff wasn't playing nice...

That is an unrealistic expectation to ask of an agent who was not involved in the scandal.

It's not a red herring....it's closer to envy, or whatever biased motivation you may have, to even think an innocent bystander must be put through the ringer because of the idiocy of a manager.


I have no dog in the fight except that Punta is hiding behind the player. Its a complete red herring. They are trying to move focus of the real issue which is that their GM cheated and that by playing this guy they are continuing to cheat.

This would be so easy to fit if Punta wanted to. They would simply set up a trade with a 3rd party. Trade the effected player to a 3rd team for the exact amount of money they paid. Then that team would trade the player to the original team. The only negative effect for anyone would be a small chemistry hit. There are tons of teams that would be able to do this yet Punta has not attempted to get this done.

This is what a person of honor would do. IMHO. I know its just a silly online game but to me its sad that some people sell out their integrity over something so meaningless.
 
rellascout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Butternuts
The player is happy playing for us until the trade is reversed or 20 days if it isn't reversed. We don't need to find him a new team


So then you are directly benefiting from the cheating and should stop denying that you are cheating.
 
Butternuts
offline
Link
 
if we traded to another team, he'd still have to wait 20 days to get back to his original team.
he is happy playing for us, we're not going to let the player go 10 games without exp that would make the trade even worse for him. We've asked support to reverse the trade and we're not going to go and trade him to someone else just because you guys don't want to play against him.
If he didn't want to play for us, then yes, we'd trade him.

You can say we're cheating or have no integrity or whatever you want i don't care tbh, it would be worse on our part to refuse a player 10 games exp because you don't like the way we got him.
 
rellascout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Butternuts
if we traded to another team, he'd still have to wait 20 days to get back to his original team.
he is happy playing for us, we're not going to let the player go 10 games without exp that would make the trade even worse for him. We've asked support to reverse the trade and we're not going to go and trade him to someone else just because you guys don't want to play against him.
If he didn't want to play for us, then yes, we'd trade him.

You can say we're cheating or have no integrity or whatever you want i don't care tbh, it would be worse on our part to refuse a player 10 games exp because you don't like the way we got him.


So you will continue to benefit from the cheating. Live with the fact you are cheater. Quit denying the fact you have put your teams first before your integrity. If it was all about the player you would trade him for cash. Instead you will keep him. Its pretty sad.

I hope support pulls the guy back ASAP. I also hope that you trade him back if that does not happen ASAP.

P.S. I could give a crap if he is on your roster. I think its funny that you have sold out your integrity for this game. So sad...... I am done with this topic. You have made it perfectly clear what you are willing to do to win.
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 10:28:22
 
therichone
offline
Link
 
Caracas FTW!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.