User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Fumbles still a problem (jumping on it early this season)
Page:
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Unlucky rolls can be a bitch.
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
I haven't seen enough games, but it seems like fumbles might be up slightly and power backs seem to be somewhat effective again.

Now it could be coincidence, but I just remember back to S3 when Bort made a tweak to help break tackles. The next game we played the Boston Nighthawks and they fumbled 9 times, but they also had a lineman recover a fumble and break like 7 tackles for a TD.

If I had to guess at a non-conspiracy theory...people have run out of cheap SPD, AGIL, VIS, SA upgrades and blew their 3 boosts on STR/TAK.
 
Barnsie
offline
Link
 
I tried to keep the huge thread alive last season saying that fumbles were too high, and I'll certainly support it again this season. My Power HB, #1 RB, has fumbled 3 times so far in the first two games. Two of what will most likely be our easier games this season. He has 5 in Cover up, 48+ Carrying, and 87 Str. Average level in my league is probably around 29-31. He had basically this same set of attributes last season (I think maybe only 3 Cover Up then, we tried to keep fixing this), and he was fumbling way more then too.

I think fumbles should occur, but is it unrealistic to have your starting HB fumble every single game guaranteed? I'm specifically trying to work with my guys on it, but I really don't know what to do next. Confidence is being raised as well (currently around 30), but really...what else is there to do?

I realize that 3 fumbles in 2 games is a short sample of data, but I can go back to last season for my team's 2 HBs and I'll continue to update this thread as it continues to happen, as I'm sure it will. You can pretty much pick games at random though and see the large fumble numbers, and given that the vast majority of teams play on Wrap-up, why are there so many fumbles?
Last edited Nov 14, 2008 07:29:28
 
Link
 
i have a HB with 50 Carry and 62 agility who already has 4 fumbles in 2 games.
 
BartRock
offline
Link
 
You do realize that for every player like yours who has fumbled more than usual, there are a bunch of others who haven't fumbled at all, right?

You got an unlucky roll with the RNG, which made you fumble, which lowered your morale, which made you more likely to fumble again. Add that to the SS's possible good build, maybe on power tackling, and his Big Hit/Monster Hit SAs, mix it all up, and you don't need to be quite so unlucky to fumble a second time.

Neither of my team's power backs have fumbled yet against a better team and a fairly equal one and they carried it a ton. They got lucky draws from the RNG. Your guy didn't. That's all.
 
Barnsie
offline
Link
 
My guys get unlucky against the RNG all the time. And the entire last season. Wouldn't mind helping to skew the RNG in my favor by raising the appropriate attributes, but apparently I don't know what those are?

Also, I've played against quite a few guts that resulted in the same thing, eliminating things such as quality builds, etc from the equation.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Unlucky rolls can be a bitch.


This.

And this....

Originally posted by BartRock

You got an unlucky roll with the RNG, which made you fumble, which lowered your morale, which made you more likely to fumble again. Add that to the SS's possible good build, maybe on power tackling, and his Big Hit/Monster Hit SAs, mix it all up, and you don't need to be quite so unlucky to fumble a second time.

Neither of my team's power backs have fumbled yet against a better team and a fairly equal one and they carried it a ton. They got lucky draws from the RNG. Your guy didn't. That's all.


 
zook28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

Unlucky rolls can be a bitch.


This.

And this....

Originally posted by BartRock


You got an unlucky roll with the RNG, which made you fumble, which lowered your morale, which made you more likely to fumble again. Add that to the SS's possible good build, maybe on power tackling, and his Big Hit/Monster Hit SAs, mix it all up, and you don't need to be quite so unlucky to fumble a second time.

Neither of my team's power backs have fumbled yet against a better team and a fairly equal one and they carried it a ton. They got lucky draws from the RNG. Your guy didn't. That's all.




I honestly think that's 90% of what caused the fumble. Get the attributes to the 2:1 cap and then see what happens. I still can't believe that an offensive linemen returning punts and kicks isn't fumbling the ball though!

Checkmate, that's a tight avitar.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Aaaaand, 2 more. Against a team that we killed.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=224861

At least these were at the hand of an LB and NT. But they both seemed to come inside the 15 yard line, for some reason. Tons of my fumbles come down there, and I'm not sure why.

At this rate, Shizzle could break 20 fumbles on the season. Isn't that just a wee bit out of hand?
 
stryves
offline
Link
 
MrMoose, I'm sorry, but we are going to have to bench you.

I fumbled twice last game as well on my HB, but if I fumble 1 out of 50 carries, I'm cool with that.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
OK, only one game in, but I'm getting on this now as opposed to waiting. I'm not saying fumble forcing chance has been increased, but it seems something in the formula is causing fumbles TOO often.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=225016

My RB, Shizzle, had two fumbles. He has 87 strength, 40 carrying, 36 vision, 35 confidence, and 5 in cover up. If these fumbles were caused by an NT or DT, I could understand that, since they probably have highter strength and tackling compared to Shizzle's Strength and carrying. However...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=225016&pbp_id=1210939 -- an FS caused one.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=225016&pbp_id=1215707 -- SS caused the other.

Before people try to blame this on confidence, Shizzle had two plays, one for 4.5 yards and one for 5 yards before this. Even if someone had auta of intimidation along with other morale hitting SAs, Shizzle shouldn't have fumbled this early as a result of confidence. On the second one, his team just stopped a drive via a turnover on downs -- shouldn't that BOOST someone's confidence? Not to mention, he had a good game up to that point, running for nearly 6 YPC with 2 touchdowns.

Considering the positions that caused this and the speed they were running, I'm thinking the effect of speed on fumbles is far higher than it should be. I understand that collision speed could result in more fumbles, but wouldn't someone who knows they are about to be hit hard cover the ball up a bit? Can we please do something about fumbles before they get to be ridiculously excessive?

And to counter the argument I know I'll see -- I highly doubt adding on 8 more carrying (to softcap) would prevent these fumbles. Do you need 75 carrying to lower the rate to any sort of a realistic level? 80? More? This RB, on the team I own, fumbles less than my RB, and he has far less strength and cover up, with similar carrying: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=31567 . And he fumbles less in a tougher league, to boot.


In my experience, a powerback with these attributes will fumble a fair amount. Which I believe is working as intended...
Last edited Nov 19, 2008 14:18:50
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology


In my experience, a powerback with these attributes will fumble a fair amount. Which I believe is working as intended...


I'm running on combo, for one.

For two, I have running backso n the team I own, as I've said, with just a few more carrying who have NOT FUMBLED this season. 40 strength 40 carrying shouldn't lead to no fumbles while 82/40 leads to 6. I don't mind SOME fumbles, since, you know, it does add to realism. But, then again, wouldn't a back who knows he is running into people secure the ball? And why is it so horribly out of hand this season when I was hardly fumbling last season, even towards the end (when you'd expect more fumbles due to people having rounded out builds)?

Basically, if it is working as intended, why wasn't this happening last season, and why isn't it happening to backs with equivalent or worse stats related to holding on to the ball?

I'd understand them if they were against good teams constantly. But they're against teams we are beating soundly, more often than not. I'd also understand if they were caused by positions who generally have a high strength and tackling, but they seem to be coming from people who generally have low tackling and strength numbers, simply by virtue of collision speed. I could understand it if you're blindsided by one of these guys, but if you see a free safety getting a full head of steam before he nails you, you're going to secure the ball. Not sit there and just let him come pop it out.

I'll repeat -- I'm not saying I shouldn't fumble a bit more than average due to a slightly lower carrying stat. But even then, 5 or 6 carrying shouldn't be making such a large difference that I go from 6 fumbles to, say, 1 or 2. If it is, something is flawed with the way fumbles are determined.

EDIT: And, if build is at fault, why isn't my other RB fumbling at a similar rate?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=628770

He has had 1 fumble this season, with 62 strength and 33 carrying (same stamina as shizzle), and 1 in cover up. He only fumbled 3 times in over 200 carries last season with over 80 strength and slightly lower carrying (I moved gear in the offseason). He has only had 45ish carries this season, but only has 1 fumble. He is often playing teams that far outlevel him.

Is it possible that the cover up SA is not working at all?
Last edited Nov 19, 2008 19:00:43
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
The amount of fumbles occuring is way out of wack and the fact that many of the players with higher strength, carrying and cover up are the ones fumbling more is idiotic any way you slice it.

Additionally, the amount of fumbles occuring on special teams is equally out of wack imo.
 
Aaddron
offline
Link
 
I'd like to add: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=80741

With 52.66 carrying he has 10 fumbles so far this season.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
I have 2 fumbles, on 49 touches this season. This is with 84 strength, 49 carrying and 3 cover up.

Fumbles should happen, but the percentage should be aimed to mimic an average, based on the number of touches your player has (determined by their attributes). So, poor attributes should fumble every ~15-20 touches, while very good attributes should fumble every ~60+ touches (+/- the defensive players attributes/SAs).

I haven't had enough carries to make an accurate assessment though. I'll assume that it will balance out over the course of the season. 24.5 touches per fumble seems a bit too high for my attributes/SAs IMHO, it should be a little more like 35-40.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.