User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America A Leagues > South America A #3 > Punata... Why oh why would you do this???
Page:
 
Butternuts
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rellascout
Originally posted by Butternuts

Antonio Cromarite, the FS and backup HB.

Also, we have boosted??


You need to do the right thing and get him banned......


we have sent a message to support, it's in their hands now
i know battlemonkey said he wanted him banned in the message
 
rellascout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Butternuts
Originally posted by rellascout

Originally posted by Butternuts


Antonio Cromarite, the FS and backup HB.

Also, we have boosted??


You need to do the right thing and get him banned......


we have sent a message to support, it's in their hands now
i know battlemonkey said he wanted him banned in the message


I am glad that this was not your main peoples doing. This group is way too classy for that kind of dick move.......

They will hopefully take care of it. It sucks for you guys. I feel for you.
 
Killer_Elite
offline
Link
 
If you play the player you wrongfully acquired you are as guilty as the guy who wrongfully acquired him for you..

"Oh! My neighbor robbed a bank and gave me $50,000. I think I'll buy a new car."

hmmm. And yes many of the players on your team are 3 lvls higher today then when I was scouting your team yesterday. But thats ok.. its part of the game.
 
Killer_Elite
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Butternuts
Originally posted by Killer_Elite

I would hope that Punata will bench any player they wrongfully got for our regular season game tomorrow until the issue can be resolved by support.


well that player won't want to miss out on 1 (or more) games exp, that would be harsh on him to stop his players development because of this


How is this SA A#3s problem.. for the integrity of the league and for your own integrity he should be benched until your issue is resolved. if you need a corner, go get one the right way.
 
temujin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Killer_Elite
Originally posted by Butternuts

Originally posted by Killer_Elite


I would hope that Punata will bench any player they wrongfully got for our regular season game tomorrow until the issue can be resolved by support.


well that player won't want to miss out on 1 (or more) games exp, that would be harsh on him to stop his players development because of this


How is this SA A#3s problem.. for the integrity of the league and for your own integrity he should be benched until your issue is resolved. if you need a corner, go get one the right way.


you just dont want to play against the guy...don't bring up integrity of the league. as long as they are doing what they need to do to correct the situation then the player should not get punished for being a part of this.

-Mike
 
Killer_Elite
offline
Link
 
So the Titans have to face this player when nobody else does? you dont think this is an issue?

And no I dont want to play them with that player.. and we should't have to. They stole the player.. why should the team get to use stolen property to attempt to win a game? And in using that stolen player you dont think they are just as guilty as the guy who took him?
 
rellascout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by temujin83
Originally posted by Killer_Elite

Originally posted by Butternuts


Originally posted by Killer_Elite



I would hope that Punata will bench any player they wrongfully got for our regular season game tomorrow until the issue can be resolved by support.


well that player won't want to miss out on 1 (or more) games exp, that would be harsh on him to stop his players development because of this


How is this SA A#3s problem.. for the integrity of the league and for your own integrity he should be benched until your issue is resolved. if you need a corner, go get one the right way.


you just dont want to play against the guy...don't bring up integrity of the league. as long as they are doing what they need to do to correct the situation then the player should not get punished for being a part of this.

-Mike


I agree with killer. I do not think that this player has any place on the roster let alone playing in a game. If the Primates play him they have traded their integrity for a chance to win an fake online football game.

My personal integrity does not come so cheap.
 
temujin83
offline
Link
 
so both of your integrity is solidly intack and good with the actual player "stolen goods" not getting any pt/exp points and just getting shafted??? you both sit on a stool and ponder how that is fair?

-Mike
 
Killer_Elite
offline
Link
 
its not.. but that was the crime of the act.. and why the GM who did this should be banned. What you are saying is shift the penalty to the Titans.. why should we suffer from this?
 
oakland360
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Killer_Elite
So the Titans have to face this player when nobody else does? you dont think this is an issue?

And no I dont want to play them with that player.. and we should't have to. They stole the player.. why should the team get to use stolen property to attempt to win a game? And in using that stolen player you dont think they are just as guilty as the guy who took him?


While what the GM NayNay77 did is disgusting. You can't punish the player involved, unless he had prior knowledge of the deal and was okay with it. It's a bad situation all around.

Now I understand the Titans position because if they somehow loose the game, they're gonna feel cheated themselves. But the Primates don't play the guy, then they're hurting the player involved when it's not his fault.

A compromise is in order. I say that they should relegate the player to backup duties and special teams to get him playing time, but not start him. He should be like the 4th or 5th CB on the team only. Until the issue is resolved. Like I said before it's not his fault and to make him suffer is unjust.
 
Butternuts
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Killer_Elite
its not.. but that was the crime of the act.. and why the GM who did this should be banned. What you are saying is shift the penalty to the Titans.. why should we suffer from this?


one player man..ONE player
you just want us to play with 2 CB's?
 
oakland360
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by temujin83
so both of your integrity is solidly intack and good with the actual player "stolen goods" not getting any pt/exp points and just getting shafted??? you both sit on a stool and ponder how that is fair?

-Mike


It's not fair to anyone involved... but they can't sit there and call for an innocent bystander to be punished for doing nothing wrong. Now if he had anything to do with the trade himself, that would be a different story altogether.

Hell I'd gladly trade this 1st game with the Titans and play Punata, while they play United Evo... no one should get shafted on this.
Last edited Nov 10, 2008 15:22:19
 
Killer_Elite
offline
Link
 
its not just 1 player.. its a 29 CB.. thats a game changer
 
temujin83
offline
Link
 
i fully expect the titans to win with or without him playing but i think oaks idea is a good one, bumping him down on the depth chart and giving him special teams...

-Mike
 
temujin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oakland360
Originally posted by temujin83

so both of your integrity is solidly intack and good with the actual player "stolen goods" not getting any pt/exp points and just getting shafted??? you both sit on a stool and ponder how that is fair?

-Mike


It's not fair to anyone involved... but they can't sit there and call for an innocent bystander to be punished for doing nothing wrong. Now if he had anything to do with the trade himself, that would be a different story altogether.

Hell I'd gladly trade this 1st game with the Titans and play Punata, while they play United Evo... no one should get shafted on this.


and by the way HAHAHA of course we would trade that matchup...your a tool oak haha

-Mike
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.