User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > The RIGHT way to Handle Gutted/CPU/Slow Build Teams
Page:
 
the_legenol
offline
Link
 
seems like a well thought out suggestion. i like it. +++
 
Piggskin
offline
Link
 
Great suggestion, Cmonbrent. This sounds like a good framework.
 
Mason Tucker
offline
Link
 
No Gutted Teams, 300-0 games suck!
 
robinhoodnik
offline
Link
 
I like it. We don't need any league getting the garbage from the upper levels dumped on it's head.

The last two arrivals to S.E.Asia A #5 managed a combined 12-20 record against our league, and that includes games against our 9 weakest teams who combined for a 17-113 record, 22-123-1 if you include the 5 win team in Zeta.
Last edited Oct 27, 2008 20:32:02
 
CMON
offline
Link
 
Well I sent the PM to support. Hopefully it gets to Bort.

I really think he needs to rethink this re-org before it happens.

It's going to cause some unhappy campers..

Here is another thing to think about..............

Expansion/Caps

Problem # 1 -- So lets say Bort Drops all these teams to A or BBB level right now.... Well Canada BBB and Africa A will have L 21 Caps, but all others dont have a cap. Is that fair? no....

Problem # 2 -- So lets say all go to lowest League this season, then Bort decides to create a new league, lets call it Western Europe BBB. Well now all the Expansion teams are in BBB but the gutted teams are in A. What happens after 1 season. Will all those teams then instantly shift down? Or will BBB become the dumping ground after season 1?

Just be careful Bort... a lot of things to think about here.

I am sure I will come up with more on this later.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
This re-alignment is a license for everybody to manuever to the lowest levels and start over. 256 teams wouldn't begin to scratch the surface of the problem this offseason.

Lets just say there are gonna be a lot more higher level FA's this offseason than people are used to seeing - unless a lot of these players whose contracts are expiring on Day 40 are getting retired instead.

This offseason will be a mess.
 
CMON
offline
Link
 
maybe maybe not, as of now i think there are 140 CPU teams.....

But still..... there is going to be huge problems unless this re-org is addressed properly and yet no one will know what will happen until its done
 
ryanshaw
offline
Link
 
I have got to say I am also concerned - my team is lvl 16 capped and finished 5th, but after a good playoff run looks like we will get promoted. But the league above us is uncapped with an average level of 31. How are we meant to compete and why would we want to be promoted? Is the disparity not just going to get worse?
 
CMON
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryanshaw
I have got to say I am also concerned - my team is lvl 16 capped and finished 5th, but after a good playoff run looks like we will get promoted. But the league above us is uncapped with an average level of 31. How are we meant to compete and why would we want to be promoted? Is the disparity not just going to get worse?


I think thats a totally different problem but it is enhanced by this absolutely. Now there will be no cupcakes in that league you get promoted too. 3-4 wins and it is a success
 
georgewvu
offline
Link
 
Well i for one would like some thing done. I took over a team http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=681 this year and to be fair i gave each player the choice to stay or try and find another team. Well they all decided to leave. well that left me to take what i could and that was not much. so i had to make a few players my self got a few others to join then the rest was CPU's . Well when the season started i got killed and thats not the reason i bought a team to get killed by every one else. i don't want to go through another season like that and most of my players doesn't either as we where led to believe we where going to be put in a league equal to our overall LVL and if thats changed then that really suxs. What fun do i get and my players get out of going through another season like that. there is no reason that bort should make teams like my self and Teams 10 or more LVL's better then teams like mine to have to go through this again and if he does then thats sorry management on his part.now i am not putting Bort down he does a lot of good things to this game and is making it better by the seasons.but this is a major problem and it needs to be taken care of and not a try and put a dressing on it.i mean i just really started playing this game a season and a half ago but i am spending lots of money on it now and really love the concept of the game and where it is heading but till this is taken care of the game can't really reach its top potential with each league having any where from 4 to 8 maybe even 10 in some case's not being competitive.i am not going to quit playing but if i have to go through another season like this one again i will not spend the money to boost or any thing else to try and make the game more fun as it will be useless to do so when i have no chance to compete and make it fun. well this is just my thoughts but i feel a lot more players feel the same so go ahead and bash me for bitching about this but i truly believe that this needs to be taken care of!!
Last edited Oct 27, 2008 21:11:33
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
How do you balance the numbers? There doesn't seem to be a mechanism to ensure the number of average level 16+ teams exactly equal the number of gutted teams in the "regular" leagues.
 
skinzfan08
offline
Link
 
i like this suggestion, but i don't see it happening. if there are either not enough/too many each season...how's that going to work? i'd really like to see a whole "overhaul" aligning teams by average human level, with a stipulation for a team with 10 or 15 human high-level players, and the rest high-level CPU's. i GM a team in the Southeast Asia league that CMONBRENT speaks of. We are no top-seed contender, but even we had some cupcake games. we also got beat in most of our losses simply due to being outleveled because we kept our guys together after our league's first season, and didn't go get free agents. i'd really like to see realignment that makes everyone more competitive with the other teams in their league, then you really get to have fun, see who can put together the best gameplan. i give this a +51 for all the guys on our team's roster, lol.
Last edited Oct 27, 2008 21:41:59
 
pattybrhg
offline
Link
 
Honestly, I would love to agree, but I disagree with you in some major ways. There is no way you're ever going to get owners who would keep teams with a permanent level 13 cap.
I do think there should be some reshuffling to put the gutted teams all together, but I think it makes sense to just horizontally shuffle teams once they're all dropped. By horizontal shuffling, I mean you move all of the gutted teams into A leagues already in existence and just distribute them along AA pods evenly. This would make the most sense to me because the few players left on gutted teams would still be able to remain with their teams and not further complicate the problem.

The proposal as I've presented it would make it easier for gutted teams to recruit by being in a league full of other gutted teams with no one as viewed as the perennial cellar dweller.
 
sdavis
offline
Link
 
My only question to CMONBRENT is, If they do run with your suggestion is it an automated process or does someone manually go in and view each team and see if they should stay in their current league or drop to your new basically Garbage league ? Either way you will have some teams moved who would be unhappy with it and quit.

I can see the people with top teams in their leagues wanting something similar to this, but I can also see middle of the pack teams being concerned. If this is an automated process maybe a team who was promoted but didn't run out and buy a bunch of bigger guys can not really compete in their new league. They would then be dropped into your Garbage League.

Personally I think a better suggestion would be to have a a few different types of leagues based on how into the game the players want to be.

A hyper competitive league with people willing to go out and buy as many players as they can to try and guarantee a championship. Team owners who wished to only play the best teams in the league could ask to be put in it, and anyone below a 500 record would be dropped automatically at the end of the season.

A competitive league with people who want to have fun playing the game, no matter if they win or lose. But these people should want to spend time and money on the game.

A casual league for the players who occasionally want to login and check their players.
Last edited Oct 28, 2008 04:09:20
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
The practice of 'intentional relegation' comes to mind. Exploiters would sleaze their way into your DD league and then get there rocks off with easy wins. It's enough to make a person puke.

I feel Bort's idea of relegating to the bottom will be fine.

If you are in the bottom and hate playing all the demoted teams...work your tail of for promotion!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.